Coterie Pizza

06/05/2026

We are celebrating four years of serving pizza in Garrett this weekend! Pixie Pies flavor of the week is birthday cake. Thank you for the incredible support as we work on fulfilling our mission: respect the craft, serve the community, build a coterie.

06/04/2026

It's that time of year again; Reader's Choice awards time! Please cast us a vote once a day until the 16th if we're your favorite Dekalb County pizza place! We appreciate our customers and love bringing the best pizza we can make to the area!

Your browser is out of date and potentially vulnerable to security risks.We recommend switching to one of the following browsers:

06/01/2026

The last pizza fired after a marathon of events this week! Thank you to everyone who came out to the restaurant or shared kind words in a backyard enjoying pizza!

05/14/2026

We are extremely excited about this opportunity and deeply grateful for the chance to expand and grow.

05/05/2026

This Friday the dining room will be closing at 5:30 for a private event. Takeout and all online ordering will still be available.

05/04/2026

What are some of the most unique toppings you've ever had on a pizza?

04/29/2026

Have you heard about our customizable pizza catering services? We bring our culinary pizza expertise to weddings, open houses, recital dinners, corporate events, and factory parties, and would be honored to host your next gathering.

04/02/2026

Pixie Pies Carrot cake available this week! Also a friendly reminder we are closed on Easter Sunday to give our staff a much needed day off with their families.

03/12/2026

Please welcome our newest future dishwasher. Mollyanne is still using the excuse she was only born yesterday, but we hope to have her trained up in the next 15 years. Even a bigger shoutout to the staff for keeping the pizza cranking in my absence!

03/11/2026

Storming into St. Patty’s weekend in style:
Pixie Pies cheesecake: Lucky Charms, and Irish Cream.
Also on tap, a fresh Irish Red from Sullivan’s Brewery.