Coyle's Ice Cream

Coyle's Ice Cream The best homemade ice cream and cakes since 1985! Sit in one of our booths or at our soda fountain -
(504)

Islip Location - 509 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751 (indoor/outdoor seating)
Bay Shore Location - 75 Howells Rd., Bay Shore, NY 11706 (indoor)

05/31/2026

Our VEGAN Cookie Butter is now available in Islip! 🐄🍦

05/26/2026

Officially the best time of the year 🍨🌞🏖️ Plus, our Islip location officially has soft serve!

Our favorite time of year is almost here…our early summer hours will begin on Monday, May 25! 🌞🍦
05/23/2026

Our favorite time of year is almost here…our early summer hours will begin on Monday, May 25! 🌞🍦

Eating ice cream is science. Eating *homemade* ice cream is the difference🍦🧬🔬
05/20/2026

Eating ice cream is science. Eating *homemade* ice cream is the difference🍦🧬🔬

05/19/2026

We’re still blinking.

is next weekend so we’ve stocked up on our homemade novelties! 🇺🇸🍦- Cannolis: Cannoli Cream in a shell rolled in c...
05/17/2026

is next weekend so we’ve stocked up on our homemade novelties! 🇺🇸🍦

- Cannolis: Cannoli Cream in a shell rolled in chocolate chips
- S’mores: S’mores ice cream between two graham crackers dipped in a Belgian chocolate coat
- Chubby Chippers: Vanilla ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies rolled in chocolate chips
- Ice Cream Sandwiches: Vanilla or Chocolate soft serve ice cream betwen a crispy chocolate cookie

This Teacher Appreciation Week, Coyle’s donated ice cream to schools across Islip, Bay Shore, and Lindenhurst to celebra...
05/12/2026

This Teacher Appreciation Week, Coyle’s donated ice cream to schools across Islip, Bay Shore, and Lindenhurst to celebrate our educators’ patience, passion, and impact — our communities are better because of you 📝🌟🍦

05/07/2026

We’re not cutting back on the important things 🚗🍦

05/06/2026

Serving joy in every scoop and every slice🍦🎂

At Coyle’s, we handcraft every ice cream cake with locally sourced ingredients and homemade recipes because we believe that’s what your family deserves.

Birthday, graduation, anniversary, or just because — we’re here for all of it 🤍

Customer love 🍭🐾🍒🍦
05/05/2026

Customer love 🍭🐾🍒🍦

Address

75 Howells Road
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Monday 3pm - 10pm
Tuesday 12pm - 10pm
Wednesday 12pm - 10pm
Thursday 12pm - 10pm
Friday 12pm - 11pm
Saturday 12pm - 11pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Telephone

+16316662229

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Coyle's Ice Cream posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category