Magic Fountain

Home
United States
Mattituck, NY
Magic Fountain

Homemade ice cream store located in Mattituck, NY on the north fork of Long Island. Come check out our unique flavors & custom cakes!
(588)

Over the four decades that we’ve been around, we’ve become known for a lot of things. Some people know us as their local ice cream shop or as the shop they go to when they’re vacationing in the North Fork. Others know us for the creative flavors we serve -- everything from sweet corn and lavender to our ever-popular pumpkin. But everyone who’s stopped by (and even some who haven’t) know that we’re

run by a charming team whose goal is making sure you leave with something sweet. Whether you’re looking for a generous scoop on a hot summer day or a cake decorated for a special celebration, we’re here to send you home with your own taste of magic.

06/22/2026

The kind of banana split that turns heads the second it hits the counter 🍌🍨✨

Loaded with homemade ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, sprinkles, and cherries on top — just how it should be.
 

06/19/2026

Why do people keep coming back to Magic Fountain? 🍦💙

Because every season brings something new. We make our ice cream with quality ingredients, create fresh flavors for every holiday, and rotate specialty flavors every few weeks so there’s always something exciting waiting for you.

Follow along to see what’s coming next... your new favorite flavor might be just around the corner.

06/17/2026

Cookies & cream, but make it vegan 🌱🍪
Our Vegan Oreo scoop is rich, creamy, loaded with cookie crunch, and completely dairy-free.

 

06/15/2026

A treat for your four-legged best friend 🐾🍦
Our homemade doggie ice cream sandwiches are made just for pups — because they deserve dessert too.

06/12/2026

From hand dipped cones to handcrafted cakes and scoop after scoop of homemade ice cream, every visit to Magic Fountain is made with a little extra love. 🍦✨

Freshly made, beautifully crafted, and always worth the trip.

06/10/2026

Toasted Almond — smooth, nutty, and the kind of scoop you keep coming back for 🤎🍦

Homemade ice cream loaded with toasted almond flavor in every bite.

06/08/2026

Nutella never get old 🍫🌰
Rich chocolate ice cream blended with Nutella paste and crunchy chopped hazelnuts in every scoop.

06/05/2026

An Oreo lover’s dream from top to bottom 🍪🤍

Chocolate drizzle, layers of cookies & cream, and Oreos stacked on every slice-worthy angle.

06/03/2026

The sweetest gift is always ice cream 🍦🎁✨

Magic Fountain gift cards are perfect for birthdays, thank yous, summer surprises, or just because. Stop by and grab one for your favorite ice cream lover.

06/01/2026

Four cones. Four moods. One impossible decision 🍦✨

Dubai Chocolate, Raspberry Sorbet, Nutella, and Toasted Almond lined up and ready for your next favorite scoop.

Address

9825 Main Road
Mattituck, NY
11952

Telephone

+16312984908

Website

http://magicfountainicecream.net/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Magic Fountain posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Magic Fountain:

Shortcuts

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Mattituck?