09/22/2026
FROM THE ARCHIVES 🗞📰📜
Adirondack Hotel & Colonial Arms
Built in the early 1820s, the Adirondack House was a beautiful hotel and tavern that sat on the site currently occupied by Walgreens.
In 1867 Royal C. Smith bought the property and named it the Adirondack Hotel. It burned in 1895 and was rebuilt as the prestigious New Adirondack Hotel. The dining room had a reputation locals compared to the Waldorf Astoria. In the 1880s the building also housed a bank; after one of the fires, the vault was all that remained standing.
In 1939 it was renamed The Colonial Arms. Over the years a famed horseshoe bar, indoor pool, and bowling alleys were added. It hosted names that still get repeated in town, including the Kennedy family and Marilyn Monroe. Separate fires in the 1970s took the bowling alley and pool; in 1977 the top two floors were lost.
The restaurant and bar survived that fire and ran until 1994, when the building was demolished and replaced with Rite Aid (now Walgreens). The developer reused the two original columns, some window parts, the hanging lamp, and a central gable—so a piece of the old portico is still on that corner.
More archival finds coming soon…