My Sweet Valentine Bakery

10/16/2026

Twenty One Pilots cookies for a birthday celebration before their home show at The Shoe this Saturday! ❤️💛💙

How fun is this?! Who’s heading to the show this weekend?! 🙌🏼

Thanks for letting My Sweet Valentine Bakery be a little part of the celebration! 🖤

10/15/2026

Pretty in purple 💜🌸 Buttercream roses, vintage piping, and the sweetest details for a special 80th birthday!

Custom cakes are one of our favorite things to make. Thank you for letting My Sweet Valentine Bakery be part of your celebrations! 🎂

10/15/2026

10/12/2026

🤍 A beautiful two-tier wedding cake for a special day! 💍

This cake featured an 8” white almond cake with raspberry filling on top and a 10” spice cake on the bottom, finished with classic white buttercream and delicate rustic details.

Thank you so much for choosing My Sweet Valentine Bakery to be a small part of your big day! Wishing you both a lifetime of love, happiness, and the sweetest memories together. Congratulations to the happy couple! 🤍✨

10/04/2026

A little pink vintage birthday cake for Rayne’s 7th birthday! 🎀💗

We had so much fun with all the pretty pinks, vintage piping, roses, pearls and that sweet little bow! 🥰

Happy 7th Birthday, Rayne! We hope you had the sweetest birthday! 💕🎂

✨ Made by My Sweet Valentine Bakery ✨

Looking for a custom cake for your next celebration? Send us a message — we’d love to make something special for you! 💗

10/02/2026

A little sneak peak.. 🧁👻 Stop by and get your treats tonight at Bessie Benson Park in Carroll.

10/02/2026

🎃 A LITTLE WEATHER UPDATE FOR TONIGHT! 🎃

Unfortunately, due to the weather and park conditions, the full Pumpkins & Painting Under the Stars event may not be able to happen tonight. 😭

BUT — we still have ALL the treats we made, and we’re bringing them with us! 💕 So we will still be at Bessie Benson Park from 6:00–6:30 PM with our bakery table set up!

We’ll have:

🧁 Specialty Cupcakes
🍪 Frosted Sugar Cookies
🍪 Holiday Sprinkle Chocolate Chip Cookies
🥨 Bags of 3 Pretzel Sticks

$3 each or 3 for $8 — while supplies last!

These treats will be available for pickup at the event today, or if you can’t make it out tonight, we can arrange a scheduled pickup in Pickerington or Thornville.

We’ve been baking all day getting everything ready, so we would LOVE to see some friendly faces and send these goodies home with you! 🩷

Thank you so much for supporting our little mom-and-daughter bakery. We appreciate you more than you know! 🎃💕

10/01/2026

COOKIE CAKE SEASON IS HERE! 🍪

Football birthdays, game days, team parties… we’ve got you covered! 🏈

This chocolate chip cookie cake was made for a football-loving birthday boy, complete with all the football details. And yes, the entire thing is a giant, soft, chocolate chip cookie. 😍

Cookie cakes can be customized for any theme, team, birthday or celebration!

09/20/2026

Made for a special cause 🤎
Auctioned to benefit Ride for FairHope Hospice.

09/20/2026

Okay THIS cake 😍

Chocolate cake + peanut butter buttercream + Hershey chocolate shavings + our specialty Buckeyes?! Omg. This one is a chocolate & peanut butter lover’s dream. 🤎🥜

And we love that this cake was auctioned off by one of our customers to help raise money for Ride for FairHope Hospice. What a sweet way to enjoy some cake while supporting such a meaningful cause. ❤️

Thank you for choosing My Sweet Valentine Bakery to be a part of it! 🧁