Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs In the Bread & Crust We Trust

Best Sub Sandwich – 2 Years Running” Idaho Falls Magazine Dining Awards We prepare the best, freshest dough daily.

Toppings come and go, and your selection is probably terrific, but that’s not where the goodness comes in a pizza or a sub. The dough is the difference; it’s the start to your culinary masterpiece. At Papa Kelsey’s, your unique, delicious pizza or sub starts early in the morning, before many of the other shops have even opened the door. So, whether dining in, delivery or take out, discover what makes Papa Kelsey different from the start.

🚔 When IFPD rolls in for breakfast… you know you’re doing something right! 🌯🥪We love seeing our Idaho Falls Police Depar...
10/08/2026

🚔 When IFPD rolls in for breakfast… you know you’re doing something right! 🌯🥪

We love seeing our Idaho Falls Police Department stopping by Papa Kelsey’s! Thanks for all you do to keep our community safe — and for choosing us to fuel the morning. 💙

🌯 Some of the best breakfast burritos in town
🥪 Award-winning, oven-baked subs
🍞 Fresh bread made right here in our store

Great food. Great people. Great community.

Thanks for coming in, IFPD — we love having you at Papa Kelsey’s! 🚔❤️

10/07/2026

🍞 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA WINNER! 🍞

This week’s trivia answer was C — 19,550 pounds of flour!
That’s how much Papa Kelsey’s uses in just one quarter to bake our fresh bread in-house.

🎉 Congrats to Richard Snyder!
He’s the winner of this week’s Tuesday Trivia and scored a FREE Half Sub of his choice from Papa Kelsey’s Idaho Falls.

Thanks to everyone who played — come back next Tuesday for another chance to win!

🍞 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA! 🍞Every day at Papa Kelsey’s, we’re making and baking our fresh bread right here in-house...
10/06/2026

🍞 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA! 🍞

Every day at Papa Kelsey’s, we’re making and baking our fresh bread right here in-house!

But have you ever wondered just how much flour that takes? 🤔

How many POUNDS OF FLOUR does Papa Kelsey’s use in just ONE QUARTER (3 months) making our fresh bread?

A. 12,750 lbs.
B. 16,250 lbs.
C. 19,550 lbs.
D. 23,500 lbs.

👇 Drop your guess in the comments!

No asking one of our employees! 😂

We’ll reveal the answer tomorrow!

You might be surprised just how much flour goes into making that famous Papa Kelsey’s bread — and one lucky winner will score a FREE Half Sub of their choice from Papa Kelsey’s Idaho Falls!

🍕🎉 OCTOBER IS NATIONAL PIZZA MONTH! 🎉🍕And we can’t think of a better way to celebrate than with a fresh, hot Papa Kelsey...
10/03/2026

🍕🎉 OCTOBER IS NATIONAL PIZZA MONTH! 🎉🍕

And we can’t think of a better way to celebrate than with a fresh, hot Papa Kelsey’s pizza!

🍕 Choose from any of our large specialty pizzas loaded with your favorite combinations…

OR…

🔥 CREATE YOUR OWN! Pick your favorite toppings and build the pizza exactly the way you like it.

Whether you’re feeding the family, watching the game, or just craving some seriously good pizza, National Pizza Month is the perfect excuse!

👇 Tell us in the comments: What toppings are going on YOUR perfect Papa Kelsey’s pizza?

Hungry? Order ahead 😊
📱 Phone: (208) 523-3136
🌐 Online: www.papakelseyspizzasubs.com

🍕 Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs — Idaho Falls

😍 LET PAPA KELSEY'S FEED THE CROWD! 😍Planning an office lunch, business meeting, family gathering, team event, or party?...
10/01/2026

😍 LET PAPA KELSEY'S FEED THE CROWD! 😍

Planning an office lunch, business meeting, family gathering, team event, or party? Make it easy—and delicious—with Papa Kelsey’s!

We’ve got something for everyone:
🥪 Our amazing oven-baked subs
🍕 Fresh, hot pizzas
🥗 Delicious salads
🍟 And plenty of sides to complete the meal!

Whether you’re feeding a few people at the office or a whole crowd, Papa Kelsey’s can help make mealtime the easiest part of your event.

📞 Give us a call and let us help you put together the perfect order.
208-523-3136

🤳 Or you can order online at: papakelseyspizzasubs.com

Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs — Fresh food. Great flavor. Happy crowds.

🔥 THE ORIGINAL OVEN-BAKED SUB — SINCE 1984! 🔥Before toasted subs were everywhere… Papa Kelsey’s was already baking them ...
09/30/2026

🔥 THE ORIGINAL OVEN-BAKED SUB — SINCE 1984! 🔥

Before toasted subs were everywhere… Papa Kelsey’s was already baking them hot and fresh! 🥖🔥

Since 1984, the Papa Kelsey’s oven-baked sub has been all about fresh bread, quality meats and cheeses, loaded with your favorite toppings, then baked to hot, melty perfection.

More than 40 years later, we’re still doing it the way we know best. ❤️

🥖 Fresh bread
🧀 Melted cheese
🥩 Quality meats
🔥 Oven-baked goodness

Papa Kelsey’s — The Original Oven-Baked Sub since 1984.

👇 What’s YOUR all-time favorite Papa Kelsey’s sub

09/30/2026

🦃 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA WINNER! 🍕

We asked how many pounds of turkey Papa Kelsey’s slices up in an average quarter…

Answer: C — 3,500 pounds!

That’s a lot of turkey — no wonder our famous Turkey Supreme is such a fan favorite. Our customers really do love that fresh‑sliced flavor! 😍

🎉 Congrats to Shauna Simpson! You’re this week’s lucky winner of a FREE Half Sub from Papa Kelsey’s Idaho Falls!

Thanks to everyone who played — stay tuned for next week’s trivia and another chance to win!

🦃 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA!Papa Kelsey’s slices up a whole lot of fresh turkey every quarter — but how much are we t...
09/29/2026

🦃 PAPA KELSEY’S TUESDAY TRIVIA!

Papa Kelsey’s slices up a whole lot of fresh turkey every quarter — but how much are we talking?

❓ How many pounds of turkey does Papa Kelsey’s slice up in an average quarter?

A. 1,500 lbs.
B. 2,500 lbs.
C. 3,500 lbs.
D. 5,000 lbs.

Drop your answer — A, B, C or D — in the comments.
We’ll reveal the correct answer and pick one lucky winner for a FREE Half Sub from Papa Kelsey’s Idaho Falls!

Hint: It’s more turkey than you’d expect… 🦃💛

🍂🍕 It’s a perfect fall Saturday in Idaho Falls! 🍁Cooler weather, changing leaves, football on TV… and something hot and ...
09/26/2026

🍂🍕 It’s a perfect fall Saturday in Idaho Falls! 🍁

Cooler weather, changing leaves, football on TV… and something hot and fresh from Papa Kelsey’s!

Whether you’re craving a homemade sub, a hot pizza, crispy fries, or one of our fresh salads, let us take care of lunch or dinner today.

🍕 Pizza
🥪 Fresh-made subs
🍟 Hot & crispy fries
🥗 Fresh salads

What sounds good on a fall Saturday — PIZZA or SUBS? 👇

Come see us at Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs and make your Saturday a little more delicious! 🍂❤️

💗 HAPPY NATIONAL DAUGHTER DAY! 💗Today we celebrate the daughters who bring so much love, laughter, joy, and a little ext...
09/25/2026

💗 HAPPY NATIONAL DAUGHTER DAY! 💗

Today we celebrate the daughters who bring so much love, laughter, joy, and a little extra sass into our lives! 😊

From all of us at Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs, we hope you take a moment today to let your daughter know just how much she means to you.

🍕 Better yet… bring her to Papa Kelsey’s and celebrate over her favorite pizza, sub, or salad!

👇 Parents, tell us in the comments—what’s one thing you LOVE about your daughter? Bonus points if you tag her! ❤️

Happy National Daughters Day from the Papa Kelsey’s family!

Address

2285 E 17th Street
Idaho Falls, ID
83404

Opening Hours

Monday 7am - 9pm
Tuesday 7am - 9pm
Wednesday 7am - 9pm
Thursday 7am - 9pm
Friday 7am - 10pm
Saturday 7am - 10pm

Telephone

+12085233136

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category