08/09/2026
Stop Scrolling! How did this pizza get its name?
The pie that put Astarita on the map.
Mr. William 🍕🔥
Astarita Pizza
797 5th Avenue
Brooklyn 📍
Theastaritapizza.com
Download the app from our website and get rewards
Why it works..
Margherita base + pepperoni
+ Mikes hot honey
Sweet heat that hits different
Ingredient breakdown (save-worthy)
• San Marzano-style tomato sauce
• Lioni Latticini Inc. - Lioni Mozzarella Fresh mozzarella
• Cupped pepperoni
• Hot honey
Simple. Fresh. No shortcuts
The brick-oven difference
High Temperature Brick Oven
Fast bake Time
Thin, crispy, never soggy.
Most ordered pie Every single week
Kids love it too
Tag the person you would split this with
Our son Mr. William
Short version:
His first speech therapist Miss Price
A very pleasant Caribbean Women who lit up when she met him and the first words out of her mouth were “Hello Misterr Willliammm so nice to meet you” Her voice melodic and very sweet and the way she said stuck in my head and never left. Whenever I hear someone say Mr. William in the Astarita, The dynamic rise and fall of her voice is what I hear..
