Sugar Kay

Sugar Kay Custom cookies, cakes, cupcakes, and more!

The last of my orders went out this past weekend. It was a very busy graduation season! Happy summer everyone 🌞I will po...
06/15/2026

The last of my orders went out this past weekend. It was a very busy graduation season! Happy summer everyone 🌞
I will post when I am accepting orders again- which I expect to be mid to late August

Hi everyone! I wanted to give a quick update regarding cookie/cake orders. At this time, I am not accepting any new orde...
05/19/2026

Hi everyone! I wanted to give a quick update regarding cookie/cake orders. At this time, I am not accepting any new orders as I focus on fulfilling several large upcoming orders and preparing for maternity leave. (Again, this is for NEW orders only. If I have already confirmed your order we are still good for that!)
I plan to reopen orders around August (or later). Thank you all so much for your continued support, patience, and understanding. I will post when I am accepting orders again.

Mother's Day Pre-orders 🩷Pricing info under pictures. Comment or message me to place an order!
04/30/2026

Mother's Day Pre-orders 🩷
Pricing info under pictures. Comment or message me to place an order!

Super cute cookies to celebrate some sweet babies!
04/30/2026

Super cute cookies to celebrate some sweet babies!

Graduation is right around the corner! Don't forget to get your order placed to celebrate your favorite grad! Custom coo...
04/20/2026

Graduation is right around the corner! Don't forget to get your order placed to celebrate your favorite grad! Custom cookies, cupcakes, and cookie cakes.

Don't forget to get your Easter orders placed!
03/31/2026

Don't forget to get your Easter orders placed!

Easter Pre Orders 🐰Message me to get your order placed!
03/16/2026

Easter Pre Orders 🐰
Message me to get your order placed!

Valentines Orders/Inspo PicsInfo listed under each picture. I also have availability for custom cakes (vintage piping he...
01/29/2026

Valentines Orders/Inspo Pics
Info listed under each picture. I also have availability for custom cakes (vintage piping heart cakes would be perfect for valentine's day!!) and can do customizable cookie cakes.
Comment or message me to place an order

I will be working on specials for Valentines Day in the next couple weeks! Send me a message if you are in need of sweet...
01/04/2026

I will be working on specials for Valentines Day in the next couple weeks!
Send me a message if you are in need of sweet treats for your special person!

12/12/2025

A day late but I promise I didn't forget! Thank you to everyone who shared my Christmas post and ordered something!
The winner of the cookie giveaway, drawn at random is Teresa Hackworth!
Again, thank you everyone for your continued support.

Address

Shelbyville, IN

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Kay posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category