Batters That Matter

Batters That Matter Welcome to Batters That Matter. We specialize in delectable homemade gluten free baked goods. Some of our delicious creations are also dairy free or vegan.
(1)

We can't wait to excite your taste buds!

🚨 Tomorrow is the day! 🚨We're still busy in the kitchen baking up all the delicious treats for the MAD Gluten Free Festi...
06/06/2026

🚨 Tomorrow is the day! 🚨

We're still busy in the kitchen baking up all the delicious treats for the MAD Gluten Free Festival! 🧁🍪

📍 Breese Stevens Field, Madison, WI 📅 Sunday, June 7 ⏰ 3:00 PM – 6:00 PM

This round's muffin variety pack includes: 🫐 Blueberry 🌈 Fruity Pebbles 🍌🍫 Chocolate Banana 🍒 Cranberry Rhubarb Cardamom

And we'll also be bringing our newest creation...

🍟 COOKIE FRIES! 🍟

They are living up to their name because so much buttery goodness has baked into them that it actually "fried" its way through some of our packaging. True fry status. 😆

Now for the important question...

👇 Which item are you heading straight for tomorrow? 🫐 Blueberry Muffin 🌈 Fruity Pebbles Muffin 🍌🍫 Chocolate Banana Muffin 🍒 Cranberry Rhubarb Cardamom Muffin 🍟 Cookie Fries

Drop your answer in the comments and we'll see if our customers' favorites match up with yours! 💙

Our Fruity Pebble Cookies were a surprise hit at Maifest, so we're bringing them back for the MAD Gluten Free Festival! ...
06/05/2026

Our Fruity Pebble Cookies were a surprise hit at Maifest, so we're bringing them back for the MAD Gluten Free Festival! 🌈🍪

Made with our famous sugar cookie recipe, we've perfected the combination of a soft, chewy cookie, a sweet sugary crust, and the nostalgic crunch of Fruity Pebbles. They're colorful, delicious, and always disappear fast!

Be sure to grab one before they're gone. 👀

And don't go too far... we've got another cookie surprise coming your way soon that you won't want to miss! 😊

💙

💍✨ These cookies are ready for their wedding debut tomorrow, and we couldn't be more excited! 😍One of the biggest differ...
06/04/2026

💍✨ These cookies are ready for their wedding debut tomorrow, and we couldn't be more excited! 😍

One of the biggest differences between purchasing from a big-box store and a small business is freshness. Every order we create is baked fresh for your special occasion, giving you that homemade-with-love taste that makes every bite memorable. ❤️

Whether you're celebrating a wedding, baby shower, birthday, or another special milestone, we're honored to help make your day a little sweeter.

Don't hesitate to reach out and let us help bring your dessert vision to life! 🍪✨

💙

🎉 The MAD Gluten Free Festival is almost here! 🎉While Batters That Matter is known for our allergy-safe baked goods, we ...
06/04/2026

🎉 The MAD Gluten Free Festival is almost here! 🎉

While Batters That Matter is known for our allergy-safe baked goods, we also offer a variety of handcrafted items that make great gifts for the gluten-free and allergy community!

✨ Stop by our booth and check out:
🔑 Themed keychains
🍴 Cooking utensils
🪵 Cutting boards

Multiple styles and sizes will be available, so there's something for everyone!

📍 Breese Stevens Field – Madison, WI
📅 Sunday, June 7
⏰ 3:00 PM – 6:00 PM

We can't wait to see you there and share some of our favorite products with the gluten-free community!

💙

🏠 Guess who's home?!As amazing as this trip was, there really is no place like home.Being gluten free, I always enjoy tr...
06/02/2026

🏠 Guess who's home?!

As amazing as this trip was, there really is no place like home.

Being gluten free, I always enjoy traveling to the East Coast because it seems like everywhere has gluten-free options. It's fun getting to try new restaurants and foods without having to worry so much. What meant even more to me, though, was how thoughtful my extended family was throughout all the wedding festivities. While there weren't any gluten-free desserts (which was a little heartbreaking 😆), I was spoiled with gluten-free pizzas, salads, an incredible short rib dinner, and so many other delicious meals. It may seem like a small thing, but when people make the effort to include you, it means a lot.

Being away from my kids for the first time also taught me a few things:

🤣 My clumsiness reaches a whole new level when I'm on vacation (pretty sure I tore my hamstring).

🍹 I definitely can't drink like I'm 21 anymore.

❤️ No matter how much my kids test my patience some days, I missed them more than I ever expected. They are my whole world, and coming home to their hugs made everything feel complete again.

This getaway was something our family needed for a lot of different reasons, and I'm so grateful for the memories we made, the family we got to celebrate, and the chance to recharge a little. But I'm equally grateful to be back home, back in my kitchen, and back to doing what I love.

Now it's time to hit the ground running! We have a busy week ahead as we prepare for a wedding dessert table and the MAD Gluten Free Festival.

If you're in the Madison area, come see us Sunday, June 7th, from 3–6 PM at Breese Stevens Field. We'd love to see some familiar faces and meet some new ones too! 💙

💙

05/25/2026

How cool is this cake?!

Hello friends! 💙Just popping in before we fully disappear into family time mode 😀Our oven is officially BOOKED through J...
05/21/2026

Hello friends! 💙

Just popping in before we fully disappear into family time mode 😀

Our oven is officially BOOKED through June 9th, and honestly… we’re still trying to wrap our heads around that. Thank you for keeping this little bakery so busy and loved. Every order, comment, share, and visit means more than you know. 💙

While the bakery slows down for a bit, this momma has switched gears into prep mode 😂 So far we’ve tackled:
✨ Chex Mix
✨ Puppy Chow (or is it Muddy Buddies?!)

Seriously though… what do YOU call it? Because I feel like this debate is stronger than pineapple on pizza 🍍🤣

We’ll be a little radio silent the rest of the month while we soak up family time, reset, and maybe eat an unreasonable amount of gluten-free food. But before that…

Catch us at:
📍 MAD Gluten Free Festival
📍 Breese Stevens Field | Madison, WI
📅 Sunday, June 7
⏰ 3pm–6pm

We cannot wait to see all of your faces again soon. 💙

Holy cow!!! You guys really showed up and stuck around through the mini rain session. 🌧 We didn't grab much, and I am ve...
05/18/2026

Holy cow!!! You guys really showed up and stuck around through the mini rain session. 🌧 We didn't grab much, and I am very grateful for my little surprises too! 💙

We sold out completely of baked goods this year! Woot!! Our tangible items were a big hit and will return for MAD Gluten Free Festival.

In the meantime, I am finally going to settle down for some dinner.... and rest after the kids go to bed.

Thank you to everyone who came out and supported us through the day. 💙

We are all set up for Maifest at Lakefront Brewery! 💙Find our blue tent on the sidewalk by food truck alley from 10am-3p...
05/17/2026

We are all set up for Maifest at Lakefront Brewery! 💙
Find our blue tent on the sidewalk by food truck alley from 10am-3pm. Be sure to stop by and grab your favorite allergen-friendly treats while you’re there!

And don’t forget to support some of our amazing friends today:
✨ Waffle Blox — located at the far end of food truck row
✨ Devour Gluten Free — at the bottom of the grassy hill

See you soon! 💙

Tomorrow is the big day! 💙We are still wrapping up the night over here — lots of packaging left and then it’s time to lo...
05/17/2026

Tomorrow is the big day! 💙
We are still wrapping up the night over here — lots of packaging left and then it’s time to load up the car for Maifest! We can’t wait to see all of you tomorrow at Lakefront Brewery in Milwaukee from 10am–3pm.

A few things to remember:
💙 Look for our blue tent
🌿 We will be set up in the grassy area
🌧️ Rain or shine, we will be there
⏰ Come early if you have your eyes on something special

We’ll have fresh baked favorites, allergen-friendly goodies, and our fun tangible items from Checkered Edge Designs and JC Bless Your Heart Creations. See you tomorrow! 💙

05/15/2026

Muffin lovers, this one’s for you ✨

Our 4 Pack Variety Muffin lineup for Sunday includes:
🫐 Blueberry
🍋 Iced Lemon Poppy
🌿 Rhubarb Cardamom
🍫 Chocolate Banana

Perfect for sharing… or keeping all to yourself. We won’t judge. 😄

See you Sunday, May 17th
📍 Lakefront Brewery – Milwaukee, WI
⏰ 10am–3pm

Come early because these bakery favorites never last long! 💙

🌟 Today's To-Do List 🌟 Let the chaos begin.... right after I drop one kiddo off at school. 😜 Happy Fri-yay everyone!
05/15/2026

🌟 Today's To-Do List 🌟
Let the chaos begin.... right after I drop one kiddo off at school. 😜

Happy Fri-yay everyone!

Tiny but mighty 💙🔑As a keychain collector myself, I thought… what better way to create something small, fun, and meaning...
05/14/2026

Tiny but mighty 💙🔑

As a keychain collector myself, I thought… what better way to create something small, fun, and meaningful for our allergy community? These limited edition allergen-friendly keychains are officially here, and I am absolutely obsessed with how they turned out!

Huge shoutout to Checkered Edge Designs for bringing my vision to life with these custom creations. From gluten free life to vegan vibes and allergy humor, these were made with our community in mind.

Catch us this Sunday at Lakefront Brewery Maifest to snag yours before they’re gone! Limited quantities available. ✨

💙

🌟 Tangible item #1 drops tonight at 5pm🌟 In the meantime, take a look at these gorgeous Fruity Pebbles Cookie (DF).
05/14/2026

🌟 Tangible item #1 drops tonight at 5pm🌟

In the meantime, take a look at these gorgeous Fruity Pebbles Cookie (DF).

☀️Can you believe this picture was taken 16 years ago!? Back in my Scottsdale, AZ days life was filled with work, scho...
05/14/2026

☀️

Can you believe this picture was taken 16 years ago!? Back in my Scottsdale, AZ days life was filled with work, school, a little adventure, and lots of pool days! 🥂

It’s kind of crazy looking back and realizing that even all these years later, I’m still spending my time in the kitchen baking away. 😀 Sometimes the path changes, but the passion stays the same. 💙

05/14/2026

I may have underestimated just how BIG an 8x batch of S’more cookies would be… 😅🍪 The kitchen is officially in full chaos mode as we prep for Sunday’s Maifest at Lakefront Brewery.

This year we’ll be bringing:
✨ Famous S’more (V)
🌈 Fruity Pebbles (DF)
🍓 Strawberry Shortbread (GF & Egg Free)

But wait… there’s more 👀
We’ll also have some AWESOME allergy-designed tangible items available this year that you’re definitely going to want to sn**ch up. Keep an eye on our page tonight for a sneak peek!

Now let’s do a headcount ⬇️
Give this post a like or drop a comment if we’ll see you Sunday for a full day of “take all my money” gluten free festival vibes 😂💙

✨ Mark your calendars because Batters That Matter is hitting the road this spring & summer! ✨From Milwaukee to Madison t...
05/13/2026

✨ Mark your calendars because Batters That Matter is hitting the road this spring & summer! ✨

From Milwaukee to Madison to Kenosha, we are so excited to bring all the gluten free goodness your way 💙

🧁 Upcoming Events:
• May 17 — Lakefront Brewery Maifest
• June 7 — MAD Gluten Free Festival
• June 28 — Kenosha’s Women’s Market

⚠️ A few important updates:
• Bakery CLOSED May 22 – June 2 for family time
• June 2 – 8, our oven is fully booked

We cannot wait to see familiar faces, meet new customers, and keep serving up treats that matter most. Thank you for supporting our small business every step of the way 💙

Today is bakery shopping day! We can not wait to see everyone at Lakefront Brewery Maifest. You don't want to miss it!Th...
05/12/2026

Today is bakery shopping day! We can not wait to see everyone at Lakefront Brewery Maifest. You don't want to miss it!

This Sunday, May 17th- 10am-3pm.
You can find us under our blue tent with our most popular treats!

Be there or be square. 😆

05/11/2026

We need some help from our cookie crew 🍪💙

We already know our S’more Cookie is basically the fan favorite around here 😅 but we want to know…

What are YOUR top 3 favorite cookies from us? 👀

Drop them in the comments ⬇️
We’re curious to see which flavors are truly stealing your hearts!

Mom wanted pizza for dinner. I grabbed the crust from Woodman's freezer section and topped it with pepperoni, sweet saus...
05/10/2026

Mom wanted pizza for dinner. I grabbed the crust from Woodman's freezer section and topped it with pepperoni, sweet sausage and fresh mozzarella. 😋

What did you have for mother's day? 💙

Happy Mother’s Day to all the moms out there doing their best every single day 💙Motherhood is equal parts chaos, laughte...
05/10/2026

Happy Mother’s Day to all the moms out there doing their best every single day 💙

Motherhood is equal parts chaos, laughter, exhaustion, and unconditional love. My kids may test my patience daily, but they’re also the reason my heart is so full. My own little Sour Patch Kids — a little sour, a lot sweet, and definitely mine 😂

05/08/2026

💙Your words mean more than you know💙

Every message, comment, happy tear, and order reminds us why we started Batters That Matter in the first place — to create gluten-free treats that actually taste delicious and help people feel included again.

The first photo is filled with messages we’ve received from so many of you over time. Messages that have made us cry, smile, and keep pushing forward on the hard days.

The second photo shows our current Facebook recommendation score. When we first started out, we unfortunately experienced some trolling that hurt our ratings early on. As a small business, a few negative reviews can have a huge impact.

If we’ve ever made your birthday sweeter, helped with an allergy-friendly dessert, brought back a favorite treat you missed, or simply made your day a little better, we would be incredibly grateful if you’d leave us a recommendation or review on our page. 💙

At the end of the day, it’s your voices that help others trust us enough to give us a try.
Thank you for supporting our small business, believing in our mission, and allowing us to do what we love every single day. 🧁✨

💙

******SOLD OUT*****Let’s be real for a minute… the business guilt and mom guilt came blazing in.Sometimes it’s hard to a...
05/07/2026

******SOLD OUT*****
Let’s be real for a minute… the business guilt and mom guilt came blazing in.

Sometimes it’s hard to accept that it’s okay to put yourself and your family first when all you want to do is grow your dream business into the best it can be. I grew up believing family comes first — before work, friends, and even fun. 💙

So a while back, I decided I was going to fully take this weekend off to enjoy my kids and celebrate Mother’s Day myself. But I also couldn’t stop thinking about my gluten-free mom friends missing out on delicious homemade baked goods this weekend.

So here’s my tiny way of easing the guilt and spreading a little joy to some fellow mommas out there…

✨ We have just 8 Muffin Variety Boxes (GF/DF) available for $16 each! ✨

Each box includes:
🫐 Blueberry
🍊 Cranberry Orange
🍌 Chocolate Banana
🍎 Apple Streusel

Porch pickup is available tonight at 5pm, or arrangements can be made for tomorrow.
Send us a message to claim your box… or maybe two. 😉

Here's a reminder to slow down, hold onto your eggs, and don't toss them on the floor. 😂 We are all human, and mistakes ...
05/07/2026

Here's a reminder to slow down, hold onto your eggs, and don't toss them on the floor. 😂

We are all human, and mistakes are bound to happen. Although we lost an egg, don't worry because we have a tiny surprise coming up later. Stay tuned!

Happy Cinco de Mayo, amigo! 🌮✨We hope your food is as spicy as you like it,the chips and guac keep rolling, 🥑and your dr...
05/06/2026

Happy Cinco de Mayo, amigo! 🌮✨

We hope your food is as spicy as you like it,
the chips and guac keep rolling, 🥑
and your drink of choice stays perfectly ice cold! 🍹❄️

Here’s to good vibes, bold flavors, and celebrating the little things that bring us happy. 🌮

Share your Cinco de Mayo plates below. We love a good visual feast!

💙

Address

Kenosha, WI
53142

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Batters That Matter posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Batters That Matter:

Shortcuts

Share

Category