Magic Fountain

Home
United States
Mattituck, NY
Magic Fountain

Call Directions Website Contact the restaurant

Homemade ice cream store located in Mattituck, NY on the north fork of Long Island. Come check out our unique flavors & custom cakes!
(586)

Over the four decades that we’ve been around, we’ve become known for a lot of things. Some people know us as their local ice cream shop or as the shop they go to when they’re vacationing in the North Fork. Others know us for the creative flavors we serve -- everything from sweet corn and lavender to our ever-popular pumpkin. But everyone who’s stopped by (and even some who haven’t) know that we’re run by a charming team whose goal is making sure you leave with something sweet. Whether you’re looking for a generous scoop on a hot summer day or a cake decorated for a special celebration, we’re here to send you home with your own taste of magic.

10/10/2026

Columbus Day weekend just got a little sweeter! 🍦🎉

Join us Saturday, Sunday, and Monday for our BUY ONE, GET ONE FREE soft serve special! Grab a friend, bring the family, and enjoy a little extra sweetness at Magic Fountain. 🍦✨

🍦 Buy one, get one free soft serve cone or cup.
📅 Saturday, Sunday & Monday
⚠️ Available while supplies last
Sugar or wafer cones only. Toppings not included.

10/08/2026

Cherry + pistachio = a scoop worth talking about 🍒💚🍦

Our Cherry Pistachio ice cream brings together rich pistachio and sweet cherry flavor in one creamy homemade scoop. Grab a cone and give this combo a try!

10/05/2026

Some customers grow up with us 🍦💛

He’s been coming to Magic Fountain since he was 6 years old—and now, at 24, he’s still stopping by for his favorite ice cream. That kind of loyalty means everything to us!

10/02/2026

Apple pie season just got even better 🍎🥧🍦✨

Our Apple Pie ice cream is made with delicious Briermere Farm apple pie for a scoop that brings two local favorites together.

09/29/2026

A little bit of every berry in one scoop 🫐🍓🍦✨

Our Mixed Berry ice cream brings together a delicious blend of berry flavors for a creamy scoop bursting with fruity goodness.

09/25/2026

Because sprinkles make everything better 🌈🍦✨

Choose your favorite homemade ice cream, dip it in colorful sprinkles, and turn your next scoop into something extra special.

09/23/2026

For the chocolate lovers who never think there’s too much 🍫🍦✨

Chocolate-dipped ice cream or chocolate ice cream topped with chocolate sprinkles, either way, you really can’t go wrong.

09/21/2026

When the kids say it’s the best ice cream on Long Island… we’ll take their word for it 🍦💛

Hearing it straight from our youngest customers makes every scoop a little sweeter. Thanks for the love!

09/19/2026

New flavors just dropped, and we’ve got some seriously good ones 🍦👀✨

Ube & Coconut, Turmeric & Candy Ginger, Toasted Almonds, Peanut Butter Cookie, Pumpkin, and Pumpkin Pralines are all joining the lineup. Which one are you scooping first?

09/16/2026

Chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry? 🥤🍦✨

Three classic flavors, three delicious milkshakes, all blended up creamy and finished with a generous swirl of whipped cream. Which one are you choosing?

Address

9825 Main Road
Mattituck, NY
11952

Telephone

+16312984908

Website

http://magicfountainicecream.net/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Magic Fountain posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Magic Fountain:

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed restaurant in Mattituck?