Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop

Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop, Restaurant, 4404 Indianola Avenue, Columbus, OH.
(1)

This burger pairs well with all of its friends in the background 🤙🏽
10/02/2026

This burger pairs well with all of its friends in the background 🤙🏽

New special!Italian Pork Porchettawith fennel pollen and rosemary served on a a hoagie with chimichurri
10/01/2026

New special!
Italian Pork Porchetta
with fennel pollen and rosemary served on a a hoagie with chimichurri

You asked. We listened. We’re officially opening for lunch on Thursdays from 11AM–9PM at the OG Fat Arnie’s.Come get the...
09/30/2026

You asked. We listened. We’re officially opening for lunch on Thursdays from 11AM–9PM at the OG Fat Arnie’s.

Come get the Apollonia. Grab an empanada. Destroy a sandwich. Make questionable decisions before noon.

📍 Fat Arnie’s inside Rafters
Thursday | 11AM–9PM

Thank you Eat Local Ohio for coming to our little restaurant and sharing our food!
09/30/2026

Thank you Eat Local Ohio for coming to our little restaurant and sharing our food!

La Barbosa started off as just another special. 6 months later it is still here but its time is limited. Get it before i...
09/30/2026

La Barbosa started off as just another special. 6 months later it is still here but its time is limited. Get it before it’s gone!

09/28/2026
Lemon Grass Pork Sandwich 1/2lb Pork ribeye with house pickles, mayo and onion on a hoagie bun
09/27/2026

Lemon Grass Pork Sandwich
1/2lb Pork ribeye with house pickles, mayo and onion on a hoagie bun

Ohio State vs. Illinois at noon. Rafters. Fat Arnie’s. Apollonia in hand. Drink nearby.We’re pretty sure this is heaven.
09/26/2026

Ohio State vs. Illinois at noon. Rafters. Fat Arnie’s. Apollonia in hand. Drink nearby.
We’re pretty sure this is heaven.

Pork Belly TacoCured and roasted pork belly, green onion and jalapeno Salsa, pickled green apple, onion and cilantro
09/24/2026

Pork Belly Taco
Cured and roasted pork belly, green onion and jalapeno Salsa, pickled green apple, onion and cilantro

Some sandwiches are lunch. La Barbosa is a character arc.
09/23/2026

Some sandwiches are lunch. La Barbosa is a character arc.

Address

4404 Indianola Avenue
Columbus, OH
43214

Opening Hours

Wednesday 5pm - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 7pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Fat Arnie’s Sandwich Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category