Papi’s Creamery

Home
United States
Yorktown, VA
Papi’s Creamery

Homemade ice cream, we make all of our elements from scratch. Creative and bold flavors.

06/03/2026

Cheeky!
_
Butterscotch ice cream with Guiness chocolate cake crumbs and a salted vanilla bean frosting.

Creamy, buttery, sweet, butterscotch ice cream, we make our own butterscotch sauce, which we then blend into our base and it makes for an amazing flavor 🤌🏼
_
Then we make a Guiness cake and crumble it into the pint. The Guiness elevates the chocolate flavor,
It gives it a lot more depth, which makes for a rich, chocolate forward, moist cake.
_
We’re big fan not adding salt elements into our ice cream. So we went with a salted vanilla bean frosting swirl. We used mexican vanilla bean, and add a generous dose of salt to make it a sweet and salty element that pairs really well with the other elements and contrasts the sweetness and richness of them.
_
Flavor drops Thursday 6/4 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in our bio.

06/02/2026

Salty Sailor
_
Sea salt ice cream with gooey caramel swirls and saltine toffee bark pieces (aka crack).
_
This is the flavor that we’ve gotten the most request to bring back n the last few months.
_
Sweet and salty flavors are among our favorites, the mix of the saltiness intertwined with the sweetness makes for amazing combinations.
_
We start by adding a generous amount of sea salt to our dairy. We aimed to keep a balanced profile, so it has a saltiness to it, but it’s not overly salty. Just enough.
_
Then we make our caramel, which y’all love, and add pools of it in our pints. The combination of the salt and caramel is already 🤌🏼🤌🏼🤤
_
But then we add saltine toffee pieces, which also have an element of salty and sweet to them. To all my sweet and salty peeps, this is a flavor you’ll want to try.
_
This flavor drops Thursday 6/4 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in our bio.

06/01/2026

Crumbs of passion
_
Ultra creamy cheesecake ice cream with chocolate-nutty Nutella swirls and ooey gooey red velvet cake pieces
_
If there’s a pint that will make you commit crumbs of passion this is the one.
_
You found your spouse secretly ate most of the pint. Let’s just say this might be the last ice cream they’ll ever get.
_
This pint drops Thursday 6/4 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in our bio.

05/28/2026

How to order
_
We’ve had a good amount of new people around here. Here’s the process on how to get pints and additional notes
_
Any question post it from en below or you can send us a DM

05/27/2026

Puff Daddy
_
Cocoa Puffs cereal milk ice cream with a malted fudge swirl and Reese’s puff cereal crunch.
_
As a kid I loved the feeling of having a bowl of chocolate cereal, finishing the cereal, being left with the “chocolate” cereal milk. I’d quickly drink it all, and not a single drop of it was wasted.
_
For this ice cream we steep Cocoa Puffs into our milk for 24+ hours, the goal is to try to get as much flavor steeped into the milk, so you get the same taste as drinking the cereal milk when you are eating it.
_
Then we made a rich malted chocolate fudge, we went light on the malt, but enough to give it old school diner vibes, and add richness to the pint.
_
Last we caramelized Reese’s puff cereal so it stays crunchy in the ice cream and you’re not stuck eating soggy cereal.
_
This pint drops tomorrow 5/28 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in our bio

05/26/2026

Yabba-Dabba-Doo
_
Fruity pebbles cereal milk ice cream with a white chocolate cheesecake swirl and fruity pebbles clusters.
_
This flavor tastes like childhood mornings, getting ready for school or starting the weekend. Getting all the energy needed to start the day with a good ol’ bowl of fruity pebbles cereal.
_
For the base we went with a light steep on the cereal milk so you get the fruity pebbles notes, the sweetness in milk, but the stronger fruity pebbles flavor comes from the fruity pebbles clusters.
_
Then we make a white chocolate cheesecake swirl, and add it throughout the pint. It brings some tangy notes to the pint and gives the pint depth in flavor.
_
This flavor drops Thursday 5/28 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in the bio.

05/25/2026

Monkey Roll
_
Brûlée banana ice cream with a lightly cinnamon spiced dulce de leche swirl and cinnamon bun cookie dough.
_
Banana bases are underrated. They usually get a bad wrap because many of them are made using flavoring, which doesn’t mimic the banana taste at all.
_
But when you use just straight up ripe bananas, and even better when you brûlée them before you make them into ice cream, it makes for an amazing flavor.
_
We made a homemade dulce de leche swirl, and add small amounts of cinnamon, so you get this beautiful Carmel/toffee-esque flavor with hints of cinnamon in each bite.
_
Last we make a cinnamon bun cookie dough and add it all throughout. It’s like getting little pieces of cinnamon roll mixed throughout your pint.
_
This flavor will be part of our drop this Thursday 5/28 . Link from the drop is in our bio.

05/19/2026

Dough you want S’more
_
Graham cracker ice cream with a torched marshmallow fluff swirl and cookie dough bites
_
S’mores is one of the most nostalgic desserts. There are so many memories of nights out by the fire, making s’mores, hanging out with family and/or friends.
_
We started this ice cream with a graham cracker base. Made by steeping tons of graham crackers into our ice cream, to give it the exact flavor you’d get if you’re eating the actual cookie.
_
Then we make our homemade marshmallow fluff and torch it to give it that smokey/lightly burnt flavor, like letting the marshmallows get toasty on the fire, and swirl it into our graham cracker ice cream.
_
For the chocolate portion, we went with soft chocolate chip cookie dough bites, which is another nostalgic and beloved food, and it works amazingly well as a pairing for this flavor.
_
This flavor drops Thursday 5/21 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in our bio.

05/18/2026

One mint stand
_
Silky dark-ish chocolate ice cream with a mint marshmallow fluff swirl and a Oreo cookie swirl
_
Toothpaste lovers rejoice, we got another flavor for you.
Jokes aside mint is growing on me… just don’t tell anyone.
_
The chocolate bring a rich, fudgy flavor to it, the mint marshmallow fluff comes in with a light sweetness and packing a fresh mint flavor that contrast so well with the chocolate.
_
Last the Oreo swirls bring a soft bite, that tastes like heaven.
_
This flavor drops Thursday 5/21 @ 7pm. Link for the drop is in our bio.

05/17/2026

What a turn out!!!
_
We had an incredible day yesterday, so many of you guys came out to celebrate our 3 years with us, and made our day.
_
I’m always amazed of the amount of love and support we get for you, thank you!
_
Big shoutout to the team, they work their butts off week in and week out, and without them we wouldn’t be able to have as much ice cream every week.
_
Another shoutout to , for celebrating with us!
_
And the biggest shoutout to all of you because without your support none of this would be possible.
_
To another year filled with ice cream and fun times

Address

2900 Hampton Highway, Suite O
Yorktown, VA
23693

Website

https://www.hotplate.com/papiscreamery

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Papi’s Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Papi’s Creamery:

Shortcuts

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Yorktown?