Tito’s Cheesecakery

10/03/2026

What's going on our Rican Vegan familia 🙌🏽 Catering season is here 🔥

We're out catering a private wedding today 🇵🇷 Award-winning Latin flavors, 100% gluten free. Booking events now — message us for your date 🤤 Non vegans get down with our food 👀

•100% GLUTEN FREE•

09/29/2026

BIG NEWS, CRESTVIEW!

Tito’s Cheesecakery is excited to announce our NEWEST restaurant partnership — Nadine's Restaurant!

Formerly The Hub, Nadine’s Restaurant will be opening its doors on October 1st at 346 W. James Lee Blvd. in Crestview!

We’re incredibly grateful for another local restaurant choosing to partner with Tito’s and give their customers the opportunity to finish their meal with a slice of our cheesecake.

Make sure you show Nadine’s Restaurant some love, follow their new page, and stop by after they open to check out what they have cooking!

09/28/2026

IT’S THAT TIME OF YEAR AGAIN!

Where are all my pumpkin spice lovers at?!

Tito’s Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake!

We start with a Biscoff cookie crust, then blend our homemade pumpkin spice mixture into part of our signature cheesecake batter. From there, we swirl it together with our original cheesecake filling, giving you that beautiful marbled look and the perfect combination of creamy cheesecake and warm fall spices.

Pumpkin Spice + Tito’s Cheesecake = the ultimate fall combination!

Tito’s Cheesecakery — bringing two favorites together for one amazing fall treat! 😋

Message us for ordering information!

09/26/2026

Tomorrow is the big day for Crestview MEAT Masters!

If you haven’t tried Tito’s Cheesecakery yet, here’s your perfect chance! Whether you’re craving a slice, a whole cheesecake…or BOTH, Crestview Meat Masters will have you covered!

Tito’s Cheesecakes Available:
• Traditional Cheesecake
• Chocolate Swirl Cheesecake
• Cookies & Cream Cheesecake
• Biscoff Cookie Cheesecake
• Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake
• Apple Cinnamon Cheesecake
• Key Lime Cheesecake
• Blueberry Crumble Cheesecake

Make sure you stop by and support another locally owned Crestview business while checking out the wide variety of products Crestview Meat Masters will have to offer.

And while you’re there… don’t forget the cheesecake!

We’re excited to have Crestview Meat Masters as Tito’s exclusive retail location for whole cheesecakes!

09/21/2026

Come see what all the talk is about! Tito’s Cheesecakery is your go-to for satisfying that sweet craving with delicious, locally made cheesecake.

Message us for ordering information or visit www.titoscheesecakeryllc.com.

You can also enjoy our cheesecake by the slice at these amazing local partner restaurants:

Bamboo Sushi and Hibachi
Bamboo Sushi Bar. Hibachi Express Niceville
Bamboo Sushi and Hibachi Fort Walton Beach
The Local's Eatery
PAPA's Smokehouse
The Shack Waterfront Seafood Restaurant

Exciting news - beginning Saturday, September 26, you’ll also be able to purchase whole cheesecakes and individual slices at Crestview MEAT Masters!

Enjoy the best cheesecake in the area while supporting these incredible local businesses. Thank you for continuing to support Tito’s Cheesecakery!

09/20/2026

Don’t miss out! Your only regret will be not trying Tito’s Cheesecakery sooner!

Sometimes, one just isn’t enough! If you haven’t tried any flavor of Cheesecake from Tito’s Cheesecakery, you’re absolutely, 100% missing out!

Every flavor is THAT GOOD!!!

09/19/2026

I want to take a moment to recognize my beautiful wife—the official taste tester and biggest supporter of Tito’s Cheesecakery.

Thank you for always believing in me, pushing me forward, and encouraging me when I need it most. You’re always willing to help, even when it means putting your own plans aside. Tito’s wouldn’t be what it is today without you by my side.

I’m just as proud of everything you’ve built with Kneaded Relief Massage and Bodywork’s ! The care you show people and the dedication you put into your work are part of what makes your business so special. You work hard to help others feel their best, and I love seeing you succeed.

Thank you for being my partner through all of this. I love you, and I’m so proud of you!

09/17/2026

The man behind those delicious cheesecakes — Tito!

What an honor it was to be part of The Finest on the Emerald Coast Community’s Choice Awards!

To be recognized as Top 3 in the area in TWO different categories — Bakery and Dessert — in less than two years of being in business truly means the world to me!

Thank you to everyone who has been part of this journey — whether you’ve ordered a cheesecake, grabbed a slice at one of our partner locations, shared a post, recommended us to someone, or simply cheered us on. Your support is what has made all of this possible.

Thank you from Tito’s Cheesecakery!

09/07/2026

ASSORTED CHEESECAKES AVAILABLE!

Each assorted cheesecake includes 2 slices of each flavor:

• Biscoff Cookie
• Chocolate Hazelnut
• Key Lime
• Blueberry Crumble
• Guava Swirl
• White Chocolate Raspberry

12 slices • 6 flavors • $60

ONLY 4 AVAILABLE! First come, first served!

Crestview: Deliveries start tomorrow!

Outside of Crestview: Message us with your location and we’ll confirm delivery availability.

Send us a message to claim yours before they’re gone!

09/03/2026

Oatmeal Crème Pie Cheesecake!!

We start with an iced oatmeal cookie crust, fold Oatmeal Crème Pie crumbs right into our creamy cheesecake filling, then finish it off with another layer of Oatmeal Crème Pie crumbs on top!

Creamy, nostalgic, and packed with that classic oatmeal crème pie flavor in every bite.

Oatmeal Crème Pie Cheesecake — Tito’s style!