Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK

Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK, Pizza Place, 5610 Gulf of Mexico Drive #4, Longboat Key, FL.

07/29/2026

Today’s sub special at our Longboat Key location. Chicken, vodka sauce, smoked provolone cheese, pepperoni and a light hot honey drizzle! So delicious! Come try one today!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Sometimes you just wanna keep it simple with a classic cheese! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.comSarasota: ...
07/28/2026

Sometimes you just wanna keep it simple with a classic cheese! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Good morning Gulf Gate! Any 2 slice and a drink special running all day long! Come see us or give us a call!😋 🍕🫡 ...
07/24/2026

Good morning Gulf Gate! Any 2 slice and a drink special running all day long! Come see us or give us a call!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

07/21/2026

Pepperoni, ricotta, hot honey and jalapeno! Order it any way you like it, we are here to serve you! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

07/18/2026

Cup and char pepperoni! Baked to perfection, always hot and fresh! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

07/17/2026

Work hard, relax and repeat! See you in a few hours!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Our “Southie” pie starts as our classic cheese, then topped with pepperoni, mushroom and slices of smoked provolone! Suc...
07/16/2026

Our “Southie” pie starts as our classic cheese, then topped with pepperoni, mushroom and slices of smoked provolone! Such an amazing blend of flavors!
😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

07/14/2026

Who remembers “McGruff the crime dog”? He’s retired and now takes a bite out of pizza instead of crime! Saw it and had to have it on the wall! 😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

07/12/2026

Garlic bread madness! Sheesh! 😁🙏

😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

07/10/2026

We’re proud to announce we’ve been nominated! 5 categories! We’re striving to win best pizza and we need your votes! Click on the link below to cast your vote now, and don’t forget you can vote once a day! Thank you to all of you for your continued support, we are forever grateful! ❤️🍕🙏
Voting link: https://bestof2026.sarasotamagazine.com/

😋 🍕🫡 www.costellosneighborhoodpizza.com

Sarasota: 6574 Superior Ave, SRQ FL 34231
📞941-924-5800
Longboat Key:5610 Gulf of Mexico Dr, LBK 34228
📞941-383-5551

Address

5610 Gulf Of Mexico Drive #4
Longboat Key, FL
34228

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza LBK posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Featured

Share

Category