Mythical Pizza

Call Directions Website

Mythical Pizza At MYTHICAL PIZZA, we have a passion for pizza.
(1)

Our flash-fired pizza brings a new feeling to the quick-dine experience, and it allows our mythical customers to take full control!

Berkeley Springs, WV’s 51st Apple Butter Festival is here, and we HAD to get Apple Butter onto a pizza. Actually… we mad...
10/08/2026

Berkeley Springs, WV’s 51st Apple Butter Festival is here, and we HAD to get Apple Butter onto a pizza. Actually… we made two!! 🍎🍕

Now it’s SWEET vs. SAVORY, and you get to pick your favorite!

🍪 For our SWEET, it's "Mothman’s Apple Butter Crunch" - Our 10" Sweet Pizza brings Apple Butter, creamy Ricotta, crushed Gingersnaps, and a dusting of Powdered Sugar. Dessert’s covered for $12!

🥓 And for our SAVORY, it's "Bigfoot’s Orchard Raid" - Our 10" Savory Pizza includes Apple Butter, Mozzarella AND Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Bacon, Ham, and Red Onion with our Sasquatch Edge, and finished with a Barbecue Drizzle, and a Parmesan Sprinkle!! You’ve got a savory Fall pizza for $15!

Or if you're really hungry for some Fall Fun, try BOTH for only $25 (that's a $2 savings!)

Please note: Both come in a 10" size only!

Available Friday, Saturday, and if we still have supplies, Monday!! Don't forget, we are closed Sunday!

Enjoy the festival, then stop by Mythical for a LEGENDARY bite. Which one are you trying first? 👇

It’s Wing Wednesday, and wings are just $0.75 each in orders of 10! 🍗🔥 Grab your favorite wing buddy, swoop in like Moth...
10/07/2026

It’s Wing Wednesday, and wings are just $0.75 each in orders of 10! 🍗🔥 Grab your favorite wing buddy, swoop in like Mothman, and get those claws on dinner. Even Bigfoot’s coming out of hiding for this one! 👣😂

Come hungry, leave saucy, and make your Wednesday LEGENDARY! We’re open ’til 9PM, so come hang out and feed that monster appetite!

We’ve got dinner covered at Mythical Pizza! 🍕👣 Hurry in for your favorites and feed that monster appetite. We’re open ’t...
10/06/2026

We’ve got dinner covered at Mythical Pizza! 🍕👣 Hurry in for your favorites and feed that monster appetite. We’re open ’til 9PM tonight, so there’s still time to make dinner LEGENDARY! 🔥

There is just something LEGENDARY about Mike’s Hot Honey on a pizza!! 🍕🔥🍯This Stand By Meat got the sweet-heat treatment...
10/05/2026

There is just something LEGENDARY about Mike’s Hot Honey on a pizza!! 🍕🔥🍯

This Stand By Meat got the sweet-heat treatment, and it is absolutely delicious!! That drizzle adds a little kick, a little sweetness, and the kind of flavor that keeps you coming back for another bite...

Who else is adding Mike’s Hot Honey to their next pie!? 👀

After a fierce Round 3 re-battle between Yeti’s Campfire S’more and Banshee Apple Crumble, we finally have a winner! 🍕🏆I...
10/05/2026

After a fierce Round 3 re-battle between Yeti’s Campfire S’more and Banshee Apple Crumble, we finally have a winner! 🍕🏆

If you recall, these dessert pies were TIED as of Thursday. But after a flood of orders on Friday and Saturday, the final vote is in...
.
.
.
.
.
.

NATALIE KIDWELL’S YETI’S CAMPFIRE S’MORE takes Round 3! 🎉🍫🔥

Chocolate, marshmallows, and graham cracker crumble pushed this contender across the finish line. Congratulations, Natalie!

This week, we are closing the Round 3 brackets and refilling supplies. Then, starting NEXT MONDAY, the bracket winners go head-to-head as we narrow down the LEGENDARY Pie Hunt. Who will reign supreme? 👀

Homecoming Weekend brings the whole crew to town! 🏈🍕 Kids, parents, extended family, old friends, and plenty of hungry v...
10/02/2026

Homecoming Weekend brings the whole crew to town! 🏈🍕 Kids, parents, extended family, old friends, and plenty of hungry visitors are all looking for a meal they can share.

For first-time Mythical Pizza guests, choosing can be tough. There are so many LEGENDARY topping choices, and every Signature Pie sounds good enough to try.

That is why we created the FLIGHT OF THE SQUONKS! Pick any THREE Signature Pies and sample more than one favorite in a single order. Our award-winning Flight of the Squonks has even sparked conversations between our Senior Management team and some larger companies.

People order them as a shareable snack, a Signature Pie test run, a full meal, or an easy way to feed a group of kids or older family members. Mozzarella Monsters and Yeti’s Pepperoni Pies are both on the list, too!

Not sure which Signature Pie is your favorite? Try three, find your go-to, and expand your palate this Homecoming Weekend! ✨

It’s OCTOBER, which means Halloween is only a few weeks away! 🎃👻Our extremely limited Hazy Dell Halloween Coloring Books...
10/02/2026

It’s OCTOBER, which means Halloween is only a few weeks away! 🎃👻

Our extremely limited Hazy Dell Halloween Coloring Books are out today at Mythical Pizza! They are perfect for adding a little spooky fun to your October, whether you are coloring at home, sharing with the kids, or putting one aside for a fellow cryptid fan.

Come by and grab yours while they are here. Once our supply is gone, we will not be able to get more! Make this Halloween season LEGENDARY!! 🍕✨

Hold on a second...... This LEGENDARY PIE HUNT battle is headed toward ANOTHER TIE! 🚨🍕⚔️It is Thursday afternoon, the ba...
10/01/2026

Hold on a second...... This LEGENDARY PIE HUNT battle is headed toward ANOTHER TIE! 🚨🍕⚔️

It is Thursday afternoon, the battle ends Saturday, and Banshee Apple Crumble and Yeti’s Campfire S’more are once again locked in a DEAD HEAT! We just pulled our latest system report to see which of these LEGENDARY PIE creations is ahead this week, and .... it's currently another tie!!!

Will Brandie Walter’s Banshee Apple Crumble take the crown with apple pie filling, brown sugar and cinnamon crumble, plus a caramel drizzle after bake? 🍎🍯

Or will Natalie Kidwell’s Yeti’s Campfire S’more melt the competition with chocolate, marshmallows, and graham cracker crumble? 🍫🔥

These dessert pies tied just a few weeks ago. Do not let this showdown end the same way!

YOUR ORDER IS YOUR VOTE. Pick your favorite. Bring your crew. Get your pie before we close Saturday and help us crown a winner! 🏆

OCTOBER IS HERE, and it is time to start the Fall season with something seriously LEGENDARY! 🍂🍕🔥Remember the French Brea...
10/01/2026

OCTOBER IS HERE, and it is time to start the Fall season with something seriously LEGENDARY! 🍂🍕🔥

Remember the French Bread Pizzas from childhood? That crispy outside. That soft, warm bread inside. That first bite that made you forget everything else on your plate??

Now imagine that feeling built exactly the way YOU want it!!

Choose your sauce. Pick your cheeses. Load up the meats and veggies. Add your favorite drizzle. Our 10" French Bread Pizzas take that classic comfort-food memory and let you turn it into your own full-on pizza creation!! 🤤

Classic and cheesy? Go for it! Spicy and loaded? Do it! Sweet heat, extra meat, or all the toppings? Make it happen!

Get in here, bring your appetite, and start October with a French Bread Pizza worth talking about. Our Mythical Crew is here until 10PM! ✨

Happy Wednesday, our pizza loving customers! 🍕🙌You make our days better just by walking through the door, and we are rea...
09/30/2026

Happy Wednesday, our pizza loving customers! 🍕🙌

You make our days better just by walking through the door, and we are ready to help make your day awesome!

Stopping in for lunch? We have you covered. Gathering the crew for dinner? We are ready for that too. Grab your favorite Signature Pie, build your custom creation, or dig into a Breaker, Kraken's Pasta Bowls, Momma or Baby Nessie Salad, or one of our delicious desserts.

Thank you for making Mythical Pizza part of your day. Come see us and make this Wednesday LEGENDARY! ✨

Address

1855 Valley Road, Suite #200
Berkeley Springs, WV
25411

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am - 9pm
Tuesday 11:30am - 9pm
Wednesday 11:30am - 9pm
Thursday 11:30am - 10pm
Friday 11:30am - 10pm
Saturday 11:30am - 10pm

Telephone

+13044026984

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mythical Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category