Magic Fountain

Magic Fountain Homemade ice cream store located in Mattituck, NY on the north fork of Long Island. Come check out our unique flavors & custom cakes!
(587)

Over the four decades that we’ve been around, we’ve become known for a lot of things. Some people know us as their local ice cream shop or as the shop they go to when they’re vacationing in the North Fork. Others know us for the creative flavors we serve -- everything from sweet corn and lavender to our ever-popular pumpkin. But everyone who’s stopped by (and even some who haven’t) know that we’re

run by a charming team whose goal is making sure you leave with something sweet. Whether you’re looking for a generous scoop on a hot summer day or a cake decorated for a special celebration, we’re here to send you home with your own taste of magic.

09/04/2026

A little sweet, a little tropical, and totally worth a scoop 🥥🍦✨

Our Kauai Pie ice cream is a fun favorite with a unique flavor you’ll want to come back for again and again.

A tropical twist on your favorite frozen treat 🥥🥑🍦✨Our Coconut Avocado ice cream is creamy, unique, and packed with a re...
09/02/2026

A tropical twist on your favorite frozen treat 🥥🥑🍦✨

Our Coconut Avocado ice cream is creamy, unique, and packed with a refreshing flavor combination you have to try for yourself.

08/31/2026

Layers of sweetness in every spoonful 🍦✨

Our Ice Cream Parfait is stacked with creamy homemade ice cream and delicious layers that make every bite just as good as the last.

Every slice has something different to love 🎂🍦✨Our sectioned ice cream cakes are topped with favorites like M&M’s, Reese...
08/26/2026

Every slice has something different to love 🎂🍦✨

Our sectioned ice cream cakes are topped with favorites like M&M’s, Reese’s Pieces, sprinkles, and more, so everyone gets the piece they’ve been hoping for.

08/24/2026

The banana split that never disappoints 🍌🍦✨

Made with creamy homemade ice cream, fresh bananas, whipped cream, and all the classic toppings, it’s the kind of dessert you’ll want to order again and again.

08/22/2026

New flavors are here, and there’s a little something for every kind of ice cream lover 🍦✨

Cookie Caramel Latte, Nutty Rose, Fig & Honey, Goat Cheese & Fig, Mango Kulfi, and Sweet Corn are officially on the lineup. Which one are you trying first? 👀

08/19/2026

Thick, creamy, and topped the classic way 🥤🍒✨

Our milkshakes are blended with homemade ice cream, finished with a swirl of whipped cream and a cherry on top for the ultimate sweet treat.

Crispy Crunch for the candy lovers 🍫✨A plain ice cream base packed with Kit Kats, Twix, and ribbons of caramel in every ...
08/17/2026

Crispy Crunch for the candy lovers 🍫✨

A plain ice cream base packed with Kit Kats, Twix, and ribbons of caramel in every creamy scoop.

When your ice cream craving needs a little something extra 🍫🍦✨Our Brownie Sundae combines a rich, fudgy brownie with cre...
08/14/2026

When your ice cream craving needs a little something extra 🍫🍦✨

Our Brownie Sundae combines a rich, fudgy brownie with creamy homemade ice cream, topped with all the extras for a dessert that’s hard to resist.

08/13/2026

Cookies, homemade ice cream, and a sprinkle-covered finish 🍪🍦✨

Our ice cream sandwiches are made with creamy homemade ice cream between soft cookies, then rolled in sprinkles for the perfect finishing touch.

Address

9825 Main Road
Mattituck, NY
11952

Telephone

+16312984908

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Magic Fountain posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Magic Fountain:

Shortcuts

Share

Category