Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant Joseph Compitello was born and raised in the Park Slope section of Brooklyn. Many of these dishes influenced him when starting Brooklyn's Finest.

Growing up in the 1960s he was surrounded by Italian eateries and delicatessens, and this is where his love of food began. From home cooked meals to eating at local restaurants he began to appreciate and understand good food. He frequented many local restaurants, and gained an appreciation for their unique home style dishes. What began as a dream, eventually became a reality when he opened in 2011. With a vast selection of local Brooklyn favorites on the menu, he brought the best of Brooklyn to Staten Island. From panelles, to egg creams, and everything in between all your Brooklyn favorites are here for you to enjoy.

There’s nothing like sharing our delicious pizza with friends or family. Experience comfort food made for good times and...
10/05/2026

There’s nothing like sharing our delicious pizza with friends or family. Experience comfort food made for good times and easy moments together. Secure your table now. 🍕

10/04/2026

Open 7 days a week and offering pick up, dine in and delivery. 718-815-7070 or on every major online ordering platform.

Game for something bold and tasty? 🍗 Our Buffalo Wings are perfectly fried, tossed in your choice of sauce, and served w...
10/02/2026

Game for something bold and tasty? 🍗 Our Buffalo Wings are perfectly fried, tossed in your choice of sauce, and served with a creamy dip. Grab a bite and enjoy every flavor!

10/02/2026

Friday is here!! Weekend is here!! Come and get yeast you’ve been craving. We got it all. From pizza, to pastas, entrees, heros, wraps and more. Don’t forget the fried Oreos and the apple c***r zepps. Check us out online or call 718-815-7070

10/01/2026

Fresh batch of our almost famous Apple C***r Zeppoles. Come check em out or give us a call 718-815-7070. They tend to sell out but don’t worry, fresh batches made daily!!

Nothing compares to the comfort of a cheesy slice with a golden crust and rich tomato sauce 🍕. Our Classic Round Cheese ...
09/29/2026

Nothing compares to the comfort of a cheesy slice with a golden crust and rich tomato sauce 🍕. Our Classic Round Cheese Pizza is always a crowd-pleaser. Try a slice for yourself!

09/29/2026

Come down to 1250 Hylan and check us out!! Pizza, pasta, specials, heros, wraps, desserts, and more!!
718-815-7070 and every major online ordering platform

Host your next birthday, bridal shower, or family reunion right in the heart of New York. Our venue is ready for your ce...
09/28/2026

Host your next birthday, bridal shower, or family reunion right in the heart of New York. Our venue is ready for your celebration and more. Contact us to plan your perfect event!

🎉🎈

09/28/2026

Have you tried our Apple C***r Zeppoles? We start with a pillowy batter that is both light and airy, add in freshly chopped Granny Smith apples, and we let them fry at a nice low heat so the apples get a melt in your mouth consistency. Dust em with a blend of cinnamon and sugar and they are ready to light your world on fire! Available by phone 718-815-7070

Grab a seat and treat yourself to a slice of our Classic Round Cheese Pizza 🍕—it’s all about that golden crust, melty ch...
09/27/2026

Grab a seat and treat yourself to a slice of our Classic Round Cheese Pizza 🍕—it’s all about that golden crust, melty cheese, and tangy sauce. What’s your favorite way to enjoy a classic cheese slice—plain or with your own special toppings? Let’s hear your must-haves! 🧂

09/27/2026

Don’t let a little rain ruin your football Sunday!! We got specials running all day long. Must call 718-815-7070 for these deals. Free Delivery when you order through us direct. We thank you for your support.

09/26/2026

Pizza, Pasta, Entrees, Wraps, Heros, Desserts and More. Whatever you’re craving, we got you covered!! Be sure to like and follow for more content and specials!! Thanks for all your support. 718-815-7070 and on every major online ordering platform.

We got deals for you all weekend long!! Don’t let a little bad weather cause you any worry. Brooklyns Finest has you cov...
09/25/2026

We got deals for you all weekend long!! Don’t let a little bad weather cause you any worry. Brooklyns Finest has you covered. Free delivery if you call. 718-815-7070

FALL IS HERE!! Nothing says fall quite like this. APPLE C***R ZEPPOLES!!! Fresh Granny Smith Apples, minced finely and m...
09/24/2026

FALL IS HERE!! Nothing says fall quite like this. APPLE C***R ZEPPOLES!!! Fresh Granny Smith Apples, minced finely and mixed into a freshly made zeppole batter. Then fried to perfection and dusted in cinnamon and sugar. Whoa baby this is CANT MISS!! 718-815-7070

Nothing hits the spot like a thick, cheesy slice with a golden crust and rich tomato sauce. 🍕 Classic flavors, hearty te...
09/23/2026

Nothing hits the spot like a thick, cheesy slice with a golden crust and rich tomato sauce. 🍕 Classic flavors, hearty texture, and real comfort in every bite. Try a piece for yourself!

Treat yourself to something special—come by for a slice of our Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza! 🍕 This pie is loaded with juic...
09/18/2026

Treat yourself to something special—come by for a slice of our Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza! 🍕 This pie is loaded with juicy chicken, crispy bacon, gooey mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, and a drizzle of ranch. What’s your go-to pizza topping you’d add to make it even better?! 🥓

BACK BY POPULAR DEMAND- Our Creamy Homestyle Mac& Cheese. Small shell pasta w/ housemaid creamy cheese sauce. This one a...
09/15/2026

BACK BY POPULAR DEMAND- Our Creamy Homestyle Mac& Cheese. Small shell pasta w/ housemaid creamy cheese sauce. This one always hits!!

Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese $7
Plain Mac & Cheese $6

718-815-7070

THE NFL IS BACK BABY!!! Celebrate and enjoy the games with some great food from Brooklyns Finest. Specials running durin...
09/09/2026

THE NFL IS BACK BABY!!! Celebrate and enjoy the games with some great food from Brooklyns Finest. Specials running during every NFL Game. 718-815-7070. Free Delivery.

Open till 10:30 tonight!! Serving up all the classics. Pizza, heros, wraps, pastas, salads and more. Don’t forget the FR...
09/07/2026

Open till 10:30 tonight!! Serving up all the classics. Pizza, heros, wraps, pastas, salads and more. Don’t forget the FRIED OREOS!!! 718-815-7070

Open ALL WEEKEND!!! We got you covered on all your food and delivery needs. Last minute? No problem. We cater WITHIN 2 h...
09/05/2026

Open ALL WEEKEND!!! We got you covered on all your food and delivery needs. Last minute? No problem. We cater WITHIN 2 hours!! MAKE SURE TO ASK ABOUT OUR SPECIAL!!
718-815-7070 and every major online ordering platform!!!

Friday baby!!! Sandwiches are going crazy today. We got FRESH FOCACCIA W/ Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce & Tomato w/ Fr...
09/04/2026

Friday baby!!! Sandwiches are going crazy today. We got FRESH FOCACCIA W/ Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce & Tomato w/ French dressing. $9
GARLIC KNOT SANDWICHES w/ choice of Chicken Parm or Chicken Vodka Parm or Chicken Cutlet w/ Roasted Pepper, Fresh Mozz and Balsamic Glaze. $9

718-815-7070
FREE DELIVERY

Catering for the home? We do thatCatering for work? We do that tooWhatever the need is, we got you covered! No catering ...
08/27/2026

Catering for the home? We do that
Catering for work? We do that too
Whatever the need is, we got you covered! No catering order too big or too small. Here we have a very affordable deal that CAN BE ORDERED LAST MINUTE!!! Ready within 2 hours
718-815-7070

PINWHEELS!!! On the counter today is everyone’s favorite. Who doesn’t love a good pinwheel huh? We’re featuring -Philly ...
08/22/2026

PINWHEELS!!! On the counter today is everyone’s favorite. Who doesn’t love a good pinwheel huh? We’re featuring
-Philly Cheesesteak
-Mac & Cheese
$5 each and limited quantities.
718-815-7070

08/14/2026

Friday baby! Weekend is here. We got all your pizza favorite and so much more!! Past, heros, wraps, we do it all!!
718-815-7070 and every major online ordering platform.

This week we’re featuring our famous Prosciutto Balls and now introducing SHRIMP TERIYAKI mini Riceballs. $2 each or $5 ...
08/13/2026

This week we’re featuring our famous Prosciutto Balls and now introducing SHRIMP TERIYAKI mini Riceballs. $2 each or $5 for 3. Available all week!!!
718-815-7070

Address

1250 Hylan Boulevard
Staten Island, NY
10305

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 10:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 10:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 10:30pm
Thursday 8am - 10:30pm
Friday 8am - 11pm
Saturday 8am - 11pm
Sunday 10:30am - 10:30pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category