My Old World Bakery

My Old World Bakery We are an old fashioned bakery. I spent 20 years learning at the French Loaf with wonderful pastry chefs from all over.

Pies, cookies, lots of breads (Pepperoni rolls!), many types of pastries from puff paste and sweet dough, random goodies when I get bored, all sizes of cakes from cupcakes to wedding cakes for hundreds. We fry our doughnuts every night, what we don't sell is donated.
`Currently we are the sole purveyor of Ace's K9 Cookies, healthy treats for dogs!

06/03/2025

The bakery is now in new hands. Thank all of you for letting me help in all your celebrations, big and little. It has been a real pleasure.
The new owners are very nice and they are quite excited to begin making DOUGHNUTS for you to enjoy. I will help them for 2 weeks, showing them whatever they care to learn, and maybe get to learn a little as well. They already have 2 bakeries so you are in good hands.

Send a message to learn more

05/31/2025

Micki will be here on Sunday from 11 to 1 if you want to see her one more time!

Send a message to learn more

05/30/2025

This is not easy to write, but it has been a fine 24 years here. Sunday is the last day we will be open as My Old World Bakery. Put in one last order and I will make it if I can. I am keeping the FB page so if I get royally bored who knows what will happen in the future. Even if you do not need anything baked, come on in and say bye.

Send a message to learn more

05/09/2025

Order today for Mother's Day, muffins and coffeecakes will be made Sunday. We have challah, cheese danish, and almond croissants today. It is hard to make only enough for an order! Challah makes very tasty French toast, even better if it is sliced a day early to dry so it soaks up more custard!

04/27/2025

It has been an awesome 24 years but the time has come for a change.The bakery is up for sale, hopefully to someone who will continue the traditional pastries and not start making anything from a mix.
I have met some very fine people and made more than a few friends, made wedding cakes for kids that I have made baby shower cakes before they were born. Made 3 wedding cakes for one woman, she got a ten year anniversary cake this year and told me she finally got it right. Come see me! We are still baking and I will probably have some sort of in house festivities before handing over the keys.

04/13/2025

Easter is next week! Order pies, cakes, cookies, and hot cross buns by Friday noon for Saturday pick up. We will be closed Sunday.

03/07/2025

We have marbled rye today! Limited loaves though. And Pi Day is a week away. order your favorite and celebrate!

02/14/2025

Happy Valentine's Day ! Come in for sweet treats for your favorite people. We will start the day by having chocolate covered strawberries with either semi-sweet or dark.

02/08/2025

We made round pumpernickel for putting dip into. We will have round Vienna bread dough loaves tomorrow.

02/05/2025

Tomorrow we will be closing at 2 . We have assorted pounds of Valentines cookies available as well as many kinds to purchase however you feel like.

01/30/2025

Valentine cookies are making their way into the case. If you want personalized hearts order at least 2 days ahead please.

01/23/2025

The announcement some of you wait all year for! Christmas cookie bags are out at $2 for at least a pound. Random cookies ,there are a couple of nut free bags,they have white tags. Last chance for fruitcakes, half off.

Address

962 Demorest Road
Columbus, OH
43204

Opening Hours

Wednesday 7am - 3pm
Thursday 7am - 3pm
Friday 7am - 3pm
Saturday 7am - 3pm
Sunday 7am - 1pm

Telephone

+16142788046

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Old World Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Category