Baygulls Bakery

Directions Website Contact the restaurant

Baygulls Bakery 🥈 Voted #2 Best Bakery in Tampa Bay — 2026 Best of the Best
Handcrafted NY style bagels, boiled & baked daily. Coffee & pastries.

Serving the Tampa and Greater Tampa Bay Area.
Join the Flock and order online now at www.tampabaygulls.com

11/20/2026

Some things just aren’t meant to be shortcuts. 🥯

Every Baygulls bagel is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked fresh daily. No machines doing the rolling. No shortcuts. Just good old-fashioned bagel-making.

Because a real bagel deserves the real deal.

Tampa, come see how we roll. 🐦

📍10007 W. Hillsborough Ave

Schmear happens. We just make it from scratch. 🥯🐦Carrots shredded. Scallions chopped. Cucumbers diced. Peppers prepped. ...
11/19/2026

Schmear happens. We just make it from scratch. 🥯🐦

Carrots shredded. Scallions chopped. Cucumbers diced. Peppers prepped. All in-house, all by hand, all folded into one ridiculously good veggie schmear.

Because around here, we don’t just give a schmear. We give a damn.

Respect the schmear. 🥕🥒🫑

Five simple ingredients. These two hands. Thirty-six hours of patience. 🥯Every Baygulls bagel starts with King Arthur Ba...
11/13/2026

Five simple ingredients. These two hands. Thirty-six hours of patience. 🥯

Every Baygulls bagel starts with King Arthur Baking Company unbleached, unbromated flour, water, yeast, salt, and our sweet little secret: barley malt syrup.

The flavor goes beyond the toppings, too. Those jalapeños in our cheddar jalapeño? Mixed right into the dough.

Then we hand-roll, cold-ferment for 36 hours, kettle-boil, and bake. A whole lot happens before your first schmear.

All that care. In every bite.

Swipe to see how we roll. What’s your go-to Baygulls bagel? 👇

Your flock. Our baking. A Thanksgiving spread worth gobbling. 🦃🥯Thanksgiving preorders are LIVE! From pumpkin spice buns...
11/09/2026

Your flock. Our baking. A Thanksgiving spread worth gobbling. 🦃🥯

Thanksgiving preorders are LIVE! From pumpkin spice buns for breakfast to brioche dinner rolls and pumpkin cheesecake for the table, let Baygulls handle the baking. 🧡🩵

🗓️ Pickup: Wednesday, November 25
⏰ Order cutoff: Monday, November 23 at 12 PM

Choose from three pickup locations:

📍 Baygulls Bakery
10007 W. Hillsborough Ave.

📍 Three Brothers Palm Harbor
3436 Tampa Rd.

📍 Three Brothers Odessa
17777 Gunn Highway

Order at tampabaygulls.com (🔗 Link in bio) and select your pickup location!

What’s making it onto your Thanksgiving table? 👇

Thankful for this flock. And a bagel piled high with schmear. 🥯🍂Your November lineup has landed:🥓 Maple Bacon🎃 Pumpkin P...
11/07/2026

Thankful for this flock. And a bagel piled high with schmear. 🥯🍂

Your November lineup has landed:

🥓 Maple Bacon
🎃 Pumpkin Pie
🌿 Boursin
🍪 Biscoff

Plus two limited-edition bagels: Orange Cranberry is back, and our Stuffing Bagel is bringing Thanksgiving to breakfast. 🦃

Go sweet, go savory, or grab enough to avoid making decisions.

Available throughout November, while supplies last.

Build your combo in the comments: which bagel + which schmear? 👇

We call it The Gobbler for a reason. 🦃👀Your weekend plans just got gravy.Sliced turkey breast, creamy Boursin schmear, w...
11/07/2026

We call it The Gobbler for a reason. 🦃👀

Your weekend plans just got gravy.

Sliced turkey breast, creamy Boursin schmear, whole-berry cranberry sauce, and peppery arugula stacked on our stuffing-inspired bagel. Served with warm turkey gravy so you can dip it like you mean it. 🥯🔥

Feeling extra festive? Try it on our Orange Cranberry bagel for a sweet and savory holiday twist. 🍊

The Gobbler is available Saturdays & Sundays only throughout November!

We’re talking turkey all month—turkey bacon is also available throughout November! 🥓

Grab extra napkins. Tag your weekend bagel date. 👇

Flock, you get first pick from the fall pastry case… which one are you claiming? 👀🎃Swipe through, then drop your pick be...
10/24/2026

Flock, you get first pick from the fall pastry case… which one are you claiming? 👀🎃

Swipe through, then drop your pick below 👇

🌀 Pumpkin Spice Scroll
🍞 Pumpkin Bread
🧁 Pumpkin Muffin
🍪 Cinnamon Iced Pumpkin Sugar Cookie
☕ Chai & Pumpkin Cookie

Camera-shy but just as cozy: our Pumpkin Snickerdoodle and made-in-house Pumpkin Spice Syrup. Your iced coffee deserves sweater weather, too. 🍂🧊

Grab your coffee buddy and swoop into Baygulls. We’ve got a little fall waiting for you by the Bay. 🩵

SPOOKY SEASON HAS LANDED AT BAYGULLS. 🎃🥯👻October’s lineup is here and we may have gotten a little carried away…🎃 Pumpkin...
10/03/2026

SPOOKY SEASON HAS LANDED AT BAYGULLS. 🎃🥯👻

October’s lineup is here and we may have gotten a little carried away…

🎃 Pumpkin Spice Bagel
🍎 Apple Crumb Bagel
🧡 Pumpkin Patch Bagels — very limited quantities

🍪 Cookies & SCREAM Schmear
🎃 Pumpkin Spice Schmear
🍎 Caramel Apple Schmear
🌿 Sun-Dried Tomato & Basil — returning later this month for something special STAY TUNED 👀

☕ Apple C***r Chai
💜 The Jasper Special

PLUS two new house-made syrups: Pumpkin Spice + Toasted Marshmallow.

Available throughout October while supplies last. Come hungry. Come spooky. Come get schmear’d. 👻

Which October drop are you trying first? ⬇️

Address

10007 W Hillsbourgh Avenue
Tampa, FL
33635

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7am - 3pm
Wednesday 7am - 3pm
Thursday 7am - 3pm
Friday 7am - 3pm
Saturday 7am - 3pm
Sunday 7am - 3pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Baygulls Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Baygulls Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby restaurants