Costello's Pizzeria

Costello's Pizzeria Costello's Pizzeria is located at 45 S New York Road in the Smithville section of Galloway Township.!

We are open year-round and offer Dine in, pick up & local deliveries orders.

🏈🦅 FOOTBALL IS BACK 🦅🏈The Eagles are back on the field tonight for preseason action against Baltimore! Kickoff is at 7 P...
08/15/2026

🏈🦅 FOOTBALL IS BACK 🦅🏈

The Eagles are back on the field tonight for preseason action against Baltimore! Kickoff is at 7 PM, so don’t wait until game time to think about dinner. 🍕🍗

📲 ORDER AHEAD and have your wings, tails, pizza, subs & more ready before kickoff!

Dine in • Pick up • Delivery

GO BIRDS! 🦅💚

🌽⚾ Baseball under the lights with a Field of Dreams feel!The Phillies take on the Twins TONIGHT at 7:30 PM ❤️⚾💙Make Cost...
08/13/2026

🌽⚾ Baseball under the lights with a Field of Dreams feel!

The Phillies take on the Twins TONIGHT at 7:30 PM ❤️⚾💙

Make Costello’s part of your game-day lineup with pizza, wings, tails, ears, subs & more! 🍕🔥

🚗 Pick up
🛵 Delivery
🍽️ Dine in

Good food, Phillies baseball & a summer night — sounds like a pretty good Thursday to us. 🌽⚾

PizzaAndWings

☀️ Nice weather calls for something fresh & simple!Our BLT Wrap is loaded with crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato & rosemary ...
08/12/2026

☀️ Nice weather calls for something fresh & simple!

Our BLT Wrap is loaded with crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato & rosemary mayo, all wrapped up in your choice of a flour or wheat tortilla. 🌯🥓🍅

Perfect for a beautiful day — grab one for dine-in, pickup or delivery! ☀️

Fresh, simple, and hits every time 🤌Arugula, fresh burrata, blistered tomatoes & a balsamic glaze stacked on a ciabatta ...
08/10/2026

Fresh, simple, and hits every time 🤌

Arugula, fresh burrata, blistered tomatoes & a balsamic glaze stacked on a ciabatta roll.
Go classic or level it up with a crispy chicken cutlet or eggplant 🔥

Pictured: with the cutlet 😮‍🔥

It’s FRIDAY! 🎉🍕🐔Kick off the weekend the Costello’s way! Whether you’re staying in, heading out, or grabbing dinner on t...
08/07/2026

It’s FRIDAY! 🎉🍕🐔

Kick off the weekend the Costello’s way! Whether you’re staying in, heading out, or grabbing dinner on the go, we’ve got you covered.

🚗 Pick up
🛵 Delivery
🍽️ Dine in

Pizza, wings, tails, subs & all your favorites are waiting. 🙌 Skip the cooking and let us handle Friday night dinner! ❤️💚

Fresh, simple, and loaded with flavor. 🇮🇹Our Chicken Cutlet, Burrata & Prosciutto Sub starts with a crispy chicken cutle...
08/05/2026

Fresh, simple, and loaded with flavor. 🇮🇹

Our Chicken Cutlet, Burrata & Prosciutto Sub starts with a crispy chicken cutlet on a fresh seeded Randos roll, layered with creamy burrata, prosciutto, and finished with a drizzle of sweet balsamic glaze.

One bite, and you’ll see why this one stands out from the rest. Stop in for dine-in, takeout, or delivery!

Glow up alert 🚨🐟Our homemade tuna salad just got an upgrade.Now mixed with celery, onions, salt & pepper for that perfec...
08/04/2026

Glow up alert 🚨🐟

Our homemade tuna salad just got an upgrade.
Now mixed with celery, onions, salt & pepper for that perfect crunch and flavor — not just tuna & mayo anymore.

Stacked on a fresh ciabatta roll and ready to hit 🤌

Two new ways to snack just dropped 👇🔥 Hot Veggie SamplerItalian mac n cheese bites, mozzarella sticks, fried zucchini & ...
08/01/2026

Two new ways to snack just dropped 👇

🔥 Hot Veggie Sampler
Italian mac n cheese bites, mozzarella sticks, fried zucchini & onion rings with vodka sauce

🥗 Cold Veggie Sampler
Blistered tomatoes, roasted red peppers, charred zucchini & eggplant with marinara & hummus

Hot or cold…what are you grabbing first?

Maybe we drove too slow in the passing lane? Maybe we took the wrong side in the Taylor Ham vs. Pork roll debate? Either...
08/01/2026

Maybe we drove too slow in the passing lane? Maybe we took the wrong side in the Taylor Ham vs. Pork roll debate? Either way, New Jersey told us to go “Fork off”.

Starting August 1st, New Jersey’s “Skip the Stuff Law” now requires the customer to specifically request plastic utensils, condiments, and/or napkins for all take out orders.

So if you order a salad and it doesn’t come with utensils, please don’t tell us to “Go Fork ourselves”. We are only trying our “forking best” to follow the new laws.

Back where it belongs… 🌿☀️The Smithville Salad has officially made its return to Smithville—and it’s everything you’ve b...
07/30/2026

Back where it belongs… 🌿☀️

The Smithville Salad has officially made its return to Smithville—and it’s everything you’ve been craving.

Mixed greens topped with chilled shrimp, crab meat, fresh avocado, juicy tomatoes & a sprinkle of Old Bay.

Light, refreshing, and perfect for a summer day. 🦐🥑

Address

45 South New York Road
Smithville, NJ
08205

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+16096520378

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Costello's Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Costello's Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category