What are the opening hours?

Wednesday 3pm - 9pm Thursday 3pm - 9pm Friday 3pm - 9pm Saturday 1pm - 9pm Sunday 1pm - 9pm

Nikki's Custard

Home
United States
Lancaster, PA
Nikki's Custard

Call Directions Website

Closed for FAMILY VACATION OCT. 26-30
Re-open Sat., Oct. 31- Halloween 12-9pm
Reg.

Hours: Wed - Sun: 12pm-9pm
Mon & Tues: Closed
Frozen Custard-Fresh Daily! 😍
Non-Dairy & GF

10/27/2026

Have a spooktacular week! This weekend is packed full of goodies for you! It is your last chance for the pumpkin pie and s’mores milkshakes!

🧡OCT. 26-30 CLOSED FAMILY VACATION🧡

10/31 Sat - Monster Smash: Vanilla custard with Oreo cookie crumb, mini-Reese’s Pieces, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup
chunks 🎃HALLOWEEN DAY 👻
11/1 Sun - Chocolate Marshmallow Pie: Chocolate custard, Oreos, marshmallow sauce swirls 🍫🥧

HALLOWEEN AT NIKKI’S
Saturday, October 31: OPEN 12–9 PM
Come in wearing your Halloween costume, both kids AND adults! 👻👺👹
FREE Mini Scoop + Sprinkles
Choose from: Chocolate, Vanilla, Dole Sorbet (vegan), Low-Sugar Soft Serve
Dress up, grab a scoop, and celebrate Halloween with us!

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 31 – Nov. 1
Fudge Brownie Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Cherry Sorbet 🌱
Cookie Dough Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Saturday and Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday – Friday for Family Vacation

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA

*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/25/2026

Come get your fix before we are closed until SATURDAY!!!

10/25 Sun - Moose Track Fudge: Vanilla custard with fudge and peanut butter cups 🫎🍫🥜

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 20-25
Strawberry Shortcake Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Orange Sorbet 🌱
Carrot Cake Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Tuesday - Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA

*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/24/2026

My, Oh my…. It’s Apple Pie!

10/24 Sat - Apple Pie: Vanilla custard with apple pie chunks 🍎🥧

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham
Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 20-25
Strawberry Shortcake Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Orange Sorbet 🌱
Carrot Cake Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Tuesday - Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA
*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/23/2026

PUMPKIN GET YA PUMPKIN HERE LAST CALL FOR PUMPKIN 🎃📣

10/23 Fri - Pumpkin Cheesecake: Pumpkin Spice custard with cheesecake bites 🎃🍰

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 20-25
Strawberry Shortcake Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Orange Sorbet 🌱
Carrot Cake Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Tuesday - Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA

*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/22/2026

I think we can all agree this is a top tier Nikki’s flavor!!!

10/22 Thu - Oreo Peanut Butter Cup: Cookies & Cream custard with Oreo cookie crumb and peanut butter cup chunks 🐻‍❄️🐻

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 20-25
Strawberry Shortcake Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Orange Sorbet 🌱
Carrot Cake Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Tuesday - Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA

*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/22/2026

🎃👻💀

ANYONE CAN PARTICIPATE !!!!

Saturday, October 31st, 12pm-9pm

Come wearing a LEGIT costume and get a free mini scoop with sprinkles!

10/21/2026

Today’s flavor is packed full of yummy goodness!!! 💚

10/21 Wed - Dubai Chocolate: Pistachio custard with peanut butter Nutella, Kataifi shreds, peanuts, mini-chocolate chips and pistachios 🍫🥜🌾

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 20-25
Strawberry Shortcake Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Orange Sorbet 🌱
Carrot Cake Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Tuesday - Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA

*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/21/2026

📣📣📣📣
Plan accordingly!!!

The shop will be closed next week from Monday October 26 through Friday October 30!

We haven’t gone on a family vacation since before we opened Nikki’s!!!!! This is a much needed break for us, (Nicole and Avery) to spend time with our loved ones.

We will be open with normal hours starting on HALLOWEEN!!! Remember to come in wearing your costume to get a free mini scoop with sprinkles!

ANOTHER REMINDER IS STARTING NOVEMBER 1ST WE WILL BE CLOSED MONDAYS AND TUESDAYS UNTIL MARCH 1ST - open Wednesday through Sunday 12-9pm

10/20/2026

Yowza! The perfect flavor for the perfect day!
10/20 Tue - Peanut Butter Marshmallow Swirl: Peanut Butter custard with marshmallow swirls 🥜🍥

🍫🍦 Our classic chocolate and vanilla custard is made fresh and is available every day.

OCTOBER’s MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – S’mores: Chocolate Custard, Marshmallow Sauce, Toasted Marshmallow Syrup, Whipped Cream and Graham
Dust🥤

FALL MILKSHAKE SPECIAL – Pumpkin Pie: vanilla custard, spiced pumpkin syrup, milk, whipped cream and graham dust🥤

🌱Soft Serve Options 🍦
Available Oct 20-25
Strawberry Shortcake Non-fat Dairy (no added sugar)
Dole Orange Sorbet 🌱
Carrot Cake Non-Dairy🌱
Vanilla Non-Dairy🌱

🧡SHOP HOURS🧡
Tuesday - Sunday: 12-9PM
Closed on Monday

📍1831 Oregon Pike, Lancaster, PA
*Please note that the appearance of the product may vary from scoop to scoop.

10/19/2026

🥳 TWELVE DAYS OF CUSTARD 🥳

🎊 Deck the halls with boxes of custard falalalalala 🎊

PRE ORDER ONLY FROM OCTOBER 19 THRU NOVEMBER 22

If you place your order before November 1, you will receive a $5 gift card when you pick up your box in December!

How to pre-order:
1. ANYTIME - visit our website ➡️ nikkiscustard.com ➡️ order online ➡️ choose option ➡️ pay 💰➡️ pick it up between December 2-6!
2. Order in store
3. Order over the phone (we will not answer the phone if we are closed or busy)

🍨 Custard 🍨
1. Chocolate Raspberry Torte
2. Peanut Butter Fudge Pie
3. Candy Smash
4. Key Lime Pie
5. Pumpkin Cookie
6. Apple Pie
7. Salty Turtle
8. Oreo Cake Batter
9. Chocolate Peanut Butter
10. Gingerbread
11. Peppermint
12. NEW FLAVOR - Peanut Butter S’mores (toasted marshmallow custard with peanut butter cups, graham cracker crumb, and milk chocolate sauce)

🌱 Non dairy & Gluten Free 🌱
1. Peanut Butter
2. Espresso
3. Pumpkin Spice
4. Cinnamon Roll
5. Peppermint
6. Marshmallow
7. Pistachio
8. Cake Batter
9. Cookie Dough
10. Carrot Cake
11. Black Cherry
12. NEW FLAVOR - Gingerbread

🎊 TIME FOR HOLIDAY CHEER 🎊

🚫 No modifications 🚫

*Discounts and rewards cannot be applied to advent calendar purchases. Thank you for understanding, and happy holidays!

Address

1831 Oregon Pike
Lancaster, PA
17601

Opening Hours

Wednesday	3pm - 9pm
Thursday	3pm - 9pm
Friday	3pm - 9pm
Saturday	1pm - 9pm
Sunday	1pm - 9pm

Telephone

+17175178439

Website

http://www.nikkiscustard.com/, https://nikkiscustard.start.page/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nikki's Custard posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.