The Supper Club

The Supper Club Welcome to the The Supper Club page!

We're a group of lifelong friends who come together each month to celebrate the joy of friendship, delicious food, and memorable times.

Despite a suspiciously timed illness from our host, the dinner went on as scheduled. Through a combination of modern tec...
06/01/2026

Despite a suspiciously timed illness from our host, the dinner went on as scheduled. Through a combination of modern technology and what some are calling unethical photojournalism, Matty was still able to make the official picture.

We also had a chance encounter with Supper Club Fan Club President Lisa Mason, proving once again that this organization somehow has fans.

The food was excellent, the wine was flowing, and every member spent the evening fighting a slow but steady slide toward the center of the table.

All hail the Supper Club!

Not saying this is a Time Magazine “People of the Year” cover……but we’re also not saying it’s not.13 members in attendan...
04/26/2026

Not saying this is a Time Magazine “People of the Year” cover…
…but we’re also not saying it’s not.

13 members in attendance — full strength, no excuses. A showing that deserves recognition.

Great food, strong drinks, and a group of men who, with the right lighting, look like they’re making global decisions… or at the very least deciding what bottle gets ordered next.

If nothing else, this photo proves one thing — when we show up like this, we don’t just attend… we make it look important.

All Hail The Supper Club

Happy Easter from The Supper ClubThe table’s been set for centuries… we just upgraded the menu.All Hail. 🐰
04/05/2026

Happy Easter from The Supper Club

The table’s been set for centuries… we just upgraded the menu.

All Hail. 🐰

There comes a time when you stop just enjoying the tradition… and start creating it.This past weekend, The Supper Club o...
03/22/2026

There comes a time when you stop just enjoying the tradition… and start creating it.

This past weekend, The Supper Club officially began the process of making our own wine. Not just drinking it (which we’ve clearly mastered)… but creating something that will carry our name and our story.

Barrel by barrel, this is something we’ll look back on years from now and say — we were there when it started.

Early reviews are strong… expectations are even higher. The Supper Club isn’t just part of tradition anymore… We’re making it!

All Hail

Last night the Supper Club packed up the appetites and headed to Da Benito in Union… and let’s just say — we may need to...
03/01/2026

Last night the Supper Club packed up the appetites and headed to Da Benito in Union… and let’s just say — we may need to refinance a few assets, but it was worth every bite.

The food? Possibly the best we ever had.
The atmosphere? Old-school Italian excellence.
The bill? Let’s just say it came with its own moment of silence.

From start to finish, this place delivered. Every plate looked like it belonged in a museum and tasted even better. You know it’s a serious night when the table goes quiet — not because we’re mad at each other — but because nobody wants to stop eating.

Huge shoutout to this month’s host, Len Nitti, for absolutely raising the bar. When Nitti hosts, you show up hungry… and maybe bring a financial advisor.

Another legendary night in the books.

Supper Club rule #47: You can’t put a price on memories.
(But apparently you can get pretty close.)

All Hail the Supper Club!

Supper Club is officially back… and we wasted no time reminding ourselves why this tradition matters.Great food, great a...
01/31/2026

Supper Club is officially back… and we wasted no time reminding ourselves why this tradition matters.

Great food, great atmosphere, and zero disappointment at Ember & Eagle — a strong choice to kick off the year and set the tone early. Stories were told, laughs were had, and nobody asked “so who’s hosting next month?” (a rare win).

Well played by this month’s host, Jason Rutan, for opening the season the right way. If this is any indication of what’s ahead, 2026 is already off to a strong start.

One dinner down. Many stories to come.

All Hail the Supper Club!

The wait is over.The dates are set.The responsibilities have been assigned.The 2026 Supper Club Schedule has officially ...
01/03/2026

The wait is over.
The dates are set.
The responsibilities have been assigned.

The 2026 Supper Club Schedule has officially been released.

Calendars should now be marked, excuses prepared, and expectations managed accordingly. Each member has been entrusted with their moment — some with pride, others with concern.

Review carefully. Plan wisely. And remember… once your month arrives, history will be watching.

All Hail

01/01/2026

🎬 Supper Club 2025: The Recap 🍷🥩🔥
The jackets. The laughter. The legends.
You lived it. Now relive it.

All hail the tradition. All hail the crew.
Watch the year unfold — now streaming on your timeline.

🎄 A Night to Remember at LouCas! 🎄Supper Club closed out the year in true legendary fashion—great wine, better steak, an...
12/21/2025

🎄 A Night to Remember at LouCas! 🎄

Supper Club closed out the year in true legendary fashion—great wine, better steak, and unforgettable company at the always-excellent LouCas in Edison. The jackets were sharp, the stories were louder, and the laughs could’ve cracked the Chianti bottles.

And of course, no Supper Club holiday bash is complete without a few well-deserved honors:

Dinner of the Year — Mike Manfre
For hosting a spread so good it nearly broke the bylaws. From ambiance to appetizers, the man delivered a 5-star performance—despite a betting record that says otherwise.

Mr. Irrelevant — Matt Gilbert
Some say it’s an insult, we say it’s a tradition. Whether it was RSVP confusion or GPS malfunctions, Matty G proved once again that absence can make the heart grow fonder (or at least make the jokes better).

Member of the Year — John Banker
For consistently showing up, pouring heavy, and still finding time to remind us all what wine actually tastes like. His cork-popping consistency and Supper Club spirit were unmatched this year.

To the entire Supper Club crew—thank you for another year of unforgettable dinners, questionable group texts, and unwavering brotherhood.

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to all… and to all a good bite.

12/21/2025

🎄 ’Twas the Night Before Supper Club – 2025 Edition 🎄

’Twas the night before Supper Club, and all through the thread, The group chat was buzzing with what still lay ahead. The jackets were pressed and hung up with care, In hopes that each member would actually be there.

The members were nestled all snug in their rides, Some coming from Jersey, some from warmer tides. And Benna in blazer, clipboard in hand, Was ready to lead with one final stand.

Banker was swirling his fourth glass of red,
Spouting aromas that lived in his head.
“Notes of leather and oak!” he proclaimed to the group— Though someone swore it just smelled like fruit soup.

Steve Manfre walked in with a confident smile,
Now fluent in AI and machine-learning style.
“ChatGPT wrote my toast,” he began with a smirk— “While I made my portfolio do all the work.”

Then Greg raised his glass with a sheepish grin,
“Let me tell you boys how my hosting caved in.
I picked the whole spot, the vibe was just right—
Then Delta said, ‘Nah, you’re grounded tonight.’
So while you all feasted, with wine and with flair,
I was main course to a plastic airport chair.”

Jim arrived sharp, tailored head to toe,
A gentleman’s presence, a presidential glow.
He hosted with grace, from cocktails to steak,
And did it with class that’s not easy to fake.

Davis flew in from Florida’s shore,
Still louder than most when he walked through the door. With a volume reserved for arena-sized calls, He echoed through dinners and vibrated walls.

Matty G rolled in, cool as can be,
Claiming, “You clowns could never outclass me.”
He scoffed at traditions, but still brought delight—
Even lit a menorah mid-dinner one night.

Phil, ever loyal in RSVP tone,
Would text, “I’ll be there!”—then leave us alone.
Each dinner approached with his trademark tease,
But the only Phil sighting was seen in the breeze.

Bosco showed up with his wallet unzipped,
And quadrupled a tip that was already tipped.
The waitress retired and bought her own yacht,
While Bosco just grinned and said, “What? I forgot!”

John brought his daughters, a beautiful twist,
A rule bent with reason no one could resist.
Talks of the future began to take flight,
As the next-gen Supper Club glowed into night.

D-Man had vanished, a ghost through the year,
No jokes, no replies, no dinners, no cheer.
But as December arrived, so did the man,
With courage to share what no one else can.
Life had been heavy—too heavy to speak—
Yet he stood with his brothers, no need to be meek. We welcomed him back with a nod and a clap, a reminder that Supper Club always has your back.

From the back corner came a subtle hush—
Three members emerged from the holiday rush.
Rutan had missed most of the regular fare,
Drawn to the sidelines, to playbooks and prayer.
Ken gave a nod, quiet strength in his stare,
Sipping his red with badge-worthy flair.
And Nitti, composed, our Commish with the pen,
Balanced the rules for the Supper Club men.
Together they entered like a well-timed attack—
The law, the logistics, and the playoff fallback.

Mike Manfre took charge as this year’s big host,
At the holiday bash he was doing the most.
With ci**rs, aged whiskey, and some questionable cheer,
And side bets that lost like they do every year.
“Investor’s Club,” he called with a grin—
“You Venmo me cash, I promise we’ll win!”

Then Boyer walked in with a napkin in tow,
Already mid-sweat from a pre-dinner glow.
Was it nerves? Was it steak? No one could say—
But the man wiped his brow like he’d run a 5K.

At the head stood President Benna with pride,
Clipboard in hand and Ken by his side.
He banged on the glass and summoned the crew,
With a grin that said, “You all know what to do.”

“Brothers,” he boomed, “we made it once more,
Through canceled events and surprise airport lore.
We’ve broken some rules, added new names,
And argued all year about sides and their claims.
But one thing holds true—through the loud and the light— Supper Club’s bond is forever airtight.

”And the laughter it roared, and the wine it did pour,
As the members all toasted to dinners and more.
And just before jackets were flung on their backs,
Came a whisper that cut through the clatter and clacks…

“Supper Club to all, and to all a good bite—
Now someone please Uber Phil home for the night.”

Address

5th Avenue
New York, NY
10019

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Supper Club posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category