Coney Island Diner

Coney Island Diner In the 1920s, two Brooklyn brothers created the savory chili topping for Coney-style hot dogs. We pride ourselves in giving fast & friendly service.
(271)

Permanently closed.

After a few years they moved north, opened a shop, and despite a fire and new owners, Coney Island Diner still proudly serves its famous Coney chili dogs today All your orders are made when you place your order. Our soups n sauces are all homemade, along with all of our desserts and pastries. We offer a loyalty program for all our customers so they can receive discounts and promotions. Give us a try today, you will not be disappointed.

05/01/2026

After many wonderful years, Coney Island Diner has officially closed its doors.

We’ve recently passed the business on to new ownership, marking the end of an incredible chapter for us. This wasn’t just a diner—it was a place filled with laughter, early mornings, late evenings, and so many familiar faces who became like family.

Serving this community has meant everything to us, and we are truly grateful for your loyalty, support, and countless memories shared over the years.

From a simple cup of coffee to full meals with loved ones, you made this place something special.

Thank you for being part of our journey 🙏🏼❤️

– The Coney Island Diner Team

Address

10 Railroad Avenue
Middletown, NY
10940

Telephone

+18453433714

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Coney Island Diner posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Coney Island Diner:

Shortcuts

Share

Category