Tortuga Sandwich Shop

10/13/2026

This weeks special is the Quesa-Dill-A. Roast turkey, avocado, dill havarti cheese, and dill pickles. Served folded into a large flour tortilla, griddled until crispy. Served with dill aioli for dipping. $15

10/07/2026

I recognize the decor

10/07/2026

Come try this week’s awesome special The Truffle Shuffle. Shredded beef brisket, caramelized onions, melted provolone, truffle aioli served on warm French bread. Served with a cup of au jus for dipping.

10/06/2026

This week’s special is The Truffle Shuffle. Shredded beef brisket, dark caramelized onions, melted provolone and truffle aioli served on French bread with a cup of au jus for dipping. $19

09/30/2026

Have you tried The Gazzo? Roast pork, garlicky sautéed spinach, garlic aioli, roasted red peppers, melted provolone. This sandwich will make you feel better about all of your life choices.

09/16/2026

Our current menu has 3 great options for steak lovers, all made with thinly sliced and marinated ribeye. The Chino, The Chivito and The Vaquero. Come try one today!

09/15/2026

Did you know that our favorite veg sandwich is back? The Salmita features grilled zucchini, salsa Veracruz, goat cheese, fresh avocado and spinach on toasted ciabatta.

09/11/2026

09/08/2026

We are now open at our new home in Kenmore!

09/01/2026

Just putting the finishing touches on the restaurant. We have not received our Erie County permit yet but it should be coming this week. Our grand opening will be Tuesday 9/8!