Fenwick Pie Company

10/12/2026

Happy Thanksgiving!!! 🦃

Thank you so much to all of our customers for your orders this week and honestly for all the weeks. Your continued support over the years means so much to us and we are so grateful for each and every one of you! 🧡

We hope everyone had an amazing Thanksgiving weekend!

Y'all definitely showed us the love and we have decided to close Tuesday and Wednesday this week for a little extra rest.

Thank you again for all your love and see you Thursday!

🥧🧡

09/27/2026

Thanksgiving is almost here and we are ready for you!!

We will have extended hours this Thanksgiving weekend to accommodate everyone's different schedules! We will also be open Sunday October 11th for order pick ups only 9am to 1pm.

We highly recommend placing an order as thanksgiving is a busy busy time and we focus our energy on pre orders before stocking our store! So please order online or call the shop before our deadline Wednesday October 7th!

Thank you so much for your love and can't wait to see you all this Thanksgiving 🧡

09/15/2026

Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers are back in stock and now with options!!!

We have added a family size 5 pack of peppers for only $25!

So now you can get our regular 2 pack or our 5 pack, whichever suits your family more!

These never last long in our freezer, so come get'em while supplies last!

09/10/2026

Apple pies and Apple Crumbles are back in stock!

These ones are fresh out of the oven if anyone was wanting hot apple pie for lunch?

09/09/2026

We have so many things this morning!

Open until 5pm!

Classic Reuben and we have added a Ham and Swiss melt for lunch today!

Apple pies are coming this afternoon!

Happy Wednesday 💕

09/08/2026

Today is a sad day at the Fenwick Pie Company...

For those of you who have been around for a while have probably had the pleasure of meeting our wonderful .

Makenna started here back in 2021 at just 15 years old in the middle of crazy COVID days as a dish washer.

Over the last 5 years she has grown to be so much more than that. She has become a literal extension of myself. Anything I have thrown at her she doesn't just conquer it, she masters it. She has done it all here and understands the flow of this place better than me sometimes!

Over the last 5 years we have all watched Makenna grow into a wonderful, caring and extremely hard working young lady and we are so grateful to have had her by our side for this ride!

As she heads into her final year of university to become an AMAZING nurse she has decided to step back from the bakery to solely focus on her school.

We want to wish Makenna an amazing last year of school and wish her all the best on her future endeavors.

If you want to see Makenna off please stop by the shop today as it is her last day with us. 😭💔

We are open 11-4!

09/04/2026

Fenwick, we are so back!!

The ladies worked INCREDIBLY hard this week to get ALMOST everything back in stock for this long weekend.

Thank you again to everyone who came and showed us so much love. So grateful to have all the support. This community ROCKS! And so does our team! Thank you Makenna and Lesley!

Have an amazing long weekend and see you tomorrow, Saturday 10-5 and at the Welland Farmers’ Market from 8-12!

🥰🙏🙌

08/25/2026

I guess we can't have anything exciting happen without a little bad...

Majorly discounted meals available today
...

08/25/2026

Something exciting has arrived at Fenwick Pies!

One of the most asked questions we get is "do you sell ice cream?" Truthfully, pie and ice cream almost belong together, so why don't we sell ice cream??

SO! We have FINALLY listened and we are VERY excited to announce that starting tomorrow you can now purchase a pint of locally hand made ice cream right here in our shop!

We have teamed up with our good friend Simon Says who makes small batch, real ice cream with real, local ingredients!

To celebrate this collaboration, starting tomorrow when you purchase any sweet pie and a pint, receive 10% off the bundle!

Our first flavours available will be:
Vanilla
Chocolate
Salty caramel

Please note that the ice cream will ONLY be available per pint in our grab and go freezers to be enjoyed at home. We will not be offering any scoops or cones in our shop. You'll have to go find Simon at one of his events for that!

Who's excited for this addition to our shop and which flavour will you try first??

08/18/2026