Old Town Pizzeria

Old Town Pizzeria Located on Old Town Road in Port Jefferson Station NY we feature a pizzeria, casual in house dining, Welcome to Old Town Pizza!

Conveniently located in Port Jefferson Station, the D’Onofrio Family has provided top quality cuisine and exceptional service for over 25 years. This family owned and operated business features a delicious pizzeria, casual in house dining and catering for any occasion. Leave the cooking to us and “Buon Appetito”! At Old Town Pizza, we use only the finest ingredients as we craft our mouthwatering p

izza, pasta and sides from traditional family recipes. Whether classics like cheese and pepperoni, or our customer favorites like Stuffed Meat or Tomato Basil, there’s something for everyone at Old Town Pizza! Come in and try our daily lunch specials, or give us a call to order for take-out and delivery. We also provide in –house or on location catering for events of all types and sizes! Visit our website for a full menu and coupons then stop by Old Town Pizza or one of our other three locations today! The D’Onofrio family will be honored to have you dine with us!

Friday is here — kick off the weekend with Old Town Pizzeria! 🍕🇮🇹Check out our August Specials and enjoy something diffe...
08/14/2026

Friday is here — kick off the weekend with Old Town Pizzeria! 🍕🇮🇹

Check out our August Specials and enjoy something different this weekend. Dine in, take out, or grab your Old Town favorites for the whole family!

📞 (631) 473-3712
📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
🌐 OldTownPizzaLI.com

08/13/2026

TWO OLD TOWN FAVORITES. ONE AMAZING PIE!

Grandma Burrata & Crispino 🔥🍅
Which side are you grabbing first?

📞 (631) 473-3712
📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
🌐 OldTownPizzaLI.com

☀️ Headed to the Beach or a Party?🎉No need to spend your weekend in the kitchen! Whether you’re headed to the beach, a b...
08/08/2026

☀️ Headed to the Beach or a Party?🎉

No need to spend your weekend in the kitchen! Whether you’re headed to the beach, a backyard BBQ, a family gathering, or a party, Old Town Pizzeria has the perfect solution.

From all your Italian favorites and handcrafted specialty pizzas to heroes, pasta, salads, appetizers, and catering trays, we’ll help make your weekend delicious and stress-free.

🏖️ Bringing something to the beach?
🎉 Need a dish for a party?
🍕 Let Old Town Pizzeria do the cooking!

📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
📞 (631) 473-3712
🌐 OldTownPizzaLI.com

🍕 Why choose one when you can have both?Treat yourself to the perfect combination of our Half Vodka Rita & Half Margheri...
08/05/2026

🍕 Why choose one when you can have both?

Treat yourself to the perfect combination of our Half Vodka Rita & Half Margherita Pizza—two incredible flavors on one pie! Fresh, handcrafted, and baked to perfection.

📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
📞 (631) 473-3712
🌐 oldtownpizzali.com

Order today for pickup, delivery, or dine in!

☔️ Rainy Mondays call for comfort food… and we’ve got you covered! 🍕Whether you’re craving our famous Deep Dish Vodka Pe...
08/03/2026

☔️ Rainy Mondays call for comfort food… and we’ve got you covered! 🍕

Whether you’re craving our famous Deep Dish Vodka Pepperoni Pesto or a sweet Nutella & Strawberry Pizzette, today is the perfect day to treat yourself.

📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
📞 (631) 473-3712
🌐 oldtownpizzali.com

Weekend Plans? We’ve Got the Food Covered! 🍕Skip the cooking and let Old Town Pizzeria cater your weekend gathering! Fro...
07/31/2026

Weekend Plans? We’ve Got the Food Covered! 🍕

Skip the cooking and let Old Town Pizzeria cater your weekend gathering! From appetizers, salads, specialty heroes, pizza trays, and pasta, we’ll make your party delicious and stress-free.

📞 (631) 473-3712
🌐 oldtownpizzali.com

🍕 JULY SPECIALS ARE ALMOST GONE…ONLY 4 DAYS LEFT! ⏰Don’t miss your chance to enjoy our delicious July Specials before th...
07/28/2026

🍕 JULY SPECIALS ARE ALMOST GONE…ONLY 4 DAYS LEFT! ⏰

Don’t miss your chance to enjoy our delicious July Specials before they’re gone!

Whether you’re dining in with family, grabbing takeout after work, or ordering delivery, Old Town Pizzeria has something everyone will love!

📍691 Old Town Road
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

📞 (631) 473-3712

🌐 Order Online:
OldTownPizzaLI.com

🍕 Sicilian Sunday Funday! 🍕There’s no better way to spend your Sunday than with a hot, fresh Sicilian pie! Thick, crispy...
07/26/2026

🍕 Sicilian Sunday Funday! 🍕

There’s no better way to spend your Sunday than with a hot, fresh Sicilian pie! Thick, crispy crust, homemade sauce, and plenty of melted mozzarella—made fresh and ready for you.

📍 691 Old Town Road, Port Jefferson Station
📞 (631) 473-3712

👉 Click the link to view our full menu and order online: OldTownPizzaLI.com

🍕

07/25/2026
FRESH, FLAVORFUL & MADE TO ORDER – CHECK OUT OUR JULY SPECIALS! Whether you’re stopping in for lunch, grabbing dinner fo...
07/22/2026

FRESH, FLAVORFUL & MADE TO ORDER – CHECK OUT OUR JULY SPECIALS!

Whether you’re stopping in for lunch, grabbing dinner for the family, or ordering delivery, our limited-time July Specials are packed with fresh, delicious flavors you won’t want to miss!

🌴 Appetizer of the Month
🥥 Coconut Shrimp – (6) coconut-battered shrimp served with Thai chili dipping sauce – $15.95

🥗 Salad of the Month
Spicy South West Caesar Salad – House-made chipotle Caesar dressing, chopped romaine, fire-roasted corn, black beans, blackened chicken, Cajun tortilla strips & cojita cheese.
Small $14.95 | Large $18.96

🍔 Burger of the Month
Guido Burger – Fresh mozzarella, crispy prosciutto, arugula, tomato & fig jam on a brioche bun, served with fries – $16.95

🌯 Handheld of the Month (Now available as a Wrap, Panini or Quesadilla!)
Honey Mustard Chicken – Crispy chicken, fries, bacon, melted cheddar mozzarella blend & honey mustard, served with house chips – $14.95

🍝 Pasta of the Month
Shrimp & Bacon Rigatoni – Shrimp, bacon, shallots & green peas in a light cream sauce – $19.95

🐟 Entrée of the Month
Flounder Francese – Egg-battered flounder in a lemon butter wine sauce – $21.95

🍕 Pizzette of the Month
Sweet Hot Honey Ricotta & Pepperoni – Our ultra-thin sourdough pizzette topped with pepperoni, whipped ricotta, hot honey & fresh basil – $17.95

📍 Dine In • Takeout • Delivery • Catering
📞 (631) 473-3712

👇 Check out all of our July Specials and make Old Town Pizzeria part of your Wednesday!

Address

691 Old Town Road
Port Jefferson Station, NY
11776

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 10pm
Tuesday 10am - 10pm
Wednesday 10am - 10pm
Thursday 10am - 10pm
Friday 10am - 10pm
Saturday 10am - 10pm
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Telephone

+16314733712

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old Town Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share