Goodfellas Pizza, Wabash County, IN

Call Directions Website

Goodfellas Pizza, Wabash County, IN The only 18" pizza in Wabash We are locally owned and operated.
(211)

Goodfella's Pizza LLC provides convenient dining options to enjoy homemade pizza, wings, subs and more to the Wabash, IN and North Manchester, IN areas.

Sunday October 18 It is a GREAT DAY to be alive… this is for sure a FACT however on this day I was ummm urged?? Firmly n...
10/18/2026

Sunday October 18
It is a GREAT DAY to be alive… this is for sure a FACT however on this day I was ummm urged?? Firmly nudged ?? Nicely asked?!?? To start getting rid of things I don’t need ?!?!?! ……. Gasp… NEeD ?! NEED , you say?? I NEED it ALL!! What do you exactly mean?!?!
“Babe, you don’t need all of these blankets “….. a, a, a… yes I do . I like this one when I am sitting in that chair catching up on Facebook .. I like that one when I am over in that chair sitting and talking with one of my dearest friends … that one. Well I like that one when I am curled up on the couch reading or watching a movie .. and that one Dexter ( our dog) loves that one… “ babe ….. when was the last time you watched a movie or read a book???” Him staring at me with the look like , CANT wait for this answer! Meanwhile as I look at him I can already see him processing what he just said as he continues to look around. Oh my I am thinking!!!! Here it comes …. His wheels are really turning ( I am completely convinced I know exactly his next words !!!! and yep …… his mouth starts in again with… and ya let’s talk about alllllllll of the books you have and the dvds over there in that shelving thing…..
when will I ever learn? I should have just said. Yes , babe i absolutely should donate a few of these extra blankets!!!! So now …. I won’t just be purging blankets but also books and dvds🤷‍♀️. ( gasp) I better make the pile super big so he doesn’t start in about starting on the kitchen and why someone NEEDS every size pan times 4 in Every size!!!!! Sooooooo , Good Morning everyone it is a great day to be alive !😉and truth be told I have in fact accumulated a BIT ( ok , a metric ton ( is that ALOT? Sounds like ALOT )lol … of TO MUCH STUFF !!!
Anyway , I woke up .. I took a breath …. So , here is to another day I am blessed with !!
So what is on your agenda today?!??
Maybe lunch with family after church ?? We open at 11
Football ???? Place an order for pick up or delivery???
We are open today 11-8 we would love to become your GO -TO when ordering for pick up or delivery…
Me …. Well I guess I have a few things to start getting packed up to donate ?!?!?? 🤷‍♀️😉
We look forward to seeing you !!!
Be kind …... share a warm smile … encourage someone and remember you NEVER know what others are going thru.
Have a blessed day Food lovers and food consumers !!! 🍕🍕🍕🍕

🍕 PIZZA …. Give us a try … we will be open tomorrow Sunday October 18th. 11am -8 ( we would like to start staying open ...
10/18/2026

🍕 PIZZA …. Give us a try … we will be open tomorrow
Sunday October 18th. 11am -8 ( we would like to start staying open later if yall support the idea ).
Let me know what you think!!!
Thank you so much for such a wonderful day!!!
Prayers for anyone reading this who is having a tough time .. for whatever reason , just remember you matter and you are loved !!
Sleep tight don’t let the bed bugs bite!!! Oh and grab another blanket it’s pretty chilly ❄️❄️❄️
Nighty Night food lovers and food consumers 😉

10/17/2026

❄️❄️❄️❄️⛄️⛄️⛄️⛄️❄️❄️❄️❄️
Good Morning !!!!!!
Wakey Wakey grab a hankey … your nose is probably running because it’s so cold????
🥶
It is Saturday morning October 17,2026
And I am feeling bright eyed and bushy tailed… ( I tell myself this as soon as I wake up. )
I am grateful for another day!

What are your plans for the day??
I see leaves on the ground so are you starting the lawn clean up?? Are you having or going to garage sales .. the chili cook off??? ( we should have entered !!!!) Ughhhh next year !!! maybe a movie.
Lunch or dinner with friends ?
Well we will be here at Goodfellas 11am - 10 pm peeking out the steamed up windows eyes wide open anticipating your arrival ( yes it is HOTT in this kitchen 🔥🔥🔥🔥and cold outside hence the window situation )
The staff has been wanting so badly to have something fun for Halloween and because it IS on a Saturday and because it is our first Halloween here at the shop and because I love to see the creativity of the costumes and well because let’s be honest I LOVE CANDY!!!!!
(Who doesn’t , right? )
I think we are going to have a contest!!!!!
I really love the pumpkin decorating contests as well as the costumes !!!! But we only have a small space so I am not sure how we could do the pumpkin 🎃 contest
So how bout we do Costumes !!!!
Ok. I will make a post for it later today🎃🎃🎃🎃🎃. Prizes to be determined soon😉
By the way we had an amazing day yesterday. We are so delighted to meet all of you who have stopped by and given us a try if it be that you are customers who come every week to the ones who are coming back for the first time in a long time or you are totally new to us !!! We couldn’t be more happy to meet you.
We are still having growing pains ( expected) and have had a few hiccups but we really appreciate the kindness and grace you haven given us to correct our mistakes and learn from them and to keep striving to do better every day.
We always knew and know there will be things that go awry but we hope that we handle any situation that comes up with understanding and resolve on our end.
We care about what we serve you and your loved ones!!!
If you ordered 3 orders of Bosco sticks and it was typed in as 1 1/2
We are truly sorry and we want to make it right . As I have said the POS system is new and we are working out some issues . But we stand behind our product and I know our intent and hearts are in the right place .. so we will keep plugging away till we get the kinks worked out ( then there will be different ones. Isn’t that life😜😜😜😜)
So , if I haven’t won you over with these ridiculously winded rambles of mine …. Rest assured our food will 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️
We are working on a few new recipes to add to the mix soooooo stay tuned !!!!
Okey Dokey I guess I just want to say we are humbled and so thankful for each and every one of you!!! Thank you for your support your kind words your encouragement and your understanding… we look forward to seeing you again..
How bout tonight?????
We do have wings !!!!
We have Chili. … we have Spuds!!!
And yes. We have 🍕 ( giggle)
Make today the best day ever. Be a blessing to someone Be kind to a stranger . Offer a smile or a compliment, they are free 🥰
Hope to see you !!!!

10/16/2026

It’s Friday!!!!
Whooooo Hooooo
We haven’t slept much in the last month so we are a bit slap happy… so if you see me talking to myself then you know why.
Ok. Let’s see …. Well it sure seems to be starting off a bit chilly today …..however I am super happy about that … have you ever worked next to a pizza oven?!?! If so you understand my elation when I see a low of 45. High of 70 . I’d be thrilled if it said high of 55!!!
Anyway I am not a weatherman so why am I giving a weather report??? 🌞☁️🌦️🌤️⛈️❄️☃️⛄️🌪️☔️💦
So , let’s talk Subs??? You know sub sandwiches. . Yep we got em !
Ham and cheese
Turkey and cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch
BBQ chicken
Sausage green pepper sauce and cheese
Well any way you like really.
What I will tell you is that the Chicken Bacon Ranch is simply to die for!!!! Grab a bag of chips and a drink and you won’t be sorry !
And if you are feeling super adventurous ( ok not even a little adventurous.. just enjoy something sweet to top it off??? )
Try our raspberry cream cheese sticks!!!!! The thing that may actually be MY last nudge into REHAB … they are absolutely delicious!!!
We also have cheescake and strawberry cheesecake and dessert pizza and let’s not forget ,the little doughballs covered in cinnamon and sugar . The little pieces of heaven you can just pop in your mouth you know the they taste like the “ears “ from the fair sorta thing.. yep that is what I am talking about!!!
Also . I anticipate being very busy so if you know you will want an order tonight don’t hesitate to call early . We can delay till your expected time but it will give us a bit of cushion since my computer skills are so so so bad🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️
We appreciate the grace you have given us in our growing pain era ..
pizzas , subs, breadsticks and more … spuds even. Yep you read that right!!!!
Look to be honest we just really want that drive thru window being abused so come thru and get a sandwich drink and a dessert. Or just simply say hi. 👋
We now have monsters in the fridge !!!!! And Pepsi products. 🥤
See yall soon !!!!
Have a most perfect day!!! Stay Safe

PS. I’ll try and get pics today of the subs 🍕

10/16/2026

We are looking to hire….
Must be reliable and responsible
Flexible …. Fast learner comfortable in fast pace environment . HONEST , Team Player
Someone who Works well under pressure and knows what customer service means.
Bring your resume
To Goodfellas pizza or also can dm us.

Good Morning 🎶🎶🎶Good Morning 🎶🎶🎶🎶To YOU ( singing in the rain version )🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶Alrighty friends and neighbors Wakey wakey...
10/15/2026

Good Morning 🎶🎶🎶Good Morning 🎶🎶🎶🎶To YOU ( singing in the rain version )🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶
Alrighty friends and neighbors
Wakey wakey …..take a deep breath and a good long stretch ( did you snap crackle and pop like I just did 😳😳😳😳😳😳?????)
Yikes !!!!!
Well , it is Thursday October 15 and we’ll that means for some of you your work week is almost almost over 😎😎😎
For Knuckleheads like me there has never been a 9-5 ( awwww, that made me think of Dolly 😢)M- F (what have I been thinking all my life !!!!)
Again i digress…….
Ok so Thursday !!!! We are Gearing UP for it to be a busy Day … and BUSY WEEKEND. It is pizza and in my world that means everyday is 🍕day but especially Thursday-Saturday
I know the haunted house is going on this weekend and I have to check out what the plan is at the drive in…. And Honeywell ..
Eagles.. is the Farmers Market still going on?? What other events are happening in this bustling town this weekend??? Do Tell … help keep us informed ??? Oh the treasure Hunt at The Legion !!! It’s a bundle of 💰💰💰💰💰
And any group bike rides?
Are you going to Bass and Bucks by chance ( cool place cool people , just sayin)
Are the Jeepers doing anything or any Motorcycle rides……
Curious Minds would like to know 😉
Whatever your plans are why don’t you pencil ✏️ us in… before , after … in the middle ,at the end …. We will be here at 1118 Stitt St stretching Dough , you can count on that !
No need for you to cook or do dishes .. we will take care of that ( I mean at our place ! We can deliver your food ya know but we don’t deliver and come in and help with YOUR dishes just to clarify 😉😉😉 in case someone wants to sue for false advertising that is my disclaimer,
Okey Dokey Food lovers and Consumers I sure hope yall have a most perfect day! Be kind … smile it is free and can change someone else’s whole day!!!
Oh , and come see us. lol 😉🤪😂😉🤣🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕 🍝🍝🍝🍝🍝

Dine In
Carry Out
And
Delivery

260-569-1162

06/29/2026

Goodfellas Pizza will close at 9:00 PM on Saturday July 4th!! Enjoy our Firecracker Special..18” One Topping Pizza for $14!!
Have a Safe and Happy 4th!!!

06/24/2026

Just wanted to send out a THANK YOU, to SHARON MORGAN!! She found a delivery bag that had fallen from our vehicle, and returned it to our shop!! Thank you for being so honest!! There are so many good people in Wabash!!❤️🍕

Address

1118 Stitt Street
Wabash, IN
46992

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Telephone

+12605691162

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Goodfellas Pizza, Wabash County, IN posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category