Cosentino's Ristorante

Call Directions Website

Cosentino's Ristorante Family owned business since 1996, Serving Classic Italian Cuisine In 1978 Marylou “Nonna” and Joe “Uncle Joe” Cosentino started a restaurant from scratch.

The result was “Uncle Joe’s” which has grown from a one room pizzeria with a small assortment of pizza and subs to a full service restaurant. Uncle Joe’s “Geneva’s Oldest Pizzeria” has a fine selection of pizza, pasta, subs, salads and wings. In 1996 Joe and Marylou purchased the former Josephine’s and Alice’s restaurant and recreated it as Nonna Cosentino’s Trattoria. They continued serving the same homemade tomato sauce, hand rolled meatballs and fresh Italian bread made in the Uncle Joe’s bakery. Opening Nonna’s gave them the opportunity to provide more of the same quality, consistency and friendly atmosphere that they were known for and a wider variety of Italian cuisine. In 1991 Joe and Marylou’s oldest of six children Bill and his wife Nancy left their hometown of Geneva for Virginia Beach, VA. Bill continued his career as a civilian firefighter for the United States Government, which began at the Seneca Army Depot in 1984. They had a son Dominick and were offered an extraordinary opportunity to work at the Naval Air Station Sigonella, Sicily. Bill, Nancy and Dominick lived in Motta Sant’ Anastasia for five years. During their time there they formed a love for the families and friends they met as well as the Italian culture. After returning to the United States, Bill retired after 30 years of service as Assistant Fire Chief and decided to come home to Geneva and venture into the restaurant business to carry on the family tradition that Joe and Marylou started so many years ago. Today, the name has changed a bit but our customers can still expect the same quality and consistency. We welcome you and hope you find Cosentino’s Ristorante to be a delicious experience for you and your family. Mangia Bene! Thank you from Bill, Nancy, Dominick
And the
Staff at Cosentino’s

Cosentino's Ristorante
10/17/2026

Cosentino's Ristorante

🍝 Make your Wednesday a little more Italian!Gather your favorite people and let Cosentino’s Ristorante take care of dinn...
10/14/2026

🍝 Make your Wednesday a little more Italian!

Gather your favorite people and let Cosentino’s Ristorante take care of dinner. A cozy evening, a delicious meal, and good company just what the middle of the week needs. 🍷

We look forward to welcoming you tonight! ❤️

At Cosentino's Ristorante we start with fresh, carefully sourced ingredients so every dish tastes consistent and true. S...
10/11/2026

At Cosentino's Ristorante we start with fresh, carefully sourced ingredients so every dish tastes consistent and true. Stop by for classic Italian flavors made with care in Geneva. 🍽

10/09/2026
10/09/2026

We welcome you like neighbors and serve the Italian classics you know and trust. Stop by Cosentino’s near 1 Railroad Place in Geneva for a familiar meal that hits the spot every time. Reserve a table or order online: https://wix.to/0Jmz5Nl 🍝🇮🇹🙂

What a beautiful day!
10/07/2026

What a beautiful day!

Autumn Beet Salad with Apples!
10/02/2026

Autumn Beet Salad with Apples!

Thirsty Thursday! Cosentino's Ristorante
10/01/2026

Thirsty Thursday! Cosentino's Ristorante

Make your reservation!
09/27/2026

Make your reservation!

🍝 DINE OUT & MAKE A DIFFERENCE! ❤️

Join us at Cosentino’s Ristorante this Wednesday, September 30th for a special P.E.O. Fundraiser!

Enjoy a delicious dinner while supporting a wonderful cause! 10% of all dinner proceeds will be donated to the Geneva Chapter of P.E.O. to help provide scholarships, grants and loans for women and girls. 🎓✨

📅 Wednesday, September 30
🍷 Dinner at Cosentino’s
❤️ 10% of dinner proceeds donated to P.E.O.

Make your reservation, bring your appetite, and help us give back to our community!

📞 315-789-1638
📍 Cosentino’s Ristorante, Geneva

Reservations are filling up—call today! 🍝🥂

Address

1 Railroad Place
Geneva, NY
14456

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 9pm
Thursday 4pm - 9pm
Friday 4pm - 9pm
Saturday 4pm - 9pm
Sunday 4pm - 9pm

Telephone

+13157891638

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cosentino's Ristorante posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category