Upstate Pizzeria

Call Directions Website Contact the restaurant

Upstate Pizzeria New York-Style Pizzeria
(1)

11/03/2026

Check out our November collaboration with Gossip Point the Gossip Point Butter Chicken pizza, available in store, on our website, and over the phone starting today. We had a great time working with Varun and can’t get enough of the butter chicken specialties from his food truck.

Boo! Look who showed up just in time for Halloween! Meet Upstate Jack and Garlic Gary the Ghost!Legend has it that many ...
10/20/2026

Boo! Look who showed up just in time for Halloween! Meet Upstate Jack and Garlic Gary the Ghost!

Legend has it that many years ago, in a little pizzeria in Upstate New York, Jack was finishing up the last pizzas of the night while his buddy Gary was in the back making dough.

Just one minute before closing, an order came in. Jack reluctantly made the pizza, and the two waited for the DoorDash horse and buggy to arrive.

15 minutes later, the door creaked open and a mysterious man in a hooded sweatshirt stepped inside.

“What order are you here for, sir?” Jack asked.

“No order. Looking to place one.”

“Sorry bubs, we closed 14 minutes ago. Just cutting the last pie of the night. We open for lunch at 11 tomorrow.”

The stranger paused.

“What I’m here to order isn’t on the menu.”

“Oh yeah? What’s that?”

“YOUR SOUL!”

The stranger pulled down his hood to reveal a glowing pumpkin head! Before Jack could react, the Headless Horseman shoved him into the pizza oven and baked him to a perfect golden brown.

The Horseman then crept into the back, where Gary was pulling dough out of the mixer.

“Night, Jack!” Gary called without looking up.

But it wasn’t Jack.

The Horseman pushed Gary into the mixer and cranked it to high! Around and around he went until all that remained was a fresh batch of garlic knots and a faint whisper of “don’t forget the garlic butterrrrr…”

Jack and Gary were never seen again.

Well, except for one time every October, when they return to haunt Upstate Pizzeria in the form of delicious pizzas.

From now until Halloween, you can take home Upstate Jack, a cheese pizza with a pepperoni jack-o’-lantern face, or Garlic Gary the Ghost, a garlic pizza with olive eyes, for just $19.99 each!

Happy Halloween from Upstate Pizzeria! And remember, don’t order one minute before close. 🎃👻

Day 1 of International Pizza Expo Columbus
10/11/2026

Day 1 of International Pizza Expo Columbus

Upstate Pizzeria turns THREE on October 9!We’re celebrating October 5–9 with some specials to say thank you:Lunch slices...
10/04/2026

Upstate Pizzeria turns THREE on October 9!

We’re celebrating October 5–9 with some specials to say thank you:

Lunch slices | Monday–Friday, 11 am - 3 p.m.
$1 cheese slices • $3 any other slices on the line

Pickup-only specials | Monday–Thursday, 3 pm - 8:30 pm.
$10 large cheese pizzas • 80¢ wings
Use promo codes PIZZA3YEARS and WINGS3YEARS when ordering through our website/toast or call ahead at 719-985-8848

But this anniversary means more to us than another year on the calendar. We don’t take our existence for granted. So many independent restaurants never make it this far, and seeing the recent wave of closures makes us especially grateful that we still get to do what we love for a living.

To our regulars: knowing your usual order, looking forward to seeing you each week, and catching up on the little details of your lives are some of the best parts of this business. You’ve made this place much more than somewhere to buy pizza.

We’ll be donating 5% of our sales during this celebration to Homeward Pikes Peak, a local nonprofit that helps individuals and families find stable housing and provides addiction treatment, mental health services, and support for lasting recovery. I lost my best friend Dan in April 2022. He was a football team captain, Ivy League grad, husband, father, and was building a promising career in corporate finance when addiction cut his life short. Losing Dan is what pushed me to pack up and move across the country to continue the family tradition of being a pizza man here in Colorado Springs.

We also have a special addition to the menu to announce on October 9. One hint: we had to special-order a cheese that can be hard to source in Colorado: Cooper Sharp.

Thank you for three years of support, conversations, and letting us feed you and your families. It means more than you know.

—Rich

Morning commute to the Pikes Peak Farmers Markets. Only a couple more weeks in the season!
10/03/2026

Morning commute to the Pikes Peak Farmers Markets. Only a couple more weeks in the season!

Thanks for coming in today, was great seeing everyone!
09/26/2026

Thanks for coming in today, was great seeing everyone!

So, I heard Upstate Pizzeria had a Pickle Bacon Ranch Pizza and being a worldy man of sophistication I enjoy all four of those things so we decided to give it a try. I have to say, it is pretty Cluckin delicious.

We also enjoyed the Ribdawg Pizza which has 3 different kinds of pepperoni and just happens to be named after my buddy Jason.

5 Stars! Will definitely be back, just with stretchy pants next time.

09/21/2026

We’re from Upstate New York, the birthplace of the Buffalo wing, and frankly we’re tired of not being part of the conversation when people ask who has the best wings in Colorado Springs.

So over the past year, we’ve been obsessing over them.

A lot of trial and error, a lot of eating wings, and a lot of conversations with wing shop and pizzeria operators from Upstate and Western New York helped us refine the method we use today.

For the longest time, I was completely against par-cooking wings. I was convinced the only “right” way was dropping them raw into 350° oil for about 12 minutes, and that anything else was cheating the customer out of a proper wing.

Turns out I was wrong.

The double-fry method we use now gives us a noticeably better wing: juicy inside, extremely crispy outside, and as a nice bonus, it gets them to the table a little faster too.

We finish them in our house-made Buffalo sauce, which is flavorful, buttery, tangy, and true to the style we grew up eating back home.

We’re confident these belong in the conversation for the best Buffalo wings in the Springs.

And at $13.99 for 10 wings, we’re also trying to keep them reasonable when plenty of places are pushing $2+ per wing.

If you’ve tried them, I’d love to hear what you think. And if you haven’t, come put us to the test

09/09/2026

Crunch that only comes from authentic New York pizza

Michele has been doing an awesome job keeping us stocked with a never ending variety of personal-sized 4” cheesecakes. Y...
08/09/2026

Michele has been doing an awesome job keeping us stocked with a never ending variety of personal-sized 4” cheesecakes. You can order them anytime on our website for pick up or delivery or stop in the shop to satisfy your sweet tooth! We love building strong partnerships with other local small businesses.

A few of the pizzas we sent out this morning before the start of the World Cup match ⚽️🏟️🍕
07/19/2026

A few of the pizzas we sent out this morning before the start of the World Cup match ⚽️🏟️🍕

Address

4621 Austin Bluffs Pkwy
Colorado Springs, CO
80918

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 9pm
Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 9pm

Telephone

+17192121090

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Upstate Pizzeria posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Upstate Pizzeria:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby restaurants