Papa's Ice Cream Cottage

Call Directions Contact the restaurant

Papa's Ice Cream Cottage We are a simple but delicious ice cream shop that serves traditional homemade ice cream treats.

10/12/2026

We are officially closed for the season!! However we are still taking ice cream sandwich orders up to tomorrow with pick up being later this week. Do not call your order in, we are only accepting orders through messenger at this time.

🚨Update on our last day!! We are officially out of soft serve ice cream!! 🚨

10/12/2026

🍦Tomorrow will be our last day of the 2026 Ice Cream Season! We will be offering FREE chocolate and vanilla soft serve (up to a med) plus FREE hotdogs 🌭 while supplies last!
🍁The homemade maple soft serve was a HUGE success that we just kept running out before we could make more! With such a huge demand, we decided to go out of our way to purchase more ice cream just to make maple for everyone to enjoy! 🍁
🍨We will have soft serve for purchase by the pints to keep you happy throughout the winter. All other frozen treats other than maple and yogurt will be 50% off as well! Don’t forget to order your ice cream sandwiches, pickup will be mid to late week for all ice cream sandwich orders taken after today.
🙂Come say goodbye to our girls and treat yourself to one last frozen treat!

🍁🍦 A LITTLE TASTE OF PENNSYLVANIA FALL! 🍦🍁We’re excited to introduce our NEW Homemade Maple Soft Serve! 🍂Made right here...
10/09/2026

🍁🍦 A LITTLE TASTE OF PENNSYLVANIA FALL! 🍦🍁

We’re excited to introduce our NEW Homemade Maple Soft Serve! 🍂

Made right here in-house at Papa’s Ice Cream Cottage using REAL Pennsylvania maple syrup!

Rich, creamy, smooth, and bursting with that delicious, authentic maple flavor. No better way to celebrate fall than with a sweet taste of Pennsylvania! 🧡

🍁Locally inspired. Homemade with love. Absolutely delicious 🍁

🍓 We are bringing Strawberry Yogurt back one last time before the season ends! 🍓Twist with vanilla for a more strawberri...
10/02/2026

🍓 We are bringing Strawberry Yogurt back one last time before the season ends! 🍓
Twist with vanilla for a more strawberries and cream or enjoy just the yogurt by itself 🍦
The specialty yogurt sundae is a MUST HAVE! Layered sundae with yogurt, marshmallow drizzle, crushed shortbread cookies, strawberry crumble and whipped cream!! 🍓🍦🤤

🍎🍦 THEY’RE BACK! 🍦🍎It’s our 2nd Annual Apple C***r Floats at The Cottage! 🍂Made with fresh local apple c***r from Rickar...
09/25/2026

🍎🍦 THEY’RE BACK! 🍦🍎

It’s our 2nd Annual Apple C***r Floats at The Cottage! 🍂

Made with fresh local apple c***r from Rickards C***r Mill and our creamy vanilla soft serve — it’s the perfect taste of fall in a cup! Served with caramel drizzle and whipped cream🍎🍦🍁

If you loved them last year, you know how good they are… and if you missed them, now’s your chance!

Back at the window for fall! 🍂

🍎🍂 APPLE CIDER… BUT MAKE IT SOFT SERVE! 🍦Our Spiced Apple C***r Soft Serve is back at the window! Sweet, creamy and pack...
09/22/2026

🍎🍂 APPLE CIDER… BUT MAKE IT SOFT SERVE! 🍦
Our Spiced Apple C***r Soft Serve is back at the window! Sweet, creamy and packed with those cozy fall flavors. 🤤

🎃 Fall just hit the window! 🍂Pumpkin Pie Frozen Yogurt is here! Creamy, smooth, and packed with that classic pumpkin-spi...
09/15/2026

🎃 Fall just hit the window! 🍂
Pumpkin Pie Frozen Yogurt is here! Creamy, smooth, and packed with that classic pumpkin-spice flavor. 🎃🥧
The specialty yogurt sundae is a Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake Sundae! Pumpkin pie yogurt with cheesecake bites in a caramel drizzled cup, topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle and cinnamon 🤤

🥨🍦 Caramel Sea Salt Pretzel Yogurt is back at the window! 🍦🥨That perfect mix of sweet, salty & creamy is here! 😋 Our Car...
09/06/2026

🥨🍦 Caramel Sea Salt Pretzel Yogurt is back at the window! 🍦🥨

That perfect mix of sweet, salty & creamy is here! 😋 Our Caramel Sea Salt Pretzel Soft-Serve Yogurt is delicious all on its own—or make it even better twisted with our classic Vanilla Soft Serve!

Caramel + sea salt + pretzel + vanilla = a combo you NEED to try!

The specialty yogurt is layered with hot caramel, crushed pretzels, whipped cream, candied caramel pieces AND a caramel chew on top!

A little cooler outside means it’s time for a flavor with a little more cozy! ☕️🍦Espresso Soft-Serve Yogurt ☕️🍦Enjoy it ...
08/20/2026

A little cooler outside means it’s time for a flavor with a little more cozy!
☕️🍦Espresso Soft-Serve Yogurt ☕️🍦
Enjoy it by itself or twist it with chocolate for the perfect creamy mocha combination. 🤎
The specialty yogurt sundae is one of our most popular sundaes! Layered with your choice of hot fudge or caramel, crushed heath bar, biscoff cookie crumbles and whipped cream on top 🤤

🥥🍍 A TROPICAL TWIST JUST HIT THE WINDOW! 🌴We’re now serving Coconut Milk Probiotic Frozen Soft-Serve Yogurt — and it get...
08/07/2026

🥥🍍 A TROPICAL TWIST JUST HIT THE WINDOW! 🌴

We’re now serving Coconut Milk Probiotic Frozen Soft-Serve Yogurt — and it gets even better…

TWIST IT with Pineapple Dole Whip! 🍍🥥

Creamy coconut + refreshing pineapple = one seriously delicious tropical twist! 🌴☀️

Try it straight, try it twisted… just make sure you try it! 😋

Our Coconut Milk Soft Serve contains 5 Live Active Culture strain, including 3 Probiotics as well as being:

All Natural
Gluten Free
Vegan
Soy Free
Dairy Free

Address

1800 Fair Avenue
Honesdale, PA
18431

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 9pm
Tuesday 12pm - 9pm
Wednesday 12pm - 9pm
Thursday 12pm - 9pm
Friday 12pm - 9pm
Saturday 12pm - 9pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Telephone

+15706164449

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Papa's Ice Cream Cottage posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Papa's Ice Cream Cottage:

Shortcuts

Share

Category