What are the opening hours?

Monday 5pm - 9pm Tuesday 5pm - 9pm Wednesday 5pm - 9pm Thursday 5pm - 9pm Friday 5pm - 9pm Saturday 5pm - 9pm

Old City Prime

Name: Old City Prime
Address: 215 S Main Street, Lima, OH, 45801, US
Telephone: +14192277463
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

Home
United States
Lima, OH
Old City Prime

A modern day classic American steakhouse. Old City Prime is a modern day classic American steakhouse. Our menu is a revival of ageless taste.
(1219)

From our fresh oysters and chilled seafood, classic tableside salads, gourmet appetizers, USDA prime aged steaks to breads and desserts from our in house bakery.

Indulge in our classic cocktails and boutique wine list, and we think you'll find yourself comfortably enjoying our vision of what today's supper club should be.

07/31/2026

Summer, thoughtfully prepared.

Seasonal entrées featuring USDA Prime beef, fresh seafood, and the finest ingredients of the season.

Reserve your table:
oldcityprime.com/reservations

07/30/2026

Rehearsal dinners. Corporate eventss. Milestone celebrations.

The Upper Lounge at Old City Prime was designed for gatherings that deserve exceptional food, attentive service, and an unforgettable atmosphere.

We'll handle the details — you enjoy the evening.
Learn more at
oldcityprime.com/private-events

07/28/2026

There's always room for one more course.

Tall New York Style Cheesecake — creamy cheesecake on a graham cracker crust, finished with warm cherry pie filling poured right over the top. Our pastry kitchen puts the same care into the last bite as the first.

07/24/2026

Steak night is serious business. Everyone has their order.

Filet Mignon. New York Strip. Wagyu Ribeye. Which one are you? Drop your answer below.

Whatever you choose, we'll have it ready.

07/23/2026

Raise a glass to the season.🍹

Discover our limited-time summer beverage features, including two handcrafted cocktails and a featured draft beer—the perfect accompaniment to your next evening at Old City Prime.

Reserve your table: oldcityprime.com/reservations

07/22/2026

Celebrating aniversaries with our guests is one of our favorite traditions. 💕 Recently, we have had the honor of celebrating 3 amazing couples.
Congratulations to Mr. and Mrs. Sullivan and Mr. and Mrs. Fronzaglia on 25 years of marriage! 🥂
Congratulations to Mr. and Mrs. Nusbaum on 54 years of marriage! 🥂

07/21/2026

Experience the flavors of the season at Old City Prime.

Our new Summer Feature Menu highlights the fresh flavors of the season with a collection of chef-crafted dishes available for a limited time.

Join us for an exceptional dining experience and discover what's new this summer.

Reserve your table: www.oldcityprime.com/reservations

07/20/2026

Old City Prime was built on a simple idea: that a great meal should feel like an occasion. From the Tableside Caesar to the dry-aged New York Strip to the last sip of a perfectly made Manhattan, every detail is intentional.

This is our vision of what today's supper club should be. We'd love to share it with you.

07/17/2026

The appetizer that never lasts long at the table.
Our Lump Crab Stuffed Mushrooms — Maryland blue crab, parmesan, and herbs, baked until golden in a sizzling cast iron skillet. The kind of starter that sets the tone for the whole evening.

07/16/2026

Join us for Third Thursday in Downtown Lima tonight at Old City Prime.

Starting at 5 PM, enjoy:
🦐 3 Cocktail Shrimp for $5
🦪 3 Oysters for $5

Spend your evening downtown with us and enjoy handcrafted cocktails, exceptional food, and a refined dining experience.

We look forward to seeing you tonight.

Address

215 S Main Street
Lima, OH
45801

Opening Hours

Monday	5pm - 9pm
Tuesday	5pm - 9pm
Wednesday	5pm - 9pm
Thursday	5pm - 9pm
Friday	5pm - 9pm
Saturday	5pm - 9pm

Telephone

+14192277463

Website

http://www.oldcityprime.com/, http://oldcityprime.com/menu, http://oldcityprime.com/live-entertainment

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old City Prime posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Lima?