08/27/2026
Today is Thankful Thursday!! Here are some snippets from some of our most loyal regulars--what they order, what they love about the West Side, and a little of what they love about us!
Alicia loves a NY style red sauce jalapeño pie--spicy and simple! She loves that the West Side is home to her and to so many interesting neighbors. Alicia recommends coming to Extra Extra ready to have fun (we agree)
The Smiths are a family of simple pleasures: plain cheese, pepperoni, a cheesy garlic bread, and some bubbly grape soda (and a bottle of red for mom + dad). They are all about our care for the community and our customers--they are often one and the same!!
Dave loves anything Sicilian--especially the #1 (pepperoni, pickled jalapeño, hot maple). He also loves being in walking distance of his "caffeine, carbs, and goodies." His favorite part of Extra Extra? Our cooperative business practices--no tips allowed!!
Pedro and Emily are long-time repeat guests--a #15, a cola, and a glass of white wine make for their favorite meal here! They love our unfussy, kind service, and they recommend a visit if you love places that are busy (in a good way!!)
Darius will always order a Sicilian pie with sweet peppers and he WILL top it generously with our tableside red pepper flakes--customization is the name of his game!! He loves the Five Points (don't we all?) and he loves a well done pie just as much♨️
Keila is another West Sider who has supported us from the day one! Contrary to our pizza-loving people, Keila loves the meatballs and bread and butter! She also loves that the West Side is full of people who look out for each other💗
Matt is a dual pie orderer--a vodka sauce pie with cup n char pepperoni + a white pie with ricotta (never forget the ricotta). Matt loves the vibrant, youthful feel of the West Side and the microcosm of small businesses that feed the locals
The Bostocks!! Perhaps our most notable regulars--lovers of our salad, cheese pizza, and ice cream!!! Little Jane proudly proclaims that ours is the ONLY pizza she eats (💁🏻♀️) and mom thinks we have a great wine program (she's right💁🏻♀️💁🏻♀️💁🏻♀️)
Have a favorite order?? Share it in the comments!!
