The Buttertart Shack

The Buttertart Shack The Buttertart Shack is exclusively about buttertarts. We take pride in making many different styles
(1)

10/02/2026

New signage!!!! Town of Niagara-on-the-Lake (Virgil) 1486 Niagara Stone Road. Coffee coming soon!!! Maybe a savoury pie….? Who knows!!! ButterTartShackUS Buttertartshackcalgary Geoff Black Brendan Dickson Brandon Christian Pumpkin pie tarts now available!!!

10/02/2026

Caledonia Fair🐮🎡 this weekend, we will have pumpkin pie Buttertarts!!!
City of Port Colborne Olga Loeffen portcolbornefarmersmarket Buttertartshackcalgary Geoff Black Brendan Dickson Brandon Christian

10/02/2026

Pumpkin pie tarts now available!!!!

Only here till Thanksgiving weekend!!!

Port Colborne Farmers' Market Port Colborne Main Street BIA The Buttertart Shack Calgary Geoff Black Brendan Dickson Brandon Christian
At Port Colborne shop today and Caledonia Fair

09/26/2026

Summit Station Dairy Geoff Black Brendan Dickson Buttertartshackcalgary Brandon Christian Ancaster Agricultural Society | Ancaster Fair

09/26/2026

Ancaster Agricultural Society | Ancaster Fair !!! We are here Saturday and Sunday.
Geoff Black Brendan Dickson Buttertartshackcalgary Brandon Christian City of Port Colborne

08/30/2026

Thank you Events Connected Canada at Niagara Pen Centre for an awesome Buttertart event!!!

Sold out here besides 15 raspberry coconut and sold out at our Virgil shop.

See you next week!!!

Jason Young Geoff Black Brandon Christian Port Colborne Main Street BIA Brendan Dickson The Buttertart Shack Calgary Port Colborne Farmers' Market

08/29/2026

What’s up Niagara Pen Centre and Events Connected Canada, come get your Buttertarts at the Niagara Buttertart festival!!!

Saturday and Sunday.

Jason Young Geoff Black Brandon Christian Port Colborne Main Street BIA Brendan Dickson The Buttertart Shack Calgary Mainly Niagara

08/28/2026

Schedule until Christmas

Markets

Dunnville Farmers Market Tuesday 2-7
Grimsby Farmers' Market Thursday 2-7
Port Colborne Farmers' Market Friday 7-12

Events

Events Connected Canada Niagara Pen Centre Buttertart festival Aug 29/30

West Niagara Agricultural Society West Niagara fair September 11-13th

Get Lost fall market at Sons and daughters winery September 19/20

Love of Local Markets Ancaster fair market September 26/27

Caledonia Fair Oct 1-4

Vineland Artfest Oct 10-12 (thanksgiving weekend)

NOTL food festival Niagara College NOTL campus Oct 16/17

ALL Canadian Events Paris Buttertart festival Oct 24/25th

Oct 31st my birthday (cool Halloween flavors at both shops)

Gotta Luv Butter Tart Festivals Christmas market at Burlington Centre Nov 7th

Events Connected Christmas market at Pen centre Nov 14th

Halton Buttertart Festival Sunday Nov 22nd

Reif Estate Winery holiday market Dec 5th

Events connected Christmas market Pen centre Dec 5

Events connected Christmas market Club Roma Sunday Dec 20th

Both shops at Christmas will be taking preorders starting in November until Friday December 14th. Pickups will be available at both shops from Monday Dec 21st to Wednesday December 23rd. Our shops will be open for the holidays for these extended hours:

Thursday December 17th until Wednesday Dec 23rd from 10-7pm

335 Wellington street
1486 Niagara stone Road

Closed Dec 24th until January 1st. Then reopen Saturday January 2nd.

Jason Young Geoff Black Brandon Christian Port Colborne Main Street BIA Brendan Dickson The Buttertart Shack Calgary

08/27/2026

Address

335 Wellington Street
Port Colborne, ON
L3K2Z1

Opening Hours

Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 7pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Telephone

+19053942462

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Buttertart Shack posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Restaurant

Send a message to The Buttertart Shack:

Shortcuts

Share

Category