Fitzy's Cafe

Fitzy's Cafe A Whitefish Bay Tradition
Open 8 AM - 8 PM
Kitchen closes at 4 PM

Happy National Coffee Day!☕️Celebrate with a taste of our exciting NEW Fall Menu at Fitzy’s Cafe! Enjoy a hot Apple Pie ...
09/29/2026

Happy National Coffee Day!☕️

Celebrate with a taste of our exciting NEW Fall Menu at Fitzy’s Cafe!

Enjoy a hot Apple Pie Latte or a cold Pumpkin Spice Latte, both perfect for the season. 🍎🎃

Stop by Fitzy’s today and celebrate National Coffee Day with us! 🤎

Fall is almost here at Fitzy’s Cafe! 🍐🍵Here’s a sneak peek at our new Pear Matcha, made for the season.Stay tuned for th...
09/18/2026

Fall is almost here at Fitzy’s Cafe! 🍐🍵

Here’s a sneak peek at our new Pear Matcha, made for the season.

Stay tuned for the full Fall Menu coming soon!

We’re thrilled to see Fitzy’s Cafe featured by Milwaukee Journal Sentinel!The Turkey Club was highlighted as one of thei...
09/15/2026

We’re thrilled to see Fitzy’s Cafe featured by Milwaukee Journal Sentinel!

The Turkey Club was highlighted as one of their new favorites, and we’re proud to see it getting some love.

Stop by Fitzy’s Cafe in Whitefish Bay and give it a try!

Read the full article here👇
https://www.jsonline.com/story/entertainment/dining/2026/09/10/more-great-milwaukee-sandwiches-dish/91680669007/?gnt-cfr=1&gca-cat=p&gca-uir=true&gca-epti=z117529p118750l115750c118750e1196xxv117529d--68--b--68--&gca-ft=9&gca-ds=sophi

Just here to remind you that chocolate counts as self-care. 🍫✨
09/13/2026

Just here to remind you that chocolate counts as self-care. 🍫✨

Happy Labor Day!Fitzy’s Cafe is closed today, Monday, September 7, in observance of the holiday.We hope everyone has a s...
09/07/2026

Happy Labor Day!

Fitzy’s Cafe is closed today, Monday, September 7, in observance of the holiday.

We hope everyone has a safe, relaxing, and enjoyable Labor Day!

Weekend mode activated 🐻💛😍
08/28/2026

Weekend mode activated 🐻💛😍

An iced latte is the perfect addition to your beach day! Stop by Fitzy's before your next beach day. 🐻🏖️💛
08/19/2026

An iced latte is the perfect addition to your beach day! Stop by Fitzy's before your next beach day. 🐻🏖️💛

08/19/2026

Need something refreshing?
Head on over to NSC member Fitzy's Cafe for a delicious pick me up to start your day off right!

learn more and see their menu at https://www.fitzyscafe.com

10/10 lineup 🐻💛
08/17/2026

10/10 lineup 🐻💛

On Saturday, August 15, Silver Spring Dr. will come alive with the Sounds of Summer Concert, presented by the Whitefish ...
08/12/2026

On Saturday, August 15, Silver Spring Dr. will come alive with the Sounds of Summer Concert, presented by the Whitefish Bay Civic Foundation.

🚧 Please Note: Silver Spring Dr. will be closed from Hollywood Blvd. to Santa Monica Blvd. beginning at 11:00 a.m.

🅿️ Visiting Fitzgerald Pharmacy or Fitzy's Café? Parking is available behind the building for your convenience.

If you're spending the evening enjoying the concert, stop by Fitzy's Café beforehand for a refreshing drink, coffee, sweet treat, or bite to eat before heading over!

Address

424 Silver Spring Drive
Whitefish Bay, WI
53217

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 8pm
Tuesday 8am - 8pm
Wednesday 8am - 8pm
Thursday 8am - 8pm
Friday 8am - 8pm
Saturday 8am - 8pm
Sunday 8am - 8pm

Telephone

+14143561424

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fitzy's Cafe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category