Old Town Pizzeria

Old Town Pizzeria Located on Old Town Road in Port Jefferson Station NY we feature a pizzeria, casual in house dining, Welcome to Old Town Pizza!

Conveniently located in Port Jefferson Station, the D’Onofrio Family has provided top quality cuisine and exceptional service for over 25 years. This family owned and operated business features a delicious pizzeria, casual in house dining and catering for any occasion. Leave the cooking to us and “Buon Appetito”! At Old Town Pizza, we use only the finest ingredients as we craft our mouthwatering pizza, pasta and sides from traditional family recipes. Whether classics like cheese and pepperoni, or our customer favorites like Stuffed Meat or Tomato Basil, there’s something for everyone at Old Town Pizza! Come in and try our daily lunch specials, or give us a call to order for take-out and delivery. We also provide in –house or on location catering for events of all types and sizes! Visit our website for a full menu and coupons then stop by Old Town Pizza or one of our other three locations today! The D’Onofrio family will be honored to have you dine with us!

Stop By Today — There’s Something for Everyone at Old Town Pizza!From specialty slices and calzones to fresh rolls, sala...
10/01/2026

Stop By Today — There’s Something for Everyone at Old Town Pizza!

From specialty slices and calzones to fresh rolls, salads, pizza and daily specials, we’ve got plenty to choose from. Stop in and grab your favorites, or make dinner easy and let us bring it to you!

🚗 We Deliver
💻 Order Online: OldTownPizzaLI.com
📞 (631) 473-3712
📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station

09/29/2026

SO MANY DELICIOUS CHOICES!

Appetizers • Soups • Salads • Pizza • Pasta • Desserts

Fresh, hot & delicious at Old Town Pizzeria!

🌐 OldTownPizzaLI.com
Order Online • We Deliver

09/24/2026
What’s for dinner tonight? Make it easy with Old Town Pizzeria! Enjoy fresh pizza, pasta, heroes, specialty slices & mor...
09/23/2026

What’s for dinner tonight? Make it easy with Old Town Pizzeria! Enjoy fresh pizza, pasta, heroes, specialty slices & more — perfect for dinner, takeout or delivery. 🍕🚗

📞 (631) 473-3712
💻 Order Online:
OldTownPizzaLI.com

📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station, NY

Serving Port Jefferson Station, Port Jeff, Setauket, East Setauket, South Setauket, Centereach & Selden.

Always fresh, hot & delicious at Old Town Pizzeria! Order your favorites online and let us take care of dinner.📞 (631) 4...
09/19/2026

Always fresh, hot & delicious at Old Town Pizzeria! Order your favorites online and let us take care of dinner.

📞 (631) 473-3712
Order Online: OldTownPizzaLI.com⁠
📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station

LOOKING FOR GREAT PIZZA AND ITALIAN FOOD? 🍕Stop by Old Town Pizzeria and try one of our September specials. Fresh ingred...
09/16/2026

LOOKING FOR GREAT PIZZA AND ITALIAN FOOD? 🍕

Stop by Old Town Pizzeria and try one of our September specials. Fresh ingredients, delicious choices, and plenty of local favorites!

📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
📞 (631) 473-3712
OldTownPizzaLI.com⁠

Order Online • We Deliver

🍕 SEPTEMBER SPECIALS ARE HERE! 😋Stop by Old Town Pizzeria and enjoy something special this September! Try our fresh Ranc...
09/15/2026

🍕 SEPTEMBER SPECIALS ARE HERE! 😋

Stop by Old Town Pizzeria and enjoy something special this September! Try our fresh Ranchero Salad 🥗 and don’t forget dessert — the Black & White Cookie Cake is the perfect way to finish! 🍰

🍲 Chicken & Rice Soup
🍤 Bang Bang Shrimp
🌯 Meatball Burrata Italian Quesadilla
🍝 Septbre Primavera
🍗 Chicken Contadina
🍕 Chicken Pineapple Jalapeño Pizzette
🍔 Buffalo Soldier Burger

Order Online • We Deliver

📞 (631) 473-3712
📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jeff Station
🌐 OldTownPizzaLI.com

🍕 September Specials are here at Old Town Pizzeria! 😋There’s something for everyone this month! Stop in and try one—or t...
09/12/2026

🍕 September Specials are here at Old Town Pizzeria! 😋

There’s something for everyone this month! Stop in and try one—or two—of our September favorites:

🍲 Chicken & Rice Soup
🥗 Ranchero Salad
🍤 Bang Bang Shrimp
🌯 Meatball Burrata Italian Quesadilla
🍝 Septbre Primavera
🍗 Chicken Contadina
🍕 Chicken Pineapple Jalapeño Pizzette
🍔 Buffalo Soldier Burger
🍰 Black & White Cookie Cake

📞 (631) 473-3712
📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jeff Station
🌐 Order Online at OldTownPizzaLI.com⁠

We Deliver • Catering for All Occasions

🇺🇸 WE WILL NEVER FORGET 🇺🇸Today, Old Town Pizza remembers and honors the lives lost on September 11, 2001.We honor the b...
09/11/2026

🇺🇸 WE WILL NEVER FORGET 🇺🇸

Today, Old Town Pizza remembers and honors the lives lost on September 11, 2001.

We honor the bravery of the first responders, the strength of their families, and all those forever affected by that tragic day.

In remembrance. In honor. Never forgotten. 🇺🇸

— Old Town Pizza
Port Jefferson Station, NY

🍕📚 Back to School = Back to Busy!Make dinner easy with Old Town Pizzeria’s September Specials! Fresh, delicious choices ...
09/09/2026

🍕📚 Back to School = Back to Busy!

Make dinner easy with Old Town Pizzeria’s September Specials! Fresh, delicious choices the whole family can enjoy. 🍕🍝

📞 (631) 473-3712
🌐 Order Online at OldTownPizzaLI.com⁠

Order Online • We Deliver!

Address

691 Old Town Road
Port Jefferson Station, NY
11776

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 10pm
Tuesday 10am - 10pm
Wednesday 10am - 10pm
Thursday 10am - 10pm
Friday 10am - 10pm
Saturday 10am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Telephone

+16314733712

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old Town Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category