Primi Italian Steakhouse

Primi Italian Steakhouse Authentic Italian cuisine combined with dry aged prime steak and a stellar wine selection.
(585)

Primi Italian Steakhouse endeavors to deliver the premier steak experience in the heart of Long Islands Great South Bay. Located in West Islip, NY the bar area features soaring 25 foot ceilings and a cozy fireplace lounge. This handsome and spacious restaurant is designed to feel cozy and comfortable, where serving the highest quality ingredients is paramount. Their menu features Steaks that are U

SDA Prime and Dry-Aged for a minimum of 28 days and is rounded out with various poultry, meat, and fish, alongside classic and inventive pastas dishes, and unique spins on traditional Italian fare. Join us for a high-energy but luxurious dinner in any of our three dining areas or drop by the bar to watch the game and enjoy a more casual dining experience featuring a unique bar menu. Primi Italian Steakhouse is the perfect gathering space for small groups and parties up to 135.

The table is set.Celebrate Father’s Day at Primi.
06/19/2026

The table is set.

Celebrate Father’s Day at Primi.

Tomorrow night at Primi.Join us for our exclusive Steak & Cigar Dinner Series in partnership with South Shore Cigar Club...
06/17/2026

Tomorrow night at Primi.

Join us for our exclusive Steak & Cigar Dinner Series in partnership with South Shore Cigar Club .

Enjoy an evening featuring:
• Full Open Bar
• Four-Course Steak & Lobster Dinner
• Three Premium Ci**rs Throughout the Night

Thursday, June 18
6:30 PM – 9:30 PM
$250pp plus tax & gratuity

Can’t make tomorrow’s dinner? Additional dates are available:
• Thursday, July 16
• Thursday, September 10

The perfect pairing of fine dining, premium ci**rs, and great company.

Reservations: (631) 526-9779
Seating is limited.

**rs

This Father’s Day, let us take care of the details.Join us at Primi for a meal that celebrates Dad, a father figure, or ...
06/14/2026

This Father’s Day, let us take care of the details.
Join us at Primi for a meal that celebrates Dad, a father figure, or anyone deserving of a special seat at the table.

And if you’re looking for the perfect gift, our Steak & Cigar Dinner Series with South Shore Cigar Club begins Thursday, June 18..

Can’t make it on Sunday? Gift cards are always available and make the perfect way to enjoy Primi whenever the occasion calls for it.

See link in bio for details, reservations & gift card purchases.

steakhouse

Summer is sweeter at Primi.
06/13/2026

Summer is sweeter at Primi.

For the dads who appreciate a proper meal.Steaks, seafood, cocktails, and the perfect excuse to savour every moment at t...
06/09/2026

For the dads who appreciate a proper meal.

Steaks, seafood, cocktails, and the perfect excuse to savour every moment at the table.

Celebrate Father’s Day at Primi.

Some nights call for one more round.Espresso martinis, dinner at Primi, and a night that doesn’t need much else. ...
06/05/2026

Some nights call for one more round.

Espresso martinis, dinner at Primi, and a night that doesn’t need much else.

Layers of diced tuna, cucumber, mango, crispy wonton chips, shaved fennel salad, and spicy mango aioli.The Tuna Tower at...
06/03/2026

Layers of diced tuna, cucumber, mango, crispy wonton chips, shaved fennel salad, and spicy mango aioli.

The Tuna Tower at Primi.
A favorite for a reason.

Steak. Lobster. Ci**rs. Cocktails.Join us for an unforgettable evening at Primi in partnership with the South Shore Ciga...
06/01/2026

Steak. Lobster. Ci**rs. Cocktails.

Join us for an unforgettable evening at Primi in partnership with the South Shore Cigar Club.

The experience includes:• Full Open Bar• Four-Course Steak & Lobster Dinner• Three Premium Ci**rs

Thursday, June 18
Thursday, July 16
Thursday, September 10

6:30 PM – 9:30 PM
$250pp plus tax & gratuity

Makes a perfect Father’s Day gift!

Reservations: (631) 526-9779
Seating is limited.

**rs

Father’s Day at Primi.A proper table, a great bottle of wine, and no reason to rush dinner.Join us for steaks, Italian c...
05/26/2026

Father’s Day at Primi.
A proper table, a great bottle of wine, and no reason to rush dinner.

Join us for steaks, Italian classics Primi style, cocktails, and a night done right.

Address

999 Montauk Highway
West Islip, NY
11795

Opening Hours

Tuesday 5pm - 9pm
Wednesday 5pm - 9pm
Thursday 5pm - 9pm
Friday 5pm - 10pm
Saturday 5pm - 11pm
Sunday 4pm - 9pm

Telephone

+16315269779

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Primi Italian Steakhouse posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Primi Italian Steakhouse:

Shortcuts

Share

Category