Costello's Pizzeria

Costello's Pizzeria Costello's Pizzeria is located at 45 S New York Road in the Smithville section of Galloway Township.!

We are open year-round and offer Dine in, pick up & local deliveries orders.

🍂 Next stop: Oktoberfest… but first, Costello’s! 🍕🚌Heading to Oktoberfest in Smithville Village? The shuttle isn’t the o...
10/03/2026

🍂 Next stop: Oktoberfest… but first, Costello’s! 🍕🚌

Heading to Oktoberfest in Smithville Village? The shuttle isn’t the only thing worth stopping for! Find us right by the shuttle at 45 S New York Road—just a short ride from the festivities and ready to fuel your fall fun! 🙌

Our neighbors are part of the fun, too! Show some love to Bagel Port Cafe | Smithville NJ and Tap House Jiu-Jitsu , and stop by 12inchtails Cat Rescue charity event to support a great cause! 🐾❤️

Grab a bite before you hop aboard, or swing by after your festival adventures. A little detour, a lot of delicious! 🍕🍗

🩷 October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month 🩷Behind every pink ribbon is a person, a family, and a story deserving of lov...
10/02/2026

🩷 October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month 🩷

Behind every pink ribbon is a person, a family, and a story deserving of love and compassion.

To those facing a diagnosis, going through treatment, living with breast cancer, or navigating life after it, we’re thinking of you. To the caregivers and loved ones offering support, and those grieving someone they’ve lost, our hearts are with you, too.

From all of us at Costello’s in Smithville, The Nest, and Hammonton: you matter, your experience matters, and you deserve support through every part of it. There is no one way to feel, and you don’t have to be strong every day. 🩷

This October and beyond, let’s make room for listening, kindness, and showing up for one another.

🎉 Happy Friday, Smithville! It’s the LAST DAY to grab this week’s specials at Costello’s! Make your Friday delicious wit...
10/02/2026

🎉 Happy Friday, Smithville! It’s the LAST DAY to grab this week’s specials at Costello’s! Make your Friday delicious with:

🍕 Blackened Chicken Roasted Red Pepper Pizza — $13.99
🥗 Arugula Pineapple Bliss Salad — $13.99
🥖 Italian Beef Dip Sandwich with French Fries — $15.99
🍋 Chicken Francese over Penne — $15.99

Been eyeing something all week? Today’s your day! 🙌 Let us handle lunch or dinner before these specials wrap up tonight!

📲 Order for pickup, delivery or dine-in!
📍 45 S. New York Road, Smithville
☎️ 609-652-0378

⚾️ Game 3 tonight calls for a lineup of Costello’s favorites! 🔥Fuel your Phillies cheers with our tail tenders, Fuggedda...
10/01/2026

⚾️ Game 3 tonight calls for a lineup of Costello’s favorites! 🔥

Fuel your Phillies cheers with our tail tenders, Fuggeddaboudit pizza (pronounced “forget about it!” 😉), and buffalo chicken dip from Costello’s Smithville! 🍕🍗

🏈 Baseball on your mind, football deals on your plate—our football specials are available TODAY, too! Swipe to the last slide to check out the deals! ➡️

Order for pickup, delivery or dine-in and get your game-night spread ready before the Phillies take on the Braves at 8 PM! ❤️⚾️

LET’S GO PHILLIES! 🙌

🔥 Keep your week delicious with Costello’s Smithville weekly specials! Available Monday–Friday, these flavors deserve a ...
09/30/2026

🔥 Keep your week delicious with Costello’s Smithville weekly specials! Available Monday–Friday, these flavors deserve a spot in your lunch or dinner plans! 🤤

🍕 Blackened Chicken Roasted Red Pepper Pizza — $13.99
A 10” oil & garlic white pizza with blackened chicken, spinach & roasted red peppers, finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.

🥗 Arugula Pineapple Bliss Salad — $13.99
Spring mix & arugula topped with pineapple, dried cranberries, walnuts & blackened chicken, served with raspberry vinaigrette.

🥖 Italian Beef Dip Sandwich — $15.99
Slow-roasted Italian beef on ciabatta with frizzled onions, melted pepper jack & creamy horseradish, served with au jus & French fries.

🍝 Chicken Francese Pasta — $15.99
Lightly egg-battered chicken in a buttery white w**e, garlic & lemon sauce over penne.

There’s still time to find your favorite—or come back for another before Friday! 🙌

🚗 Order for pickup, delivery or dine-in!
📍 45 S. New York Road, Smithville
📞 609-652-0378

Monday Night Football calls for Costello’s! 🏈🍕🍗The Eagles take on the Bears tonight at 8:15, and our football specials a...
09/28/2026

Monday Night Football calls for Costello’s! 🏈🍕🍗

The Eagles take on the Bears tonight at 8:15, and our football specials are on for game day. Get your order in before kickoff, grab your favorites, and let us handle the food while you cheer on the Birds! 💚🦅

Order ahead for pickup or delivery. GO BIRDS!

Week 2 of our Smithville weekly specials is here! 🍕🥗🥪🍝This week’s lineup:🍕 Blackened Chicken Roasted Red Pepper Pizza — ...
09/28/2026

Week 2 of our Smithville weekly specials is here! 🍕🥗🥪🍝

This week’s lineup:
🍕 Blackened Chicken Roasted Red Pepper Pizza — $13.99
🥗 Arugula Pineapple Bliss Salad with blackened chicken — $13.99
🥪 Italian Beef Dip Sandwich with fries — $15.99
🍝 Chicken Francese over penne — $15.99

These specials are available Monday through Friday at our Smithville location. Come dine in, pick up your favorites, or have them delivered! Which one are you trying first? 👇

🦅🏈 FOOTBALL SUNDAY… BUT SOMETHING’S MISSING. 🏈🦅No Eagles today?! 😩💔 Football Sunday just doesn’t hit quite the same with...
09/27/2026

🦅🏈 FOOTBALL SUNDAY… BUT SOMETHING’S MISSING. 🏈🦅

No Eagles today?! 😩💔 Football Sunday just doesn’t hit quite the same without the Birds… but at least the FOOD can still show up. 😏🔥

Our Football Specials are available ALL DAY TODAY — so throw on the games, grab your crew and let Costello’s handle the game-day eats! 🍕🍗🍔

📲 Order for pickup or delivery
🍽️ Or come hang with us and dine in!

The Birds may have the day off… but your appetite doesn’t. 😂💚

🏈 GOOD FOOD. FOOTBALL ALL DAY. GO BIRDS ANYWAY. 🦅💚

Rainy day plans? Let Costello’s handle the food. ☔🍽️Stay cozy and order delivery, swing by for pickup, or come dine in w...
09/26/2026

Rainy day plans? Let Costello’s handle the food. ☔🍽️

Stay cozy and order delivery, swing by for pickup, or come dine in with us! The photos might make your decision a little harder: our Tail Tends, the Fuggeddaboudit (that’s “forget about it” 😉), and the Big Biff.

Which one are you ordering today? 👇

🌈 Calm before the storm… but there’s gold at the end of the rainbow. ✨ Happy Friday from Costello’s!
09/25/2026

🌈 Calm before the storm… but there’s gold at the end of the rainbow. ✨ Happy Friday from Costello’s!

Address

45 South New York Road
Smithville, NJ
08205

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 10pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+16096520378

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Costello's Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Costello's Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category