Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK

Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK, Pizza Place, 5610 Gulf of Mexico Drive #4, Longboat Key, FL.

You’ve got to try our all new “Guppy’s Cheesesteak Pizza” featuring shaved ribeye sourced from our Philly neighbor, onio...
09/25/2026

You’ve got to try our all new “Guppy’s Cheesesteak Pizza” featuring shaved ribeye sourced from our Philly neighbor, onion, green peppers and last minute melted provolone cheese! Available for take-out, dine-in or delivery! It’s sure to please any kind of pizza lover! We look forward to serving you!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com
Available exclusively at our Longboat Key location!
5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

There’s just something about cup and char pepperoni! It’s like the icing on the cake! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighbor...
09/22/2026

There’s just something about cup and char pepperoni! It’s like the icing on the cake!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

09/08/2026

You only live once! Live it happy! Pizza doesn’t hurt either!

😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Yes we are open today both locations normal hours! Call or come on in! Happy Labor Day! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighb...
09/07/2026

Yes we are open today both locations normal hours! Call or come on in! Happy Labor Day!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

09/03/2026

Let’s get this beautiful day started with some pizza by the slice. Come see us we are open and here to serve you remember slice special runs all day long until close!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

08/31/2026

The “Peggy Supreme” right before the magic happens in our bakers pride oven made in the 1940’s!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Take advantage of our off season deals! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.comSarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ ...
08/28/2026

Take advantage of our off season deals!

😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Any 2 slices and a drink special ALL day EVERY day! Featured here is our Buffalo chicken pizza, but feel free to mix and...
08/18/2026

Any 2 slices and a drink special ALL day EVERY day! Featured here is our Buffalo chicken pizza, but feel free to mix and match whatever you like in our showcase! We look forward to serving you.
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Address

5610 Gulf Of Mexico Drive #4
Longboat Key, FL
34228

Telephone

(941)3835551

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK:

Shortcuts

Featured

Share

Category