Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe

Call Directions Website

Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe Penny Lane Art Gallery and Coffee Shop offers cafe style food, drinks and beautiful artwork. We are truly proud that this is our hometown.
(420)

We strive to create a relaxed, laid-back atmosphere where you can come in and take a break from the daily grind. Located in the heart of New Carlisle, Ohio, we are overwhelmed by the sense of community that has been shown to us since we opened. Come in, have a coffee or sandwich and enjoy the atmosphere. We hope to see you soon!

10/14/2026

The bee was a paid actor 🐝 👹 ☕️

Sample our Ghosted Latte, Scary Berry Latte, Dirt Nap Shaken Espresso, and Hex Appeal with a couple of your ghoul-friends. It’s a scary good time 👻 🩸 💀

Come visit Penny Lane Express for our Halloween Menu Drop!!! While we’re talking about Express, let’s answer some common...
10/13/2026

Come visit Penny Lane Express for our Halloween Menu Drop!!! While we’re talking about Express, let’s answer some common questions we’ve been getting!

📍 Where are you located?
6821 Dayton Springfield Road 45323

📞 What’s your phone number?
326-209-0575

🥪 Why is the menu smaller?
This location has a drive through! We want to bring you a big taste of Penny Lane without as long of a wait! Things like our Seasonal Flight, that you can find at our New Carlisle Location, are WONDERFUL but they are a monster to make to order! Certain items , as well as a large number of items, dramatically slow our ticket times, which aren’t very compatible in a Drive Through setting! We think we’ll be adding more seasonal items in the coming months, though!

🕰️ What are your hours?
Tuesday - Friday 6:30 AM - 4:00
Saturday 7:30 AM - 4:00

🙋‍♀️ Will you only be open 5 days a week forever?
NOPE!! We plan on being open 7 days a week (hopefully) in the near future! It was critical for us that we get our current staff up to speed and fully trained at both locations before we brought in more team members to open the full 7 days! Quality over quantity 🩷

🪑 Is there seating?
Yes! There are a lot of cozy corners to get lunch with a friend, it’s more intimate two tops! We suggest going to New Carlisle if you want to gather with a larger group!

I’m sure you have more questions! Let me know in the comments below, I’d love to answer them here!!

Want to work at one of our locations?? Great! But before you apply, let’s talk about who we are, what we do, and what we...
10/12/2026

Want to work at one of our locations?? Great! But before you apply, let’s talk about who we are, what we do, and what we’re looking for.

Read through. We might just be your people. 👉

This is who you’re working for, my name is Allyson and I care a LOT about the culture we create, the food we make, the drinks we send out, the customers we get to take care of, and a good dose of fun, creativity, and excitement 😜

This is who you’re working WITH! A special group of hardworking, talented, fun individuals that you can count on to make a delicious sandwich, bring all of the good vibes and positivity your way, crack a joke, and bust a move during our rushes ☕️

This is what you’ll be DOING (and learning) ! Learning ever changing seasonal menus. Yes taking orders, but building relationships with customers. Perfectly executing drool worthy sandwiches and drinks.

Here’s what I’m looking FOR! Someone who really cares. About Penny Lane. About people. About creating something special. About the culture. That’s it . (Oh, maybe some Sunday availability 😉) We can teach you the skills, you bring the heart. Send us your resume via our website , and let’s talk!

These delicious breakfast options at Penny Lane New Carlisle will be haunting your dreams 🍳 🥯 GOOD MOURNING - A French O...
10/12/2026

These delicious breakfast options at Penny Lane New Carlisle will be haunting your dreams 🍳

🥯 GOOD MOURNING
- A French Onion Breakfast Bagel Sandwich made with our house caramelized onions, local roast beef, egg, lots of Swiss, and Dijon thyme aioli on a bagel

🥑 TOAST MORTEM
-Chipotle Cranberry Avocado Toast on multigrain with feta and bacon

🩸 SCARY BERRY OVERNIGHT OATS
- Vanilla bean cold steeped oatmeal, cheesecake yogurt, macerated raspberries

Penny Lane Express is OPEN TODAY (Sunday, Oct . 11th) 7:30 AM - 4:00 PM for Apple Butter Festival fun!! Stop by and see ...
10/11/2026

Penny Lane Express is OPEN TODAY (Sunday, Oct . 11th) 7:30 AM - 4:00 PM for Apple Butter Festival fun!! Stop by and see Jess for an Apple Butter Latte and an Apple Crisp Cheesecake Cup 🍎 ✨

Enon - Apple Butter Latte 🍎 ☕️ New Carlisle - Type O Negative Where are you headed today?? New Carlisle has all of the s...
10/10/2026

Enon - Apple Butter Latte 🍎 ☕️
New Carlisle - Type O Negative
Where are you headed today?? New Carlisle has all of the spooky vibes, Enon has everything Apple! You need to try it ALL!

10/10/2026

Make sure to swing by Penny Lane Express today in Enon, to enjoy something off of our LIMITED TIME Apple Butter Festival Menu!! It features our Apple Butter Grilled Cheese, Apple Crisp Cheesecake Cup, Apple Butter Latte, and Chaider! 🍎

Our October pastry drop is disturbingly good 🤤 Come by for our world famous (well, maybe just New Carlisle famous) Prote...
10/10/2026

Our October pastry drop is disturbingly good 🤤 Come by for our world famous (well, maybe just New Carlisle famous) Protein Buckeyes all decorated for Halloween 👻 An Ube Cookies & Scream Blondie, or a Boo-Berry Linzer Cookie made with care by Franklin Street Farmstand! Our suggestion is to try all 3 for a scary good time 😈

We have some savory, cheesy, melty deliciousness for our rotating special this week! It’s our FRENCH ONION CHICKEN MELT ...
10/09/2026

We have some savory, cheesy, melty deliciousness for our rotating special this week! It’s our FRENCH ONION CHICKEN MELT 🤤 🧅 Mesquite grilled chicken, perfect caramelized onions, Dijon thyme aioli, lots of Swiss, and French fried onions grilled on our ciabatta bread!! Only available Friday October 9th - Wednesday October 14th, so hurry in!!!

10/08/2026

Apparently a Ghosted Latte from Penny Lane is the only thing worth breaking no contact for 😬 Available starting tomorrow, even though your situationship may not be 🫠

ps you deserve better 😘

Address

109 S Main Street
New Carlisle, OH
45344

Opening Hours

Monday 6:30am - 6pm
Tuesday 6:30am - 6pm
Wednesday 6:30am - 6pm
Thursday 6:30am - 6pm
Friday 6:30am - 6pm
Saturday 7:30am - 6pm
Sunday 7:30am - 6pm

Telephone

+19376795304

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Penny Lane Art Gallery & Cafe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category