Pop-Start Pizza

10/03/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

We’re crashing the party with this one.

📸 Pie-to-Try: “THE WEDDING CRASHER”
🍆 Baba Ganoush
🍅 Fire-Roasted Heirloom Tomato Sauce
🌶️ Charred Garden Peppers
🐑 Spicy Lamb Sausage
🧀 BelGioioso Ricotta Salata
🌿 Parsley
✨ Za’atar Spice

⚠️ Contains Sesame

This pie is showcasing a serious haul from our friends at Garden of Eaton.

We start with smoky charred eggplant purée as the base, then layer in fire-roasted heirloom tomatoes, charred garden peppers, spicy lamb sausage, salty ricotta salata, fresh parsley, and plenty of za’atar.

Smoky. Spicy. Bright. A little funky. Loaded with Middle Eastern-inspired flavors that’ll keep you guessing with every bite.

This is one of those pies that might make you question what pizza can be...

Then make you want to throw your hands in the air and shout about it. 🙌🍕

MA! THE PIZZA! 😂

🚨 ALSO — QUICK PSA: 🚨

Today may be your LAST DAY to grab the “Pray-Zay-All-Day.” 🍅🌿

If you’ve been meaning to get one more before it disappears from the board, consider this your warning.

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

WisconsinPizza

10/02/2026

🍕🎷 PIZZA PEOPLE 🎷🍕

Today we’re celebrating ONE YEAR of Sam at Pop-Start Pizza! 🎉🍕

So naturally, we made a pie for the occasion.

📸 Pie-to-Try: “ALL THAT JAZZ”
🔥 Spicy Tomato Sauce
🌭 Italian Sausage
🍄 Wild Mushrooms
🫒 Kalamata Olives
🤍 BelGioioso Stracciatella
⚫ Black Pepper
🧄 Fried Garlic
✨ Aged Balsamic Glaze

This one starts with Sam and his mom’s go-to pizza combo: sausage, olives & mushrooms.

He took their classic order and “jazzed” it up Pop-Start style with spicy tomato sauce, creamy stracciatella, fried garlic, black pepper, and a little aged balsamic to finish it off.

And the name goes a little deeper than just dressing up an old-school pizza combo. Chicago happens to be Sam and his mom’s favorite musical — so All That Jazz felt pretty damn perfect.

Sam’s been rocking with us for a full year now, and we’re lucky to have him as part of this weird little pizza crew.
So in honor of Sam...

🎶 Start the car...
We know a whoopee spot...
Where the drinks are cold,
But the pizza’s hot. 🍕🎷

Come grab All That Jazz and help us celebrate Sam’s Pop-Start anniversary!

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

WisconsinPizza

09/26/2026

🍕🇪🇸 PIZZA PEOPLE 🇪🇸🍕

Sometimes simple just hits different.

📸 Pie-to-Try: “THE INDIGO MONTOYA”
🍅 Garden of Eaton Heirloom Tomato Sauce
🐷 Speck Prosciutto
🧄 Garlic
🌿 Thyme
🔥 Pimentón
🫒 Olive Oil

Much like its namesake, this pie might look like a modest Spaniard — but there’s some serious precision behind the simplicity.

Locally grown heirloom tomatoes from Garden of Eaton create a fresh, bright tomato base, while smoky pimentón, speck prosciutto, garlic, thyme, and good olive oil do the rest.

Our riff on one of Spain’s simplest and most delicious tapas: pan con tomate — literally, tomato with bread.

No need to overthink it. Great tomatoes. Great crust. A few good ingredients. Done right.

Close your eyes, pretend you’re sitting somewhere in Spain, and pair it with a cold glass of Rabble Rosé.

🤌 Chef’s kiss.

Come check out The Indigo Montoya while it’s on the board.

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148

⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!
WisconsinPizza

09/19/2026

🍔🍕 PIZZA PEOPLE 🍕🍔

GUESS WHO’S BACK.

Y’all have been asking. Y’all have been waiting. And we finally gave in…

📸 Pie-to-Try: “SMASH MOUTH”
🧄 Garlic Cream
🍔 Seared Ground Beef
🧀 Henning’s Cheddar
🧅 Caramelized Onions
🥒 Dill Pickles
🌶️ Chopped Chilies
🔥 Burger Sauce
🌿 Chives & Dill

This one’s been a banger since its debut.

Our pizza-shop riff on a classic smash burger — beef, cheddar, pickles, onions, burger sauce and all the good stuff.

With the city celebrating Ethnic Fest today, consider this your little slice of Americana. 🇺🇸🍔🍕

AND WHILE WE’RE TALKING WISCONSIN…

One of our favorites officially earned its wings and graduated from Pie-to-Try to the EVERYDAY MENU.

“CURD FERGUSON”
🧄 Garlic Cream
🧄 Shaved Garlic
🫒 Roasted Garlic Oil
🧀 Henning’s Cheese Curds
🌿 House-Made Ranch Powder
🍋 Lemon
🌱 Fresh Herbs

Our riff on the Wisconsin institution that is fried cheese curds + ranch.

Fresh Henning’s curds, plenty of garlic, ranch powder, herbs and a hit of lemon — Wisconsin bar food through the Pop-Start lens.

And now you don’t have to wait for it to come back. Curd Ferguson is here to stay. 🧀🙌

We’ve got pies pulling inspiration from Wisconsin, New York, Italy, France, Mexico, Jamaica and just about anywhere else we can find something delicious.

So while you’re out celebrating today, come on in and plant your flag on whichever pie speaks to you. 🌎🍕

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148

⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

09/17/2026

🍕🇫🇷 PIZZA PEOPLE 🇮🇹🍕

FRANCE VS ITALY

Two countries. Two pies. One very unnecessary international showdown.

🥊 IN THE FRENCH CORNER…🇫🇷
📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “ZIGGY PIGGY”
🍄 Wild Mushroom Cream
🧀 Wood River Truffle Gruyere
🥓 Nueske’s Bacon
🐷 Prosciutto Cotto
🍄 Wild Mushrooms
🌿 Rosemary

Earthy, rich, and unapologetically decadent.
Wild mushrooms, truffle cheese, bacon, and ham come together for a pie that’s just French enough to have Napoleon himself polish off the whole thing.

🥊 AND IN THE ITALIAN CORNER…🇮🇹
📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try #2:
“ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED?”
🧀 Henning’s Black Garlic Black Pepper Cheddar
🟡 BelGioioso Parm
🐑 Pecorino
⚫ Black Pepper
🫒 Olive Oil

Our pizza riff on the Roman classic pasta Cacio e Pepe — literally, cheese and pepper.

It’s simple. Salty Pecorino, plenty of black pepper, good olive oil, and a little Pop-Start spin with Henning’s Black Garlic Black Pepper Cheddar.

This pie might not look like much…

BUT ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED?!

It can go toe-to-toe with any pie we throw into the arena. ⚔️🍕

🇫🇷 Ziggy Piggy vs. Are You Not Entertained? 🇮🇹

Come try ’em both and pick your side.

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148

⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

09/02/2026

🍕✨ PIZZA PEOPLE ✨🍕

Feeling a little fancy today?

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “FANCY ‘B’”
🧄 Garlic Cream
🐷 Mortadella
🧀 BelGioioso Mozz Mix
🤍 BelGioioso Stracciatella
🌿 Arugula
🌱 Basil
💚 Pistachios

Whether you’re a fan of Fancy Bologne… or it’s just because eating this pie makes you feel like a Fancy B — either way, this one’s an Italiano banger. 🇮🇹🤌

Creamy, salty, herby, a little nutty, and just fancy enough without taking itself too seriously.

Pinkies up. Grab a pie. Be fancy. 🍕🥂

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148

⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

08/29/2026

🍕🌧️ PIZZA PEOPLE 🌧️🍕

Fair rained out? Stay dry and get a pie.

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “Nuthin’ But A Bee Sting”
🌶️ Chipotle Garlic Cream
🥓 Nueske’s B**r Braised Bacon
🧀 Leon’s Bee Sting Cheddar
🌿 Green Onions
✨ Fennel Pollen
🍯 Hot Honey

Smoky, creamy, sweet, and spicy with just enough sting to keep things interesting.

If the weather killed your fair plans, we’ve still got you covered. Grab a table, call one in, order online, or get it delivered through DoorDash.

No poncho required. 🍕☔

🔥 Dine-In
📞 Call-In Orders
💻 Online Ordering
🚗 DoorDash Delivery
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148

⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

RainyDayPizza

08/28/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

Can't make it to the fair? We'll bring a little Farmer Fran to you.

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: "FARMER FRAN"
🌶️ Cajun Tomato Sauce
🌭 Andouille Sausage
🧀 Henning's Onion & Chive Cheddar
🍅 Heirloom Tomatoes
🫑 Roasted Peppers
🌿 Green Onions
🔥 Louisiana Hot Sauce

Our Louisiana-inspired pie is back on the board.

Smoky andouille, Cajun-spiced tomato sauce, local cheddar, fresh summer tomatoes, roasted peppers, and a hit of Louisiana hot sauce to finish it off.

If you want to get the farm without going to the fair, come grab one today.

This thing is slap-yo-mama good. 🔥🍕

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

PiesToTry

08/08/2026