Pop's Custard

Pop's Custard Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Pop's Custard, Burger Restaurant, N87 W16459 Appleton Avenue, Menomonee Falls, WI.
(486)

Pop’s Custard has been my home for last 26 years.  It feels very surreal to wake up every day and not have to think abou...
09/11/2025

Pop’s Custard has been my home for last 26 years. It feels very surreal to wake up every day and not have to think about what the next flavor is going to be or how many buns we are going to need for that day. I grew up there and met the most important people in my life while working there.

And the big reason that I loved Pop’s so much was the
customers. You guys are the best and I know I have said it before but honestly you have all become my little
family. There are so many of you that I know your favorite flavor or exactly how much hot fudge you like on your sundae. I feel like I have been through it all with you guys. When I decided to become the owner of Pop’s everyone was so gracious and really made it an easy transition. I am not sure how to put into words how to thank you all for these last few weeks. I feel awful because there were a lot of you that I didn’t even get to have our last little chat or make your last kids scoop because we were so BUSY. The few of you that I got to hug goodbye through the tears (thanks for ignoring them) or read your amazing emails\letters really touched my heart.

Now I know that big question is about the sale of Pop’s Custard. I know you are all very curious about it but I promise you I will update you as soon as we have some information. Pop’s Custard is very much still for sale and we are now finally looking at buyers. Thank you to everyone that has reached out with
interest and sorry for taking so long to get back to some of you. It has been a crazy month for sure. All the communication about the sale and interest should be directed towards [email protected]

Drum on down to Pop's for the last flavor of the day! Vanilla custard with chocolate drizzle, peanuts and waffle cone pi...
08/31/2025

Drum on down to Pop's for the last flavor of the day! Vanilla custard with chocolate drizzle, peanuts and waffle cone pieces makes one of our classic flavors Drumstick!🍦🍗 (Pictured below in a waffle cone for double deliciousness)

Our flavor of the the day is fast becoming a favorite with our customers but we are sure it has everything to do with th...
08/30/2025

Our flavor of the the day is fast becoming a favorite with our customers but we are sure it has everything to do with the man and not the custard. In honor of Big Jack, we are having the flavor appropriately named Big Jack! It is our butter pecan custard with salted pecan pieces and chocolate chips!

The flavor of the day is Black Raspberry🍦! It is a refreshing black raspberry flavored custard with no fruit or seeds fo...
08/29/2025

The flavor of the day is Black Raspberry🍦! It is a refreshing black raspberry flavored custard with no fruit or seeds for those who hate those! Yum! Perfect to enjoy on our patio on this berryful😂day! ☀️😍🌺

Thank you for all the love, support and patience everyone has shown these last few weeks! We will surely miss you!

The flavor of the day is one to go bananas🍌over and we are not monkeying🐵around! Chunky🐒Monkey is our homemade banana cu...
08/28/2025

The flavor of the day is one to go bananas🍌over and we are not monkeying🐵around! Chunky🐒Monkey is our homemade banana custard (made with only real bananas) and our chocolate flakes! We are sure you will find this flavor "appealing"!🙈🍌🙊

We wanted to have one more of the top favorites here at Pop's so you butter believe it's delicious! Reese's Trax is our ...
08/26/2025

We wanted to have one more of the top favorites here at Pop's so you butter believe it's delicious! Reese's Trax is our homemade peanut butter custard (made with real peanut butter🥜🍯)with lots of Reese's peanut butter cups pieces! 🍦🍦

Father Fran is the flavor of the day! Our original chocolate custard with salted pecan pieces, homemade brownies and cho...
08/24/2025

Father Fran is the flavor of the day! Our original chocolate custard with salted pecan pieces, homemade brownies and chocolate chips is the best combination of salty and chocolatey sweetness! 🍦🍫☀️🌱

We have a flavor of the day that is turtley worth stopping in at the window for! Turtle🐢is a sweet caramel custard with ...
08/23/2025

We have a flavor of the day that is turtley worth stopping in at the window for! Turtle🐢is a sweet caramel custard with chocolate covered salted pecan pieces! 🍦Yum!

Birthday🎂Cake is the flavor of the day! It is our homemade white cake batter custard with homemade birthday cake pieces ...
08/22/2025

Birthday🎂Cake is the flavor of the day! It is our homemade white cake batter custard with homemade birthday cake pieces and rainbow sprinkles! Yum! 🥳🍦Come and visit us today!

The flavor of the day is Mint Chip! We have many different variations of this flavor but this always seems to be the fav...
08/21/2025

The flavor of the day is Mint Chip! We have many different variations of this flavor but this always seems to be the favorite! It is our refreshing mint custard with rich chocolate flakes! Yum! 🍦🍦🍦

Red raspberry😍is the flavor of the day! Prepare to be razzled and dazzled with this red raspberry custard with fresh ras...
08/20/2025

Red raspberry😍is the flavor of the day! Prepare to be razzled and dazzled with this red raspberry custard with fresh raspberries throughout! Yum! 🍦

Vanilla Malt Chip is the flavor of the day! If you love😍 a good malt this is the perfect flavor for you! It is our homem...
08/19/2025

Vanilla Malt Chip is the flavor of the day! If you love😍 a good malt this is the perfect flavor for you! It is our homemade vanilla malt custard with sweet chocolate flakes scattered throughout making it one of our most requested flavors!🍦🍨

We had planned to have this flavor but what we didn't plan on was losing one of our biggest supporters this past week. Scott Krause told anyone and everyone how great Pop's is and was constantly sending in anyone new to the Falls to come and visit. He was family so much so that he was the only customer we let have a running tab. He will be very dearly missed so in his honor we also have his favorite flavor today. Ann's Joy is a vanilla custard with chopped almonds🌰 toasted coconut🥥 and sweet chocolate ribbons🍫. I can almost hear him telling me I am ruining his diet.

Address

N87 W16459 Appleton Avenue
Menomonee Falls, WI
53051

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+12622513320

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pop's Custard posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share