Tortuga Sandwich Shop

06/17/2026

Behold, The Chino, our Peruvian steak sandwich. Marinated sirloin steak, sautéed onions, cheese sauce, aji Amarillo mayo, fresh tomato salsa and crispy potato sticks on French bread.

06/16/2026

Meet the Ernesto. Braised shredded brisket, garlic aioli, provolone cheese, sautéed onions and crispy potato sticks all served on our French bread and breaded on our griddle until melted and crispy. Now available as part of our new menu. Come get one today!

06/13/2026

One of our most popular sandwiches is the Ybor. Mojo roast pork, smoked ham, Manchego cheese, dill pickles and dijonnaise on French bread and pressed until melted and crispy. Is it one of the best Cuban sandwiches in WNY?? That’s not for me to say..,but Yes

06/11/2026

I think it’s time for some new photos of all of our sandwiches.
This is The Fenix. Roast turkey breast, crispy bacon, Jack cheese, fresh avocado, pickled red onions, pickled jalapeño, chipotle mayo, jalapeño ranch and romaine lettuce on toasted ciabatta.

06/10/2026

Tortuga has a new menu!

06/06/2026

Today is the last day to get yourself our Loco Chicken Burrito. We are also going to have a new menu starting next week. We are open until 7pm today. See you soon!

06/02/2026

05/26/2026

This week’s special is The Clicker. Cheesesteak made from thinly sliced ribeye, caramelized onions, garlicky mushrooms, piquillo peppers, truffle aioli and Cooper sharp white cheese sauce. $20

05/20/2026

Thank you Step Out Buffalo !