First Date Coffee Shop

First Date Coffee Shop First Date Coffee is a cozy coffee shop in Toms River, NJ, serving specialty coffee, cold brews, refreshers, and sweet treats. Come sip, stay, and enjoy!

Inspired by the magic of first dates, we’re here to create memorable moments, one cup at a time.

WELCOME BACK TO HOGWARTS ⚡️Our September menu has officially arrived at First Date.We went all in on this one — house-ma...
09/01/2026

WELCOME BACK TO HOGWARTS ⚡️

Our September menu has officially arrived at First Date.

We went all in on this one — house-made syrups, ridiculous cold foams, a little magic, and an entire menu inspired by the wizarding world.

AND every Hogwarts drink comes with a scratch-off Sorting Hat sticker on your cup. Scratch it to reveal your Hogwarts house. 👀

No choosing. No cheating. The Sorting Hat has spoken.

Available starting TODAY for a limited time.

Okay… what house are you hoping for?

The easiest person to shop for? A coffee person. 🤍First Date Coffee Shop gift cards are available in shop perfect for bi...
08/26/2026

The easiest person to shop for? A coffee person. 🤍

First Date Coffee Shop gift cards are available in shop perfect for birthdays, thank-yous, teacher gifts, or just an excuse to treat someone to their next coffee date.

Because coffee is always a good gift.

08/22/2026

Our new neighbor!!! Can’t wait to try ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Your favorite First Date coffee, but at home ☕️We officially have bags of Lakes Coffee on the shelf! If you’ve ever aske...
08/22/2026

Your favorite First Date coffee, but at home ☕️

We officially have bags of Lakes Coffee on the shelf! If you’ve ever asked what beans we use behind the bar these are them.

Grab a bag on your next coffee date and bring a little First Date home with you. 🤍

Candle-making night is coming to First Date!Join us and Best Day Events by Jen on September 18th from 6–8 PM to create y...
08/20/2026

Candle-making night is coming to First Date!

Join us and Best Day Events by Jen on September 18th from 6–8 PM to create your own custom-scented candle while sipping on your favorite First Date drink.

Tickets are $50 and include:

Your handcrafted candle
All candle-making supplies
Step-by-step instruction
One First Date drink

Spots are limited, so grab your bestie and get your tickets before we sell out! Tickets are available through the link in our bio.

Address

11 C Washington Street
Toms River, NJ
08753

Opening Hours

Tuesday 8am - 3pm
Wednesday 8am - 3pm
Thursday 8am - 3pm
Friday 8am - 3pm
Saturday 8am - 2pm
Sunday 8am - 1pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when First Date Coffee Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to First Date Coffee Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category