Benny's Brown Bag

Benny's Brown Bag Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Benny's Brown Bag, Sandwich shop, 1100 Elm Street, Peekskill, NY.

This one is only built for Cuban Linx, from the Deep South.You know we aren’t a bunch of trad chads, we gotta do some ro...
06/04/2026

This one is only built for Cuban Linx, from the Deep South.

You know we aren’t a bunch of trad chads, we gotta do some rocket surgery between the bread babies!

This week’s special is a certified heater, we marinated then slow smoked pork shoulder until our new kitchen staff Vega and Edward Scissorhands went BUCK shredding it. We also threw in some maple glazed smoked ham, pepper jack cheese instead of Swiss and disarrayed the typical mustard and pickle options (see below, I basically just told you everything going on here).

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“Down South Cubano”

• Slow Smoked Pork Shoulder
• Maple Glazed Smoked Ham (Sliced)
• Pepper Jack Cheese
• Sweet Pickled Pepper Relish
• Apple Compote Mustard With Chives
• Brick Pressed Butter Toasted 8” Hoagie Roll

WE CAN’T KEEP GETTING AWAY WITH IT!

📸

It’s not just a little bit of everything, it’s a lotta bit of everything!Here at Benny’s we run on dreams and mild panic...
05/28/2026

It’s not just a little bit of everything, it’s a lotta bit of everything!

Here at Benny’s we run on dreams and mild panic, so why not create chaos week after week.

Pulling from Italian flavors, this thing eats like a hefty salad in a sandwich with a light origin story, a real oxymoron!

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“Girl Dinner Fried Chicken”

• Marinated & Battered Fried Chicken Breast
• Genoa Salami
• Havarti Cheese
•Lemon-Basil Herb Mayo
•Tomato Marinated In: EVOO, Red Wine Vinegar, Confit Garlic, Italian Herbs
• Arugula
• Butter Toasted Large Brioche Roll

“Perfect” & “Meeeeee” both have seven letters, I don’t think this is a coincidence.

📸

OK YOU UNDERWATER BASKET WEAVERS!Benny’s is hiring for our back of house team, come ball so hard with a hilarious group ...
05/26/2026

OK YOU UNDERWATER BASKET WEAVERS!

Benny’s is hiring for our back of house team, come ball so hard with a hilarious group of chuckleheads you will want to pay US for our time!

Email us with a tidbit about yourself and a resume! C-Ya Next Summer! LYLAB!

Remember when the dog died at the end of Marley & Me? This is the total opposite!We took aim at the traditional pastrami...
05/22/2026

Remember when the dog died at the end of Marley & Me? This is the total opposite!

We took aim at the traditional pastrami reuben and made a few technical German tweaks to it (while yelling the entire time)!

Some revamps we did were: Reverse Russian Dressing - instead if it being ketchup forward it is Düsseldorf mustard heavy. We also butter braised the sauerkraut and cooked it down with dill and sweet heat pickles, oh mein Gott!

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“Düsseldork Pastrami”

• Pastrami Seared Hot
• Melted Havarti Cheese
• Düsseldorf Mustard “Reverse” Russian
• Butter Braised Krautsalat (Sauerkraut, Sweet Heat Pickles, Fresh Dill)
• Thick Cut Marble Rye

How many Germans do you need to change a lightbulb? One. They are efficient and have no humor.

📸

Joe mentioned that there were rumors about Drake getting a Brazilian Butt Lift years ago so our only course of action wa...
05/14/2026

Joe mentioned that there were rumors about Drake getting a Brazilian Butt Lift years ago so our only course of action was to make a sandwich around it!

Combining Brazilian and Canadian flavors (and a little champagne papi) we came up with what we think is a banger that even Kendrick couldn’t take down!

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“Drizzy’s BBL Brazilian Fried Chicken”

• Toasted Coconut / Panko Crusted Chicken Breast Marinated In Brazilian Spices
• Candied Jalapeños
• Peri Peri / Chipotle Mayo
• Champagne Vinegar / Maple Syrup / Chipotle Slaw
• Butter Toasted Large Brioche Bun

You can try to call us on our cell phone but the lines might be too busy to order this one. Bop on down!

📸

I warned you! No off-roading, I gave you enough chances!It’s Italian Combo season mangiapatates! That means we are back ...
05/08/2026

I warned you! No off-roading, I gave you enough chances!

It’s Italian Combo season mangiapatates! That means we are back with another obscure Sopranos sandwich!

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“Dave’s Scantino’s Polymarket Bets”

• Hot Coppa
• Mortadella (Nut-Free)
• Spicy Soppressata
• Genoa Salami
• Fresh Mozzarella
• Sweet & Sour Sicilian Caponata (Roasted Eggplant, Peppers, Capers, Olives)
• Preserved Lemon / Basil Mayo
• Arugula
• Balsamic Glaze
• Butter Toasted 10” Seeded Italian Hero

Don’t drive your SUV onto a field to drop off some cheerleaders.

📸

Vietnam, Japan, China, PEEKSKILL - What do they all have in common? Delectable tastes of Asia!We are bringing you a spec...
05/02/2026

Vietnam, Japan, China, PEEKSKILL - What do they all have in common? Delectable tastes of Asia!

We are bringing you a special banh mi? this week that combines a wackadoo array of Asian flavors.

Chaos.

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“BBQ PULLED PORK BANH MI”

• Japanese BBQ Marinated Pork Should Smoked For 8 Hours
• House Pickled Daikon & Carrot
• Chinese Style Spicy Chili & Soy Aioli
• Vietnamese Nuoc Cham Sauce
• Cilantro & Scallion Garnish
• Butter Toasted 8” Hoagie Roll

2000s Pan Asian fusion is back!

📸

It tastes like….RIGHT BY THE BEACH…boy!We are back with version 3.0 of Miss Cleo and it might be the best one yet. We we...
04/26/2026

It tastes like….RIGHT BY THE BEACH…boy!

We are back with version 3.0 of Miss Cleo and it might be the best one yet. We went full authentic marinating chicken thighs in house made scotch bonnet jerk for 24 hours then smoking it with pimento wood.

You deserve this sandwich, so take it. You’re gonna love it.

SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“Miss Cleo Jerk Chicken”

• Jerk Marinated Chicken Thighs Smoked With Pimento Wood
• Ting Reduction Pineapple / Jalapeño Slaw
• Butter Toasted Ciabatta Long Roll

If I wasn’t Jamaican, then why would I wear this hat? Huh.

📸

SPRING MENU IS BACK BABIES. 4 FAVORITES HAVE REPLACED 4 OF YOUR OTHER FAVORITES. Welcome Back:• Chimi Chimi Ya Roast Bee...
04/15/2026

SPRING MENU IS BACK BABIES. 4 FAVORITES HAVE REPLACED 4 OF YOUR OTHER FAVORITES.

Welcome Back:

• Chimi Chimi Ya Roast Beef
• Green Goddess Chicken BLT
• Bloomin’ Onion Roast Beef
• Thai Fried Chicken

Q2 is lookin pretty good!

Mixing up the mess while messing up the mix!Spring is almost upon us, so that means things are a changing around these p...
04/09/2026

Mixing up the mess while messing up the mix!

Spring is almost upon us, so that means things are a changing around these parts.

It’s your last week to get your winter favorites before the menu flips to something very demure, very mindful, very cutesy.

NO SPECIAL SPECIAL SPECIAL!

“LAST WEEK FOR”

• Fox Choker Fried Chicken
• Chicken Curry Toyotathon
• Bear Mountain Roast Beef
• ODB Roast Beef

Don’t get all heated in the comments, Leave Benny Alone.

Address

1100 Elm Street
Peekskill, NY
10566

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 5pm
Wednesday 11am - 5pm
Thursday 11am - 5pm
Friday 11am - 5pm
Saturday 11am - 5pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Benny's Brown Bag posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category