10/20/2026
Boo! Look who showed up just in time for Halloween! Meet Upstate Jack and Garlic Gary the Ghost!
Legend has it that many years ago, in a little pizzeria in Upstate New York, Jack was finishing up the last pizzas of the night while his buddy Gary was in the back making dough.
Just one minute before closing, an order came in. Jack reluctantly made the pizza, and the two waited for the DoorDash horse and buggy to arrive.
15 minutes later, the door creaked open and a mysterious man in a hooded sweatshirt stepped inside.
“What order are you here for, sir?” Jack asked.
“No order. Looking to place one.”
“Sorry bubs, we closed 14 minutes ago. Just cutting the last pie of the night. We open for lunch at 11 tomorrow.”
The stranger paused.
“What I’m here to order isn’t on the menu.”
“Oh yeah? What’s that?”
“YOUR SOUL!”
The stranger pulled down his hood to reveal a glowing pumpkin head! Before Jack could react, the Headless Horseman shoved him into the pizza oven and baked him to a perfect golden brown.
The Horseman then crept into the back, where Gary was pulling dough out of the mixer.
“Night, Jack!” Gary called without looking up.
But it wasn’t Jack.
The Horseman pushed Gary into the mixer and cranked it to high! Around and around he went until all that remained was a fresh batch of garlic knots and a faint whisper of “don’t forget the garlic butterrrrr…”
Jack and Gary were never seen again.
Well, except for one time every October, when they return to haunt Upstate Pizzeria in the form of delicious pizzas.
From now until Halloween, you can take home Upstate Jack, a cheese pizza with a pepperoni jack-o’-lantern face, or Garlic Gary the Ghost, a garlic pizza with olive eyes, for just $19.99 each!
Happy Halloween from Upstate Pizzeria! And remember, don’t order one minute before close. 🎃👻