Key Lime Pie Lady

Call Directions

Key Lime Pie Lady Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Key Lime Pie Lady, 81905 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL.

Craving something perfectly sweet with just a little bit of tart? Maybe a signature Key Lime Pie? This is your sign. 💚He...
09/17/2026

Craving something perfectly sweet with just a little bit of tart? Maybe a signature Key Lime Pie? This is your sign. 💚

Head to one of our vendors throughout the Florida Keys and get your fix!

Traditional. Handmade. Delicious.
And we stand by it! Come give our pies a try. 🙌🏼

Look for our logo! 💚 You can find Key Lime Pie Lady at select locations throughout the Florida Keys — bringing authentic...
09/01/2026

Look for our logo! 💚 You can find Key Lime Pie Lady at select locations throughout the Florida Keys — bringing authentic key lime pie to your favorite island stops.

Want to know exactly where to grab one?
Visit 👉 www.keylimepielady.com and check out our Vendors page for the full list.🌴

Our classic Key Lime Pie is calling your name! 🍋🥧Traditional, handmade, and completely delicious. Each pie features a th...
08/18/2026

Our classic Key Lime Pie is calling your name! 🍋🥧

Traditional, handmade, and completely delicious. Each pie features a thick homemade graham cracker crust, a just-enough-tart key lime filling, and a decadent, creamy whipped topping. Locally crafted right here in the Florida Keys! 🌴

Find a vendor near you by visiting our website: www.keylimepielady.com

Summer in the Florida Keys is no joke. ☀️ We may be a little biased, but we think the best way to cool off is with one o...
07/19/2026

Summer in the Florida Keys is no joke. ☀️ We may be a little biased, but we think the best way to cool off is with one of our delicious Key Lime Pie treats. 😋

We’ve got options! Grab a pint of our creamy Key Lime Pie Ice Cream, packed with pie chunks and graham cracker pieces, or treat yourself to one of our chocolate-dipped Key Lime Pie Bars on a stick. Either way, you’re in for the perfect sweet-and-tangy treat.

Want to find a vendor near you? Head to www.keylimepielady.com to see where you can grab yours! 🍋💚

🍋 Craving the taste of summer?Our famous Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is waiting for you! From creamy pints loaded with graham...
07/07/2026

🍋 Craving the taste of summer?

Our famous Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is waiting for you! From creamy pints loaded with graham cracker pieces and buttery pie chunks to our chocolate-dipped Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Bars, there’s a sweet treat with your name on it.

Visit keylimepielady.com and check out our Vendors page to find the location closest to you. Stop by, grab a treat, and taste why it’s a Florida Keys favorite! ☀️🍦💛

Savor the taste of the Florida Keys with our traditional Key Lime Pie. 🍋🥧 Locally crafted in Islamorada and made with lo...
06/23/2026

Savor the taste of the Florida Keys with our traditional Key Lime Pie. 🍋🥧 Locally crafted in Islamorada and made with love, it’s a true Keys classic.

Head to www.keylimepielady.com to find a vendor near you! 🌴

Summer just got a whole lot sweeter! ☀️🌴🍦Cool off with a taste of the Florida Keys! Our Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is packed...
06/06/2026

Summer just got a whole lot sweeter! ☀️🌴🍦

Cool off with a taste of the Florida Keys! Our Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is packed with creamy key lime goodness, buttery pie chunks, and crunchy graham cracker cookie pieces in every bite. And if you’re on the go, our chocolate-dipped Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Bars are the perfect sweet-and-tangy summer treat.

📍 Locally crafted in the Florida Keys
🥧 Made with our famous Key Lime Pie
🍦 Available at select vendors and retailers

Tag someone who needs to cool off with some Key Lime Pie Ice Cream! 😋

Ready to cool off? 🍋✨ Our Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is here and it’s everything you’re craving—rich, creamy, and loaded wit...
05/06/2026

Ready to cool off? 🍋✨ Our Key Lime Pie Ice Cream is here and it’s everything you’re craving—rich, creamy, and loaded with graham cracker cookies & buttery pie chunks. Grab a pint or treat yourself to a chocolate-dipped bar for that perfect sweet-meets-tangy bite.

Locally crafted in the Florida Keys 💛
Find a vendor near you: keylimepielady.com

Key Lime Pie… but make it ice cream 🍋🍦🤍Creamy, tangy, and loaded with graham cracker cookies & real pie chunks—this is y...
04/16/2026

Key Lime Pie… but make it ice cream 🍋🍦🤍

Creamy, tangy, and loaded with graham cracker cookies & real pie chunks—this is your new go-to treat. Or grab a chocolate dipped bar if you’re feeling extra fun!

Locally crafted in the Florida Keys and ready for you.🌴

Find a vendor near you at keylimepielady.com

GLUTEN-FREE — just look for the label 💛Our gluten-free Key Lime Pie is made with almond flour and crafted right here in ...
04/04/2026

GLUTEN-FREE — just look for the label 💛

Our gluten-free Key Lime Pie is made with almond flour and crafted right here in the Florida Keys—so you get that same creamy, tangy flavor you love, just without the gluten.

Available now at the Trading Post in Islamorada 🌴

Address

81905 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL
33036

Telephone

+13053939053

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Key Lime Pie Lady posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share