The Goombah Pizzaiolo

The Goombah Pizzaiolo 🤌🏼🍕🇮🇹🔙🚪❤️✌🏼
We operate out of the Elks Kitchen in Downtown Cape Coral
You don't have to be an Elks member to get take out.

Good morning my Goombah's.As you already know The Fat Cowboy & Motts Life gave us a glowing review and we've been insane...
06/20/2026

Good morning my Goombah's.
As you already know The Fat Cowboy & Motts Life gave us a glowing review and we've been insanely busy over the past few days.
These guys are exemplary human beings and go out of there way to help small businesses and the proof is in the pudding whether you like them or not.
With that being said we are running really low on product, so please understand if some items we run out of or if we sell out fairly early. Theres only so much we can store and being we are closed tomorrow we keep our product tight to ensure the upmost freshness.
All in all get your orders in asap as we could again go on long wait times very soon into opening like yesterday.
Thank you everyone as you all have ultimately made my father's day.

06/18/2026

Everyone who doesn't already know them, go check out The Fat Cowboy & Motts Life they are a wild duo and a great team.

06/18/2026

We’ve eaten a lot of pizza across Southwest Florida, but every once in a while you come across a place that reminds you pizza is more than just food—it’s a craft.

Today that place was Goombahs Pizza in Cape Coral.

Not only was this some of the best pizza we’ve had in SWFL, but the entire experience was something special. We spent time learning about the art of pizza making from Chef Rich, and let me tell you—the knowledge, passion, and experience this man has is absolutely incredible. You can see it in every conversation, every ingredient choice, and most importantly, every pie that comes out of the oven.

What really separates Goombahs from the pack is the variety and attention to detail. Whether you’re a fan of New York Style, New Haven Style, or Chicago Style pizza, they have something for you. Add in multiple sauce options, a huge selection of toppings, and even different varieties of pepperoni to choose from, and you quickly realize this isn’t your average pizza shop.

Every pizza is built with purpose, backed by years of experience and a genuine love for the craft. That’s becoming harder and harder to find these days.

The Fat Cowboy stamp of approval goes on this one. If you’re a pizza lover living in Southwest Florida and you haven’t been to Goombahs yet, move it to the top of your list.

This isn’t just a recommendation—it’s a MUST TRY.

🍕🔥🍕🔥🍕

Have you tried Goombahs? Which style are you ordering first: NY, New Haven, or Chicago?

06/17/2026

🚨 The Goombah Pizzaiolo REVIEW DROPPING TONIGHT AT 6PM! 🚨
Before we even get to the pizza, we have to address the security situation. Or should we say… the complete lack of one. 😂
Y’all, we walked around back and discovered the entire establishment appears to be protected by what can only be described as the same latch holding your grandma’s garden shed closed. 🔒🤣
At that point we weren’t sure if we were reviewing a pizzeria or contemplating a career change as highly unsuccessful burglars.
The good news? Nobody’s breaking in for the cash. The bad news? After tasting the food, they might be breaking in for the pizza. 🍕👀
Did Goombah’s earn its place in the SWFL pizza conversation? Find out tonight at 6PM when the full review drops!

06/17/2026

Frfr 🤌🏼🔥🍕📈🙏🏼🌴🫡

Chicken Parm Ah-Beetz — it's special-priced today only. 🍕House chicken cutlets, our Grande east coast cheese, Fresh Mozz...
06/13/2026

Chicken Parm Ah-Beetz — it's special-priced today only. 🍕
House chicken cutlets, our Grande east coast cheese, Fresh Mozzarella, our new Ol' Skool sauce, and fresh basil on that wild-yeast crust you already know and love.
Today only:
18" — $20
16" — $18
14" — $16
Call it in, Cash only. Limited — order before it's gone.
📍 The Goombah Pizzaiolo, Cape Coral

Ayo Goombah's 🚨🚨TEASER ALERT🚨🚨We decided to really hone in our back alley vibe so our menus will be getting a new look a...
06/11/2026

Ayo Goombah's

🚨🚨TEASER ALERT🚨🚨

We decided to really hone in our back alley vibe so our menus will be getting a new look as well as adding a few options. These changes will make it to where and we are proud to say that every last item on this menu is made in house even down to the boneless wings which anyone in the industry would know is hard to come by.

You will also notice a lunch special menu. This will have a 3 hour window. 12pm to 3pm.

Again this is not up and running yet but we will have it solidified into our systems and online ordering after Fathers Day.

That is all. 🤌🏼🫶🏼🔥🍕📈🏅🥇🙏🏼🌴

Pro tip...If you want to have the Ol' Skool sauce on your pie you have to let us know. Its an option, its not just autom...
06/06/2026

Pro tip...

If you want to have the Ol' Skool sauce on your pie you have to let us know. Its an option, its not just automatically applied. 🤌🏼🫶🏼

No jars. No shortcuts. No apologies.Introducing Ol' Skool — our scratch tomato sauce made the way it was always supposed...
06/04/2026

No jars. No shortcuts. No apologies.
Introducing Ol' Skool — our scratch tomato sauce made the way it was always supposed to be made.
Fresh tomato. Fresh basil. Real garlic. Extra virgin olive oil. A pinch of salt.
Five ingredients. That's the whole list. No "natural flavors." No stabilizers. No fine print.
This is what sauce looked like before the corporations showed up and ruined everything. We're just keeping it honest.
Ol' Skool. Because some things were right the first time. 🍅
We made this for the people that like their sauce with no sweetness attached to it. Think Birdies/Leones remix. 🤌🏼

🍕 We need your opinion, Goombah fam! 🤌🏼We've been thinking about throwing our peel in the ring and entering some pizza c...
05/30/2026

🍕 We need your opinion, Goombah fam! 🤌🏼

We've been thinking about throwing our peel in the ring and entering some pizza competitions. The Pizza Tomorrow Summit 🏆
Should we do it? 🏅🥇

🔥 = YES — go show 'em what Cape Coral is made of!

👎🏼 = NAH — just keep doing your thing

Drop your vote in the comments below! 👇

Address

850 Lafayette Street
Cape Coral, FL
33904

Telephone

+12397704352

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Goombah Pizzaiolo posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to The Goombah Pizzaiolo:

Shortcuts

Share

Category