Goodfellas Pizzeria

Directions Website

Goodfellas Pizzeria Late-night NY-style pizza & hidden bourbon speakeasy with rare wh***ey flights in KY, IN, OH, and TN! Goodfellas has been serving pizza by the slice since 2005.

Our pizza is gigantic, 22 inches, serving a true New York style pizza by the slice. Our dough is made fresh daily, hand tossed and baked off on the stone. Entertaining our guests is part of our service, tossing the dough and performing dough tricks to great energetic music is always a crowd pleaser. We are Late Night Pizza ROCKSTARS ! Stop by late night and see why! Locations in Kentucky, Ohio, Indiana, Tennessee, & More to come!

We don't skip dessert around here. 🤌🍪 Cannolis, cookies, and cheesecake. Consider it an offer you can't refuse.
10/15/2026

We don't skip dessert around here. 🤌🍪 Cannolis, cookies, and cheesecake. Consider it an offer you can't refuse.

This is what fresh outta the oven looks like. 🤌
10/13/2026

This is what fresh outta the oven looks like. 🤌

Sausage on pizza? Yes. Paulie’s Favorite? Absolutely. 🍕
10/11/2026

Sausage on pizza? Yes. Paulie’s Favorite? Absolutely. 🍕

Pizza Month is getting serious. 🍕 The Goodfellas Dough Toss-Off is on. Follow on Instagram to vote in each round.Who’s ...
10/01/2026

Pizza Month is getting serious. 🍕 The Goodfellas Dough Toss-Off is on. Follow on Instagram to vote in each round.

Who’s taking the whole thing? 👀

10/01/2026

Things are about to get tossed. 🍕 18 Goodfellas crew members are going head-to-head all October long.

You decide who moves on. First vote drops Oct. 1st via Instagram stories!

Yeah, we’re hungry too. Get the meatball sub + a drink for $11 from 11 AM–3 PM daily. 🥖🔥
09/30/2026

Yeah, we’re hungry too. Get the meatball sub + a drink for $11 from 11 AM–3 PM daily. 🥖🔥

09/30/2026

Now THIS is how you do Louisville. 🍕🥃

Hot honey, anyone? 🍯🌶️Add it to any pizza and make your usual order a little hotter, a little sweeter, and a whole lot h...
09/28/2026

Hot honey, anyone? 🍯🌶️

Add it to any pizza and make your usual order a little hotter, a little sweeter, and a whole lot harder to share.

09/28/2026

See you soon, Cincy. 🍕

Address

110 North Mill Street
Lexington, KY
40507

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 10pm
Tuesday 11am - 10pm
Wednesday 11am - 10pm
Thursday 11am - 1am
Friday 11am - 3am
Saturday 11am - 3am
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Goodfellas Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category