02/23/2026
Tonight, the very last Sicilian pie Gino’s will ever make found its way to the right hands.
We had posted that there were three left. By the time this gentleman walked in, there was only one. He said, “I know this is a long shot… but is there any chance you have a Sicilian pie available?”
It turns out it was a lucky long shot — because we had the very last one. And it was his.
He told us how he used to come here with his father after church when he was about six years old. Now here he was, holding his own child, taking home the final Sicilian pie ever made at Gino’s.
We asked him to come behind the counter and take one last photo with us. It felt right.
Unfortunately, in the moment, I didn’t get his name. If anyone knows him or can tag him, please do. I’d love for him to have this photo and see this memory.
Some moments just feel meant to be.
This was one of them.