Shut Your Cake Holes

10/05/2026

🧁🍭🍪🍩 HEY SUPERNATURAL FAMILY! 🍩🍪🍭🧁

Hi! 👋 I’m a cottage baker operating as Shut Your Cake Holes, and my cakesicle flavors are inspired by some of our favorite Supernatural characters! 👻🔪

I’m working on my menu for the Supernatural Convention in Chicago, November 6th–8th, and I NEED YOUR VOTE! 🗳️

I won’t be a vendor at the convention, but I WILL be taking preorders for anyone who wants to bring a little Supernatural-inspired sweetness along for the weekend! ❤️

Because let’s be honest… we ALL deserve a little sweet treat! 😈🍰

🏆 HELP ME NARROW THE MENU DOWN TO 4 CHARACTERS!

Copy the bracket, mark your choices, and let me know who YOU think deserves to make the final menu!

🍰 PRICING

💙 $4 each — individually wrapped

🎁 $15 Flight — one of each flavor, individually wrapped and presented in a gift box

🍭 $20 — 6 cakesicles — individually wrapped, mix & match 2 flavors

🍰 $40 — 12 cakesicles — individually wrapped, mix & match 4 flavors

And because apparently I have trouble making just a few cake pops… 😂 — I’ve included some examples of other Supernatural-inspired treats I’ve made!

So… who are you voting for?! 👀
Drop your picks in the comments and SHARE this post with your fellow SPN family! ❤️

10/03/2026

I’m a lazy poster on here. So go check out my Instagram page. I really need to figure out how to link all my socials 😂. Anyone local and not in the supernatural fandom is also welcome to vote!

09/27/2026

If was pie? What flavor would he be? 🍎🎃🍒?

08/16/2026

Sunday, August 16th 11am-8pm or sold out
Today’s proceeds will go to Kudzu Cat Alliance. Thanks to them, the orange tabby will be vetted and fixed! The stray kitten, now named Doby, will be fostered, vetted and fixed until we can find him a forever home. Contact me for adoption!

$4 each
$15 flights (one of each packaged in a box)
🍒Cherry
🍓🍋Strawberry Lemonade
🥜🫐 Peanut Butter/Blueberry Jelly
❤️‍🔥Cookie Butter
Overland Dr Powder Springs, Ga

08/11/2026

07/26/2026

Cake pop cart will be closed on Sunday July 26th
I still need to clear what’s left of my inventory!

Super deal of 6 cakesicles for $12!! That’s only $2 each!

Get a random grab bag or choose now!
Banana pudding
Fluffernutter
S’mores
Strawberry
Chocolate
Dubai chocolate
Fruity pebbles

DM to claim yours! They will be available for pickup starting tomorrow, Monday 7/27
4804 Overland Dr Powder Springs, Ga

07/25/2026

Full lineup today!
4804 Overland Dr Powder Springs, Ga
8am-8pm
Banana pudding
Fluffernutter
Dubai chocolate
Death by chocolate
Chocolate strawberry
Fruity pebbles
Red velvet
S’mores

Plus FREE candy bark with purchase!

07/24/2026

cart is out! Two new flavors! Fluffernutter and banana pudding!
4804 overland dr powder springs ga.

07/23/2026

The weather has been keeping me away but I’m back at it for the weekend! Starting off Thursday 7/23 11am-7pm with s’mores, fruity pebbles, red velvet and chocolate strawberry 4804 Overland Dr Powder Springs, Ga.
Cash, PayPal, cashapp and Zelle.
$4 each or 6 for $20

07/09/2026

🎉 CAKESICLE GIVEAWAY! 🎉

We’re celebrating with 3 chances to win! Complete all three entries to maximize your odds.

🥇 1st Place
✨ 1 dozen cakesicles in the flavor of your choice.
📦 Shipping included (U.S.) if needed.

🥈 2nd Place
✨ 1 dozen cakesicles in the flavor of your choice.
📍 Must be local for pickup or someone I can meet while traveling.

🥉 3rd Place
✨ ½ dozen surprise cakesicles (chosen by me!).
📍 Must be local for pickup or someone I can meet while traveling.

📣 How to Enter

Each completed platform = 1 entry (up to 3 entries total).

Instagram
✅ Follow Shut Your Cake Holes
✅ Like this post
✅ Tag 2 friends in the comments
✅ Tell me which flavor you’d choose if you win

Facebook
✅ Follow Shut Your Cake Holes
✅ Like this post
✅ Tag 2 friends in the comments
✅ Tell me which flavor you’d choose if you win

TikTok
✅ Follow Shut Your Cake Holes
✅ Like this post
✅ Tag 2 friends in the comments
✅ Tell me which flavor you’d choose if you win

📅 Contest ends July 18 at 11:59 PM ET.
🎉 Winners will be randomly selected and announced on July 19.

Rules
• Must be 18 or older or have parent/guardian permission.
• Tagged friends must be real people.
• Winners must respond within 48 hours or another winner may be selected.
• This giveaway is not sponsored, endorsed, administered by, or associated with Instagram, Facebook, or TikTok.

🍰 Good luck, and I can’t wait to see which flavors everyone picks!