Nina's Custard

06/22/2025

04/09/2025

Everything must go.

View information about this sale in Getzville, NY. The sale starts Thursday, April 10 and runs through Saturday, April 12. It is being run by The Stock Exchange Estate Sales.

02/23/2025

Hey there – to the young couple who dined with us tonight at My Tomato Pie: we understand that mistakes happen. Our cameras caught your visit, and while we’re not sharing any photos or video publicly at this time, we kindly ask that you swing by and settle your bill. You can even use the QR code on the bottom of your check for a quick payment. We appreciate your prompt attention and look forward to clearing this up. Thank you! https://order.toasttab.com/pay/mytomatopie/dc5051e5-d94c-47aa-b198-d6272cda2908/tab

02/01/2025

🍦 Own a Piece of Nina’s Custard History! 🍦

Though our doors may be closed, the memories live on! ❤️ Now, you can take a sweet piece of Nina’s with you by grabbing your very own Nina’s Custard Tee! 🍦👕

Shop now: https://ninas-custard.spiritsale.com/

Wear it with pride and keep the nostalgia alive! 🏡✨ Share your favorite Nina’s moments with us in the comments! ⬇️

Your local ice cream and food restaurant.

01/01/2025

🍦 Exciting News from Nina's Custard! 🍦

Missed your chance to snag a Nina's Shirt on our last day? No worries! We've set up a special online store just for you. 🎉

👉 Visit https://ninas-custard.spiritsale.com/ now to grab your favorite Nina's gear!

📅 Hurry! The store is only open for a limited time, and all items will be delivered by the end of the month. Don’t miss out—shop now and rep Nina’s in style!

Order apparel online today

01/01/2025

📣 Thank You for 34+ Incredible Years! 💛🍦

As we close this chapter, we want to express our heartfelt gratitude for 34 amazing years of memories, laughs, and, of course, custard. The retirement congratulations and kind words from so many of you have been overwhelming—we will truly miss each and every one of you.

To our loyal customers, thank you for being the heart and soul of Nina’s Custard. You’ve made every moment worth it.

To the thousands of employees who became part of the Nina’s family—many of you starting your first job here—thank you for your hard work, smiles, and dedication over the years.

It’s been a great run, and we couldn’t have done it without you all.

With love and gratitude,
The Lettieri & Scioli Families ❤️

12/30/2024

📣 Today is the Day!

It’s Nina’s last day in business, and we want to thank everyone for the incredible support over the years. 🧡

Stop by today to celebrate with us and grab your favorites one last time – but don’t wait until 10 p.m.! We’re expecting to run out of items as the day goes on.

Let’s make it a memorable send-off for Nina. See you soon! 🎉

12/26/2024

Thanks for the amazing video. You will be missed. Thanks for the memories. Last day Monday.

Check out Julie Gem’s video.

11/30/2024

So many people are coming in looking for tee shirts. We have a limited supply available. https://ninascustard.com/order/ninascustard/item-small-white-gildan_981e7a0a-54d8-48b5-814c-98cd76ebb798

11/27/2024

🌟 Bittersweet Announcement 🌟

After decades of serving smiles, scoops, and sweet memories, Nina's Custard will be closing its doors on December 30th as Susan and Mary embark on their well-deserved retirement journey.

It has been our honor and joy to be part of your celebrations, family traditions, and everyday treats. From first dates to after-school ice cream runs, we’ve cherished every moment with you, our loyal customers and friends.

As we prepare to say goodbye, we invite you to stop by and enjoy your favorite treats one last time. Let’s make these final weeks as sweet as ever!

Thank you for making Nina's Custard a beloved part of the community. Susan and Mary look forward to this next chapter but will always hold your love and support close to their hearts.

See you soon—let’s make these last scoops unforgettable! 🍦❤️

Andrew Galarneau

05/14/2024

Nina's is now open later.
Sunday 12-9pm
Monday- Saturday 11am -10 pm