The Fish Store

Call Directions Website Contact the restaurant

The Fish Store The Fish Store is home to Long Island's freshest seafood market and restaurant. Along with great customer service - it is a combination that can't be beat.
(283)

Whether cooking yourself, grabbing to go or sitting down to a delicious freshly prepared meal in our dining room - our food and friendly staff will be sure to please. Started in 1978, this family business is located in the center of Bayport on the corner of Montauk Highway and Bayport Avenue. The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, dining in our new restaurant, catering and more. Through our commitment, experience and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime! The Fish Store is a proud member of the Bayport-Blue Point Chamber of Commerce.

CHICKEN WINGS! Yes from The Fish Store!Choice of Buffalo, Barbecue, or Thai ChiliWings (1/2 Pan).........$49.99Wings (F...
10/15/2026

CHICKEN WINGS! Yes from The Fish Store!

Choice of Buffalo, Barbecue, or Thai Chili
Wings (1/2 Pan).........$49.99
Wings (Full Pan)........$99.99
Boneless (1/2 Pan)......$59.99
Boneless (Full Pan)......$119.99

Chicken Fingers Also Available!
1/2 Pan..........$31.99
Full Pan..........$59.99

Just out of the oven - LOBSTER Pot Pie! Extremely limited and will sell out! Call 631-472-3018 to order!
10/15/2026

Just out of the oven - LOBSTER Pot Pie! Extremely limited and will sell out! Call 631-472-3018 to order!

Don't forget to vote for The Fish Store as best fish market on all of Long Island everyday! Thank you and here is the l...
10/14/2026

Don't forget to vote for The Fish Store as best fish market on all of Long Island everyday! Thank you and here is the link -
https://www.bestoflongisland.com/voting/ #/gallery?group=560635

Honored to be nominated for Best of Long Island! You helped us win it for 12 years - let's go for 13. Just click on th...
10/12/2026

Honored to be nominated for Best of Long Island! You helped us win it for 12 years - let's go for 13. Just click on this link, go under category of "Food", then find us under "Fish Market". You must put your email address in only once.
https://www.bestoflongisland.com/voting/

Come dine with us this weekend!📸: Joseph Leon
10/09/2026

Come dine with us this weekend!
📸: Joseph Leon

Pumpkin bisque with marshmallow croutons. Dine in or take out - you must get this seasonal deliciousness!
10/07/2026

Pumpkin bisque with marshmallow croutons. Dine in or take out - you must get this seasonal deliciousness!

Ugh Monday! What's for dinner? Our Bundle Dinner - with enough to feed whole family! Call now to order 631-472-3018. ...
10/05/2026

Ugh Monday! What's for dinner? Our Bundle Dinner - with enough to feed whole family! Call now to order 631-472-3018. $49.99 for salad, baked clams, loaf of garlic bread and your choice side and entree. Available Monday - Thursday to make dinner easy and delicious!

You need to do this! Sushi all day and night on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays only. And always freshly prepared.
10/01/2026

You need to do this! Sushi all day and night on Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays only. And always freshly prepared.

Look at all this food in our Bundle Dinner! Plenty, delicious and easy on the wallet! Our Back to School Bundle is $49...
09/29/2026

Look at all this food in our Bundle Dinner! Plenty, delicious and easy on the wallet! Our Back to School Bundle is $49.99 and available Monday - Thursday. Please call ahead and allow 30 minutes to prepare 631-472-3018. What do you get?
* 1/2 pan Caesar salad
* 8 baked clams
* 1 loaf of garlic bread
* Your choice of sides - 1/2 pan penne ala vodka, mac & cheese of fries
* Your choice of entree - broiled salmon, fried flounder, grilled marinated chicken or 1/2 pan of chicken fingers

Congrats to the Phantoms for just winning homecoming over Babylon 23-0!
09/29/2026

Congrats to the Phantoms for just winning homecoming over Babylon 23-0!

Address

836 Montauk Highway
Bayport, NY
11705

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 7pm
Tuesday 9am - 8pm
Wednesday 9am - 8pm
Thursday 9am - 8pm
Friday 9am - 9pm
Saturday 9am - 9pm
Sunday 9am - 7pm

Telephone

(631) 472-3018

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Fish Store posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to The Fish Store:

Shortcuts

Share