Extra Extra

Extra Extra New York style Pizzeria
(1)

We get asked this question all the time, and truly the best way is to see them side by side! We think that a medium is g...
06/20/2026

We get asked this question all the time, and truly the best way is to see them side by side! We think that a medium is good for 1-2 people, a large for 2-4, and a Sicilian 3-4 people. Make sure you order enough for leftovers too 😋

Join us for another goofy Kids Lunch! Full menu available🍕🍦
06/15/2026

Join us for another goofy Kids Lunch! Full menu available🍕🍦

Lets give it up for 🌶️Lil Miss Chili Relish🌶️Featuring Calabrian chili peppers, onion and garlic, this sauce does it all...
06/10/2026

Lets give it up for 🌶️Lil Miss Chili Relish🌶️

Featuring Calabrian chili peppers, onion and garlic, this sauce does it all. Add it to a cheese slice, as the base in Pizza #11, or take some home for your cold cut sandwiches and scrambled eggs😜

We wanted to make a hot sauce that is spicy AND flavorful, but be mindful— the heat really does build, so go slow!

What’s your fav way to chili relish???🔥🔥🔥

Thai Tea and coconut lime had a short but beloved time with usEnjoy the last few swirls in a pint at home!Order online a...
06/01/2026

Thai Tea and coconut lime had a short but beloved time with us
Enjoy the last few swirls in a pint at home!
Order online at extraextrapizza.com (link in bio 🍋‍🟩🧡)

Drink # 57: Sangria Saturday🍷🍊🍋🍋‍🟩This iteration features a light cheerful southern French Grenache with some cognac an...
05/30/2026

Drink # 57: Sangria Saturday🍷🍊🍋🍋‍🟩

This iteration features a light cheerful southern French Grenache with some cognac and all the sunny citrus

Each glass of Sangria sold this afternoon comes with one hot take from Bridget on the Summer House Reunion

Patio? Patio.☀️🌳🌻🍃🍕🍷Please note— our patio does NOT allow dogs, and closes 1 hour prior to restaurant closing. First com...
05/29/2026

Patio? Patio.
☀️🌳🌻🍃🍕🍷

Please note— our patio does NOT allow dogs, and closes 1 hour prior to restaurant closing. First come, first serve (obv) and no parties larger than 4!

Don’t judge a pizza by its roundness!!! This Sunday, worker-owner Joey is teaching the next generation of Extra’s Extras...
05/27/2026

Don’t judge a pizza by its roundness!!!

This Sunday, worker-owner Joey is teaching the next generation of Extra’s Extras how to stretch, top, and launch a pie. Why are we telling you this? Because there will be a LOT of cheese pizzas, some with a bit of a unique shape.

Instead of throwing this pizza away, we’ll be selling them to you, for a $5 or $10 donation to Cooperation Buffalo! has been an invaluable partner to us since the inception of the business, and are a cornerstone to the co-op community in Buffalo.

The orders will go live on Sunday morning, and we are capping it at 2 pizzas per order so that everyone can get some🍕

See you Sunday!

🚨PLANT BASED BADDIES TO THE FRONT🚨We’ve seen the quiet disappointment on your faces as we describe our delicious soft se...
05/11/2026

🚨PLANT BASED BADDIES TO THE FRONT🚨

We’ve seen the quiet disappointment on your faces as we describe our delicious soft serve flavors, so Jill has been hard at work making something ✨just✨for✨YOU✨

This treat features coconut milk ice cream in between 2 citrus sugar cookies! Serving coconut lime realness with no tummy ache afterwards🍊🍋🍋‍🟩🥥

$7 while supplies lasts!

Did any other parents look at the calendar for the week ahead and realize that BPS is off again? 🙋‍♀️we can help! Join u...
05/11/2026

Did any other parents look at the calendar for the week ahead and realize that BPS is off again? 🙋‍♀️we can help!

Join us once again for a silly, saucy, goofy, extra cheesy kids lunch this Friday May 16th. Plenty of slices, and adult bevs too 🫗

If it’s nice we’ll have some chalk out, and I’m sure DJ Junie Pucc will have some Disney Hits bumpin for an impromptu dance party🕺🏻🕺🏻

Protein/fiber-maxxing, Extra Extra StylePizza #24 features prosciutto cotto (fancy Italian ham), sweet peas, and lots o...
05/07/2026

Protein/fiber-maxxing, Extra Extra Style

Pizza #24 features prosciutto cotto (fancy Italian ham), sweet peas, and lots of fresh grated Grana Padano cheese with black pepper.
Sweet+salty, simple + delish!
🍖🫛🧀

(No cottage cheese was blended or harmed in the making of this pizza)

Address

549 West Utica
Buffalo, NY
14213

Opening Hours

Monday 5pm - 10pm
Wednesday 5pm - 10pm
Thursday 5pm - 10pm
Friday 12pm - 10pm
Saturday 12pm - 10pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Extra Extra posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to Extra Extra:

Shortcuts

Share

Category