Red Cup Cafe

06/05/2026

🥧 Fresh-Baked Pies Are Here This Weekend! 🥧

We’ve been busy baking up some sweet treats for you and yours!

✨ Available this weekend:

🍋 Lemon Meringue Pie — $20 whole pie | $5 slice
🍎 Apple Pie — $18 whole pie | $4 slice
🍓 Raspberry Pie — $18 whole pie | $4 slice
🍒 Cherry Pie — $18 whole pie | $4 slice
🍫 French Silk Pie — $20 whole pie | $5 slice
🍌 Banana Cream Pie — $20 whole pie | $5 slice
🫐 Triple Berry Pie — $18 whole pie | $4 slice

Whether you’re looking for a slice with your coffee or a whole pie to take home and share, we’ve got you covered.

⏰ Stop in early—these won’t last long!

See you at Red Cup Café! ❤️🥧☕️

04/20/2026

03/19/2026

I’m so flipping excited to get to meet the cows! Thank you so much, Michelle and Joe Wagner ♥️

01/22/2026

Our Gambit’s Giveaway is still going on! The winner of this special giveaway will receive our first Inner Sweets Society card, which includes a bunch of benefits for the whole year - 10% off every purchase, double stamps on your Crack Corn card, one free Tethan’s chocolate bar every month, invites to special events, and more! To enter, just visit a participating local business, make a purchase, and then ask for a mini Gambit at checkout. Turn in your mini Gambit here for your entry and to take a bolt off the puzzle box — when the puzzle box is open, we’ll pick a winner!

Red Cup Cafe
Duneland Station Deli
Chelle's Boutique & Garage
219 Taproom
Willow
Evexia Salt Cave & Spa
Trusty Spot Records & Tees
Three Wicked Apples
Cheers in Chesterton
Val's Famous Pizza and Grinders
Running Vines Winery

01/15/2026

✨ WE’RE READY FOR A ROARING GOOD TIME ✨
Downtown is about to feel very Great Gatsby this weekend — and Red Cup Café is bringing the Prohibition-era magic ☕🐄

We’re welcoming the mini Highland cows from Wagner’s Ranch AND rolling out a limited-time Roaring 20’s menu you do not want to miss…

⸻

🥃 THE PROHIBITION COFFEE BAR

🖤 The Bootlegger
Classic black coffee — bold, smooth, and straight-up outlaw approved.

💃 The Flapper
A rich, decadent mocha that’s as fabulous as your favorite fringe dress.

🕵️‍♂️ The Speakeasy
A dirty chai with a little mystery and a whole lot of attitude.

⸻

🍰 WEEKEND-ONLY SWEET TREATS

🎩 The Gatsby
Chocolate cocoa muffin served with homemade cherry compote — indulgent, elegant, and straight-up roaring.

🕯️ The After Hours Brownie
Dark, bold espresso brownies — rich, smooth, and a little dangerous.

⸻

🥪 SAVORY SPEAKEASY BITES

🗝️ The Society Lady
House-made egg salad sandwich — classic, creamy, and perfectly proper.

🎶 The Jazz Club
Chicken salad sandwich — smooth, savory, and cool as a trumpet solo.

⸻

Throw on your pearls, grab your best fedora, and come sip, snack, and snap photos with the cutest Highland cows in town.
This weekend only. Downtown never looked so good. 🖤✨

01/10/2026

❄️ Cozy Season = Muffin Season ❄️

Cold outside? We’ve got exactly what your soul needs.

Come warm up at Red Cup Café with a fresh, fluffy chocolate chip muffin topped with strawberry icing and your favorite cozy drink in hand.

It’s sweet, it’s comforting, and it’s basically a hug in muffin form. 🧁

Grab a friend, grab a seat, and let winter slow down for a minute.

11/26/2025

🎄☕ Parade Update + Weekend Plans! ☕🎄

We’re sad the parade was rescheduled too — but hey, it’s the midwest… the place where we drive through blizzards for fun until someone mentions snow in a forecast, and suddenly everything gets canceled. 😂❄️
It’s all good though — we’ll roll with it!

We truly have one of the BEST spots in town to view the parade, and we can’t wait to celebrate with you on the new date: 12/5!

In the meantime…
Small Business Saturday is a BIG deal for all of us local businesses. So don’t let a little weather scare you away — come warm up with us and support your local favorites!

🧁 Fresh muffins
🥪 Sandwiches
☕ Coffee
🍫 Hot chocolate
🍵 Tea
…all the cozy things to kick off your holiday season.

We’re here, we’re festive, and we’re ready to make this weekend magical — snow or no snow! 🎄✨